NewsApp (Free)

Read news as it happens
Download NewsApp

Available on  

Rediff News  All News  » News » Why no death penalty for rapists? Justice Verma explains

Why no death penalty for rapists? Justice Verma explains

January 27, 2013 13:09 IST

Justice J S Verma has said that there was a unanimous view by women’s groups against the death penalty for convicted rapists.

"It was a unanimous suggestion of even women leaders who have been fighting for the cause for decades. Even the current trend is against the death penalty," he said.

He said when a brutal rape ends up in death, Section 302 (murder) will be automatically applicable to the accused and so the room for capital punishment was still there.

Asked about his recommendations on the failure of the command structure, Justice Verma said it was necessary because if higher officers can execute their responsibility properly, many crimes can be avoided.

On whether the committee tried to get a political profile by giving certain political recommendations, he said, "We are not concerned about the profile. But we comprehended the legitimate scope of our limit. That is what we have done. And electoral laws are important because ultimately that affects the true representations. And
unless there is true representation, the constitutional guarantees can not be fulfilled."

Hitting out at political and religious leaders for making controversial comments on women, the committee has recommended framing laws to disqualify politicians who issue statements "reinforcing gender bias".

Suggestions of the Congress Party on changing anti-rape laws were delivered past midnight to Justice Verma, leading to party chief Sonia Gandhi tendering an apology to him for the odd timing.

Justice Verma also said Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and Finance Minister P Chidambaram were instrumental in forming the committee which gave far reaching recommendations favouring comprehensive amendments to criminal laws.

"Past midnight, someone came to my residence, woke me up and wanted to hand over personally (the Congress Party's suggestions). But somehow the Congress president came to know of it. She was very gracious and the next day, she rang me up personally and profusely apologized, to my great embarrassment. I had to tell her do not do this," he saide.

Justice Verma headed the three-member committee -- which was constituted by the government in the wake of the December 16 gang rape incident -- to suggest amendments to anti-rape laws.

On January 23, the committee submitted its recommendations seeking minimum 20 years imprisonment for gang rape and life term for rape and murder, but refrained from prescribing the death penalty. It also suggested amendment of criminal laws to provide for higher punishment to rapists, including those who were policemen and public servants.

Justice Verma said he took the chairmanship of the committee after Chidambaram called him up at the behest of Dr Singh. He said he had not talked to Home Minister Sushilkumar Shinde even once till now.

© Copyright 2018 PTI. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of PTI content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent.