Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article

Home > News > Report

DDA scam: Delhi high court ex-judge
gets bail on medical grounds

Onkar Singh in New Delhi | May 05, 2003 17:14 IST

The Delhi High Court on Monday granted one month's interim bail to its former judge Shameet Mukherjee on medical grounds after May 7 when his police custody expires.

Mukherjee was arrested on April 30 in connection with the Delhi Development Authority land scam.

Justice R C Chopra passed this order after hearing arguments on behalf of the petitioner and the Central Bureau of Investigation for over one-and-a-half hours in a packed court room.

"His bail petition is rejected. However, he is granted interim bail for a period of one month from the date of expiry of the police remand on May 7. He would have to furnish a personal bond of Rs 50,000," the judge said in his order.

"We are happy with the relief our client has been given," said Dinesh Mathur who argued the case on behalf of Mukherjee.

Asked if the CBI would approach the Supreme Court against the order, Additional Solicitor General R N Trivedi said it was too early to say anything on this matter.

Earlier, Dinesh Mathur argued that the CBI has arrested Mukherjee on flimsy grounds.

The so-called copies of judgments recovered from accused Ashok Kapur and Dharam Vir Khattar was not a copy but merely a draft of the actual judgment.

"No case is made out against my client wherein the CBI could show that he has benefited monetarily. The case of Azad Singh vs CBI is pending before the division bench of the Delhi High Court and will come up for hearing on May 15."

"So where is the question of the judgment giving benefit to any party. The CBI only talks of Khattar providing wine and women, but that does not come under the Prevention of Corruption Act," Mathur said.

"Mukherjee has an ailing wife to look after, a son who studies in Kolkata and a daughter who studies in the 8th standard. We are pleading for granting of bail on medical grounds," he said.

Opposing bail, Trivedi said since this was a prestigious case, any order would have greater ramifications.

"The higher the status of the person involved in a case, the greater are his responsibilities. The remand of the accused finishes on May 7 and so he should be denied bail. We need to bring him face to face with other accused persons arrested in the case," he said.

The judge asked the CBI if it had enough evidence to link the judge to the other accused and whether he got any benefit for passing judgments favourable to Vinod Khatri, owner of a restaurant in Vasant Kunj in south Delhi.

To this, Trivedi offered to play the recorded conversations between Mukherjee and the accused in the judge's chamber.

More reports from Delhi
Read about: Assembly Election 2003 | Attack on Parliament

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 5

Sub: Bail to the ex judge

The judgement of the Delhi HC granting the bail to the Ex Judge is very right as the bail has been given only on the ...

Posted by shekharvyas

Sub: High Court Judge gets bail

This is witch hunting. The Police gets a sadistic pleasure in seeing persons in senior postions in custody wheras they Hundreds of accuseds in more ...

Posted by Lt Col BR Mahotra (Retd)

Sub: delhi hc ex-judge gets bail

it is well known that judge knows all the loopholes of the law why CBI is wasting its time to catch these persons. Sometime, while ...

Posted by dara

Sub: delhi hc judge gets bail

It was not necessary to arrest the judge. The cbi should have been asked by the the court to demonstrate as to why the investigation ...

Posted by mad tail

Sub: bail to judge

This decision clearly shows the difference between a ordinary citizen of this country and class 1 citizen in the eye of judiciary. It is a ...

Posted by vinay



Copyright 2006 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.