The Web


Home > Movies > Reviews

Padmashree is an insult to cinema!

Ronjita Kulkarni | January 28, 2005 12:43 IST

Padmashree Laloo Prasad YadavDear Mahesh Manjrekar,

I watched your film Padmashree Laloo Prasad Yadav on Wednesday and felt I had to write you this letter.

There are two reasons why filmmakers make films -- it could be their passion to make films, or to make money. Which of these reasons was yours to make Padmashree? It doesn't seem to be your passion, as you have made good films like Vaastav and Astitva earlier. And I wonder how you may make money out of this, as the entire theatre was empty at the film's premiere in Dubai, as part of GIFA (Global Indian Film Awards), except for a handful of journalists. That, even though the film's cast and Salman Khan were expected to make appearances in the cinema halls!

Padmashree is an insult to cinema. You made a talented actor like Sharat Saxena and even Masumeh Makhija (who was quite good in Maqbool) make complete fools of themselves. I will not include the rest of the cast like Suniel Shetty, Johnny Lever, Kim Sharma and Anupama Verma in the talented category because they are really non-actors (Johnny Lever may have been good at one time, but he seems to have lost his touch).

More on !

'I want to make a comedy!'

Shabd : Story in pictures!

Oscar nominees, 2005!

The performances were terrible. Okay, so the film is a comedy, but it did not evoke any laughs. You tried to force in comedy even when it was not necessary. When Sharat Saxena sees his mistress in bed with his Casanova employee Laloo (Suniel Shetty), he did not show anger. Instead, he mouths 'funny' dialogues.

And just because Shah Rukh Khan and Saif Ali Khan's Kantabai act worked in Kal Ho Naa Ho does not mean we should be subjected to Suniel Shetty blowing kisses to Johnny Lever, and looking positively vulgar.

Kim Sharma and Anupama Verma looked like semi-nude bimbettes, and the film will surely not do anything for their careers. Gulshan Grover does his usual 'bad boy' act, and Suniel Shetty cannot carry a movie on his shoulders.

Masumeh seemed to be the central character in the film, as she featured in almost all the scenes. Her only requirement, in this extensive role, was to seduce one and all. I wish I could say she did well.

Padmashree Laloo Prasad YadavYou don't even have a novel story here. Padmashree (Masumeh), Laloo (Suniel Shetty), Prasad (you), Yadav (Johnny Lever) and Johnny (Gulshan Grover) are out to get some diamonds owned by Padmashree's late father. It could have been a cool thriller, or a comedy of errors, but it turned out to be a pathetic waste of time. Too many characters, much, much too loud and very bad dialogues.

So what were you thinking when you made the film? Is this really your idea of entertainment? Or do you underestimate the B and C centres (for whom this film seemed to be made for) so much?

And the way you ended the film. When politician Laloo Prasad Yadav was addressing the four lead characters, Suniel Shetty was missing! You made someone stand in for him, and he covered his face the entire time. How tacky!

It seems to be a trend. Your previous films, Rakth, Hathyar, Pitaah and Ehsaas may have starred popular actors but the audience hated them.

Perhaps it's time you take a break from the camera and rethink your style of entertainment.

From a movie buff,

Ronjita Kulkarni

Want to see this movie? Check out Rediff Movie Tickets!

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 27

Sub: Padmashree: an insult to cinema!

Hello You are absolutely right. It's an complete insult to a cinema. I am a movie buff, but never saw a bad movie like this ...

Posted by Sujay

Sub: Apt review

Ronjita's review though sarcastic is very apt. She did the right thing by pointing out the flaws of the movie. She must have gone overboard ...

Posted by sachin

Sub: padmashree laloo prasad yadav

ronjita kulkarni looks like u are seeing hindi movies for the first time who said sunil shetty cannot carry a movie on his shoulders and ...

Posted by kingmaker

Sub: Padmashree: Hilarious spoof on jewel heist!

Dear Rongita: This is in response to your review on "PLPY".I was surprised at the viciousness of the attack. I went to see the movie ...

Posted by Movie Mad

Sub: any way we shud see

hi reader i think that no one shud not believe without check the things . sanju

Posted by sanjeev


Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Write us a letter
Discuss this article

Click here for More Reviews

Copyright © 2005 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.