Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article
Home > Movies > Reviews

Manisha, we want Rajjo back!

Indrani Roy Mitra | December 30, 2005 15:30 IST

A still from AnjaaneDear Manisha,

As I write, my head reels. I am yet to recover from the pain I went through while reviewing Anjaane: The Unknown. Sadly, Bollywood is infested with directors who pick popular Hollywood films and make sad remakes of them. Anjaane, which features you ans is a remake of The Others, is no exception.

In a recent chat with me, you told me you want to concentrate on good films. If Anjaane is your idea of a quality production, maybe it's time you started thinking.

More on!

Return of John Matthew Matthan

Shikhar is very mediocre

Morning Raaga & Oscar cacophony

Anjaane makes you lose faith in the process of filmmaking.

I used to be a great fan of yours. I saw 1942: A Love Story a couple of times. Your non-regular appearances in films upset me. But what has happened to your choice of films? First, there was the disastrous Mumbai Xpress. Then there was Akbar Khan's poor man's epic Taj Mahal.

Anjaane did not mention any time frame. Assuming it depicts India 2005, the jewellery you wore look as if they were lifted straight out of the history books.

A still from AnjaaneYour performance too was far from satisfactory. Your eyes could not emote. I was desperately seeking the nave innocence of Rajjo (1942) in your character Shivani and found there instead, a soul-less mannequin.

Didn't the directors -- Nilesh Ubhe, Shailesh Rane and Krishna Jani -- tell you that your voice was too shrill? For that matter, Helen's voice was shrill as well.

Why are you acting in B grade films like Market, Chahat and Anjaane these days? I still believe in your unquestionable acting prowess. And I hope you will regain the lost berth in your admirers' hearts.

Let Rajjo resurface.

Indrani Roy Mitra

Want to see this movie? Check out Rediff Movie Tickets!

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 9

Sub: The film was so bad...the reviewer had to give her piece of mind

the letter format was interesting...and make me want to watch the movie to actually c how bad it was... manisha really needs a good film. ...

Posted by SS

Sub: was that a review?

there was no mention about the movie at all except for a comment on manisha's jewellery! what is happening to rediff reviewers?

Posted by Saritha

Sub: Review a film or don't?

Hello , instead of giving advice give the film review.

Posted by Saket Gadkari

Sub: This is not the review

This is not the movie review. It is very sad to inform that you should review the movie in this column and not write your ...

Posted by Venu

Sub: Review

Indrani, I thought one is supposed to write a film reviews in this section. We are not intrested in how much you admire Miss Koirali's ...

Posted by Harshal



Copyright 2005 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.