» Business » Budget: The joke's on the middle class

Budget: The joke's on the middle class

By Shekhar Gupta
July 16, 2019 09:31 IST
Get Rediff News in your Inbox:

'That Modi and the BJP can continue to treat the rising and expanding middle class this way shows that they have gamed its mind quite perfectly,' argues Shekhar Gupta.

Kindly note that the image has been posted only for representational purposes. Photograph: Reuters

One key headline point from the Narendra Damodardas Modi government's latest Budget is the raising of top tax rates for the rich earning more than Rs 2 crore a year.

The increase is steeper for the super-rich above Rs 5 crore per year.

This is such an awful example of Indira Gandhi-style 'soak-the-rich' politics, the pro-reform group will say.

Many others in deeply pink polity -- and public opinion -- would hail it as an uplifting evidence that Modi too has fully embraced the principles of socialism as mandated in the Constitution's post-Emergency preamble.

Never mind that he leads India's most unabashed government of the right into its second term.

Both are wrong.

Because the Modi government isn't really soaking the rich, but the middle classes, who also happen to be its most loyal vote bank.

The question we are examining is, is their unquestioning loyalty precisely the reason the government can afford to treat them like this?

Let's collect some facts.


Over the past five years, the Modi government has carried out probably the most spectacular and efficient transfer, or redistribution of national wealth to the poor.

It is tough to estimate it to the last decimal point, but between housing, toilets, cooking gas and Mudra loans, anything between Rs 9 trillion to Rs 11 trillion were distributed to the poor.

That it was done with minimal leakage and with no discrimination of caste or religion has been acknowledged.

That helped Modi win his unprecedented second majority.

But where did this money come from?

Our immediate instinct would be to imagine it came from the rich.

The facts suggest something else.

The government kept raising taxes on fuel as crude prices fell and folding the bonanza into its pocket.

Most of this came from the vehicle-owning middle classes.

You can conclude, therefore, that a spectacular transfer of wealth did indeed take place to the poor.

But it came from the middle classes of all and not particularly the rich.

It also bought enough votes for Modi to sweep another election.

All exit poll data, from the big cities to urbanising states tells you that the middle classes too voted overwhelmingly for the BJP.

The rapidly urbanising state of Haryana, the richest in India with very few extreme poor, is a good example.

The BJP was marginal here until 2014.

Now it collected nearly 59 per cent of the vote.

This is the most important political takeaway from the way Modi has run his economy.

He has taken from those in the middle to give to those at the bottom, and both are voting for him with equal enthusiasm.

The middle classes have emerged as his most rock-solid vote bank.

And they happily pay for it.

Now come to the latest Budget.

Once again, there is the pretence of taking from the rich.

But should it bother the rich? More importantly, does it make the government any richer, or add much more to its kitty to give away to the poor? The answer is no.

You might wish to look at how many of these super-rich exist in the first place.

CBDT data shows that in the last financial year only 6,351 individuals returned incomes above Rs 5 crore with an average income of Rs 13 crore.

How much additional revenue will it bring? No more than a year's turnover of BCCI, the minder of Indian cricket.

The poor will be thrilled the rich are being socked.

And the really rich will complain in whispers but, in any case, keep buying anonymous electoral bonds and dropping them off in one letter box -- you can guess which one.

Because if they don't the taxman might call.

The poor are fooled purely for their cheap thrills and entertainment, but the real joke is on the middle classes.

Because, as in 2014-19, they're the ones who will again contribute the wealth to be transferred to the poor.

To begin with, the finance minister gifted them additional taxes on petrol and diesel in the Budget to "make up", hold your breath, for the drop in crude prices.

This has followed a string of policies that can only be described as "soak the middle class" and not the rich.

The long term capital gains tax (LTCG) on equities was introduced, dividend distribution tax (DDT) was increased, additional tax was levied on dividend incomes above Rs 10 lakhs per year, surcharge on incomes between Rs 50 lakh and one crore was raised (unless you call them super-rich today), subsidies were reduced and taken away from the middle class including on cooking gas.

We'd welcome the removal of these non-merit subsidies.

But remember, who is paying.

Demonetisation and GST also raised costs of living for them.

That Modi and the Bharatiya Janata Party can continue to treat the rising and expanding middle class this way shows that they have gamed its mind quite perfectly.

Its loyalty to them is fired not so much by economic impulse as by the resurgent, muscular Hindu definition of Indian nationalism that they have bought into.

Add to this, the dislike of the Muslim.

Many of them may still find lynchings abhorrent, but they are quite happy to see Muslims completely out of the power structure: Cabinet, top government positions, and greatly reduced in Parliament.

My colleague D K Singh points out a remarkable set of figures on the number of times the BJP finance ministers have mentioned the middle class in their budget speeches.

Generally, it has averaged five.

In Piyush Goyal's Interim Budget speech, on election eve, it suddenly shot up to 13 times.

In Nirmala Sitharaman's now, it fell to three.

Of course she also completely forgot the promises Goyal had made to them in his speech in February: Increase in standard deduction, TDS threshold, relaxation tax slabs.

Why should we bother when you will vote for us entirely out of your love for us while the poor vote with gratitude.

Four decades, India's Muslim minority was similarly gamed out by 'secular' parties.

They took Muslim voters for granted, knowing they will vote for them out of their fear of the BJP.

That's the reason they saw no need to do anything for the Muslims.

Their vote came as ransom for protection.

The BJP has now realised the majority middle class sees a similar compulsion to vote for it.

The reason we call them Modi's 'Muslims'.

By special arrangement with The Print

Get Rediff News in your Inbox:
Shekhar Gupta
Source: source