Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Mobile Downloads
Text 67333
Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article
Home > Cricket > Message Board

Should non-performers be recalled from SA?

December 14, 2006

Related Articles
Pathan seeks Akram's help again
Chappell, Ganguly friends again

Earlier this week the Board of Control for Cricket in India sent out a veiled threat, saying under-performing players will be called back from South Africa.

BCCI secretary Niranjan Shah said the Board has the "full power" to call back any player if he isn't performing.

"Selection committee can always call anybody back and replace him with a new player. Board and selection committee have the full power in this regard. But first we would be watching the performance in the first Test," Shah told a news channel.

However, chief selector Dilip Vengsarkar did not share Shah's viewpoint. He said unless a team member gets injured or is not able to continue playing for any other reason, he would not be asked to go back.

In Indian cricket history players have never been recalled from a tour for reasons other than injury or indiscipline.

The legendary Lala Amarnath was sent back from the 1936 tour of England on charges of indiscipline while former opener-turned-politician Navjot Singh Sidhu had walked out of the 1996 tour of England on his own volition.

The Indian team has received a lot of flak after being whitewashed in the one-day series in South Africa, and Shah said such a harsh step is necessary if the players are unable to give their best.

There is also talk about introducing a performance-based clause in the players' contracts.

Is it right to recall a player from a foreign tour if he is not playing well? Is the BCCI going a step too far in adopting a stance?

Tell us

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 115

Sub: Tendulkar should be sent back or consider retirement

The way Tendulkar has been playing of late indicates a decline in his batting. His reflexes and footwork are on the decline, which does not ...

Posted by shyam

Sub: Right decision to send back Pathan

The decision to send back Irfan Pathan seems to be a fantastic decision on the face value, since he was not performing well. But the ...

Posted by Francis Louis

Sub: Send non-performing players back ??

The first cry from any Indian's heart would be to call back non-performing players and give a chance to new talent and potential players sitting ...

Posted by Deepak Mukhija

Sub: BCCI doing good

That was a great move to improve team work. But sending back should be depend on the average of atleast 3 or 5 matches. and ...

Posted by Narendra

Sub: email id's of cricketers

E-mail id's of cricketers :- 1. LAXMAN : 2. GANGULY : or> 3. KUMBLE : 4. SACHIN : 5. KAIF ...

Posted by rita



Copyright © 2006 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.