Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article
Home > News > Report

China keen on opening border with Sikkim: Analyst

Sheela Bhatt in New Delhi | May 23, 2003 04:13 IST

If China recognises India's sovereignty over Sikkim it may gain more access to the expanding Indian market, Srikanth Kondapalli, China scholar and research fellow at the Institute of Defence Studies and Analyses, told

Media reports have suggested that intense efforts are underway to resolve Sino-Indian differences on the Sikkim issue before Prime Minister Atal Bihari Vajpayee's scheduled visit to China next month. 

Sikkim became part of the Indian Union in 1975. China had then taken 'strong' objection to the merger, terming it as 'illegal occupation by India.' The Chinese position, Kondapalli said, was in sharp contrast to India's recognition of Tibet as an integral part of China.

In fact till the 1990s China had been vocal in its opposition to the merger of Sikkim. The decibel levels of Chinese protests reduced after a détente between the two countries in 1995-96, when then Indian Prime Minister P V Narasimha Rao signed an agreement with his counterpart Li Peng in New Delhi.

Foreign Minister Jaswant Singh's March 2002 visit to Beijing, while further softening China's stand on Sikkim, did not, as the Indians wanted, culminate in Beijing fully acknowledging Indian sovereignty over the northeastern state.

The tactical Chinese move to grant India political legitimacy over Sikkim has been necessitated because China wants to improve its management of Tibet and want to increase trade across Indo-China border. By recognizing Sikkim China wants some leverage on the pending border dispute with India and trade-related issues.

"Sino-Indian border trade is valued at over $100 million. This trade can be facilitated if the route through Sikkim is opened up," Kondapalli said. "Sikkim is the lifeline of Tibet. For the better management of Tibet China needs to regularise food supplies through Sikkim."

Moreover, any border trade between Sikkim and China, millions of dollars according to some estimates, can be extended till Kalimpong in West Bengal and further to Bangladesh. 

Many years ago Yatung in Tibet had a flourishing trade with Sikkim and China's aim, Kondapalli said, is to revive it.

If the Sikkim route is opened up, China could think of using the Siliguri corridor to reach Bangladesh.

The 180-km long corridor is also the lifeline of the Indian Railways and Indian military. Any opening up of this region, he said, will have to take into account security considerations.

China has also started constructing railway lines from Tibet to the Indian border. By 2007, the lines are expected to be operational.

The construction of such an ambitious railway network, when seen in the context of China's recent defence pact with Bangladesh, throws light on the Chinese plan of setting up a supply corridor stretching from Bangladesh, West Bengal, Sikkim and all the way into Tibet.

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 10

Sub: Chinese Invasion

It was victory for China all the way. Our PM and other delegation were no match to their superior maneuvering skills. No wonder why china ...

Posted by Defender

Sub: Tibet, Dalai Lama and Indian Army

"The Chinese position, Kondapalli said, was in sharp contrast to India's recognition of Tibet as an integral part of China.".... ----------------------------------------- The Indian response at ...

Posted by NJ Ramesh

Sub: Operation sarp

It's common knowledge how stupid the Indian governments are and have been regarding foreign relations. The Chinese have been dancing jigs around them, supporting terorrist, ...

Posted by bodh

Sub: Never Trust the Chinese

India has already burt its fingers by trusting the Chinese during 1960's. Partly due to an Ignorant Prime Minister(Nehru) and because of his ill-timed slogan ...

Posted by Aditya

Sub: Beware of China

India should state in no unambiguous terms to China that Sikkim is an integral part of India. Let us not repeat the same old mistakes ...

Posted by Balaji JV



Copyright © 2005 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.