Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article

Home > Movies > Bollywood News

Kolkata-based film wins Oscar!

Arthur J Pais | February 28, 2005 11:31 IST

Acclaimed photographer Zana Briski, whose film Born Into Brothels about her work with the children of Kolkata prostitutes won the best documentary Oscar, will soon see her inspiring film expand from its current screen count (about 40) to hundreds of screens across North America and Europe.

The Oscar nomination has also brought controversy to the film. The British Broadcasting Corporation recently quoted Partha Banerjee, who interpreted for the Bengali-speaking children and English-speaking filmmakers, complaining there were 'ethical and stylistic' problems with the documentary.

The Oscar winners!
On the red carpet
Oscar fashion
Full Coverage

A still from Born Into BrothelsHe also wrote to the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences, the organiser of the Oscars, asserting the experience made the children's lives 'worse,' not better.

About a dozen children were taught to take pictures by Briski; some stayed with her program, a few quit. Banerjee also wondered why the film should be considered a documentary as it used fictional shots.

Briski has said†her film told nothing but the truth, and that Ross Kauffman and she told the success stories as well as the failures. "It is evident throughout the film how desperate I felt from time to time because I could help only a few children," she had said in an earlier interview.

The modestly successful film, which has been on a slow expansion plan till now, had formidable challengers, especially in Super Size Me, a comedy against fast food chains. The film has grossed $10 million across America.

Briski's film, directed with her former boyfriend Ross Kauffman, has grossed an encouraging $700,000 in 12 weeks in North America. It is showing in about 40 theatres. It could double its theatre count on March 4. In two weeks, it may reach $1 million. But it is unlikely it will†be seen in India.

Three months ago, Briski†told in New York that even if the film were to win an Oscar, she would not want it to be seen in India except at film festivals because she had promised to protect the identities of the prostitutes from police and politicians.

She also said†the proceeds from the film would be used to set up a school for the prostitutes' children.

One of the moving sequences in her documentary shows her fight to have the children enrolled in a good school.

The more she thought about the problem, Briski said the more she was convinced†it was important to run a special school right from†scratch.

And if the Indian model is successful, she wants to build a similar school for the orphans of violence in Israeli and Palestinian territories, she said.

The film, which was made for about $100,000, could now end its worldwide run with about $4 million, thanks to the Oscar.

Though it†won†plaudits and awards at numerous film festivals,†only after it was nominated for the Oscar did it see its box-office rise. Briski also tries to sell†photographs taken by the children at†theatres showing the film.

She has raised almost $90,000 by selling prints of the children's photographs. "All the money that comes from the sale will†be used for the children's education," she said.

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 4

Sub: Next time you can try ...

Zana Briski, you can try for next Oscar and get one of sure if you just make a documentary (or more of it) about the ...

Posted by Vijay

Sub: Easier said than done...!!

Its have always been easy to crtisize anybody for anything.We have all have been knowing the reality,but just kept our mouths shut and whenever it ...

Posted by Alok Gupta

Sub: Shame shame

Itís a shame that our media is basking in the glory of a British film just because it is set in India. And even the ...

Posted by saunskruti

Sub: There is nothing to be proud of here

Its the usual. You show the poverty and all the crap happening in India and you win an Oscar. Thats the bottom line!!

Posted by Kumar Memon



Copyright © 2006 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.