Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article

Home > News > Report

Kolkata does not have a birthday: Court

May 17, 2003 00:50 IST

In a historic verdict, the Calcutta high court on Friday said British trader Job Charnock was not Kolkata's founder.

Chief Justice A K Mathur and Justice Jayanta Kumar Biswas directed the West Bengal government to delete Charnock's name from history books and not celebrate August 24 as the city's birthday.

"Calcutta does not have a birthday," the judges noted in their verdict that, in effect, upheld the report of a five-member committee set up by the court to probe the city's origins.

August 24, 1690, when Charnock was believed to have set foot on Kolkata, was considered the city's foundation day.

But the inquiry committee had opined that clusters of 'rural settlements had agglomerated in the last decade of the 17th century to coalesce into the English East India Company's trading factory. This grew into a township in the 18th century. No particular year marks its date of birth'.

The court had set up the committee while hearing a petition of an aristocratic Bengali family that challenged the city's birthday two years ago.

The family of Sabarna Roychoudhury, which is believed to have 'owned' much of what is today Kolkata, had claimed that Charnock had landed in Calcutta in 1676. On August 24, 1690, he came for the third time.

It contended that Calcutta found mention in documents and the city's maps dating back to 1660.

Historians believe that human settlement began in Calcutta about 1,500 years ago. The first European traders to arrive in the region were not English, but Portuguese in 1510.

The state government has accepted the verdict.

More reports from West Bengal

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 4

Sub: wasting time and money

In a country plagued with courts being woefully behind when dealing with cases, this is something we definitely dont need. Honestly, who cares if Calcutta ...

Posted by Bharat

Sub: Re:tp

Spot on. Who cares?

Posted by arun visvanathan

Sub: tp

wasting time on forming commitees on such useless controversies and passing just adjudgements is sickening...while there are so many cases pending, it doesnt matter whether ...

Posted by Vikram

Sub: A landmak judgement

This really is good news for the residents of Kolkata and all those who love it. The city has finally been cleansed of its colonial ...

Posted by Sushomoy Bhattacharyya



Copyright 2006 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.