NewsApp (Free)

Read news as it happens
Download NewsApp

Available on  

Rediff News  All News  » Cricket » 'Kumble-Kohli feud akin to 1952 Nayudu-Mankad skirmish'

'Kumble-Kohli feud akin to 1952 Nayudu-Mankad skirmish'

December 15, 2017 21:10 IST

 India’s captain Virat Kohli and then head coach Anil Kumble in the background

IMAGE: India’s captain Virat Kohli and then head coach Anil Kumble in the background. Photograph: BCCI

Clash of egos is not new in Indian cricket and former BCCI COA member and noted historian Ramachandra Guha is of the opinion that the fallout between former coach Anil Kumble and Virat Kohli was similar to what happened between former captain Vinoo Mankad and chief selector CK Naydu in 1952.


"I resigned from the Committee of Administrators six months ago and this is for the first time that I am commenting in public on cricket. (There is a) story about massive dispute between Col CK Nayudu and Vinoo Mankad," Guha spoke during a function at the Bombay Gymkhana in South Mumbai.

"So essentially Nayudu was the chairman of selectors and Mankad was India's great cricketer. India was touring England in 1952 and Mankad had been offered a contract with Lancashire League," the eminent historian recollected.

"So when Mankad told the BCCI that if you assure me that I will be on the England tour of 1952 I will not take this contract. (To which) Nayudu said we will not give you an assurance. India lost the first Test (and) Mankad played in Lord’s."

Although India lost the Lord's Test, he scored 72 and 184 along with figures of 5/196 in the England first innings.

"My one point on cricket today it struck me is that the relationship between Nayudu and Mankad in 1951-52 was akin between Anil Kumble and Virat Kohli.

“With this difference, in 1952, the administrators, selectors and managers had an upper-hand compared to the players. Abhi ulta hai (now it’s the opposite)." 

© Copyright 2018 PTI. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of PTI content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent.