Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Mobile Downloads
Text 67333
Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article

Home > Business > Business Headline > Report

Pan-IIT alumni against OBC quota

Aziz Haniffa in Washington, DC | November 16, 2006 16:39 IST

The Pan-IIT alumni organisation favours affirmative action but is opposed to reservations for Other Backward Classes in the prestigious Indian Institutes of Technology.

The organisation, which collectively represents approximately 150,000 alumni of the seven IITs, has in a letter to has written to President A P J Abdul Kalam and Prime Minister Manmohan Singh argued that while they are supportive of creating equal opportunity for all, they did not believe a system of reservations is the correct approach.

The letter, co-signed by Pan-IIT-USA, Pan-IIT-India Executive Council, and the Global Pan-IIT Coordination Council said, "We admire the government's allocation of resources and appointment of an advisory panel for examining these issues. We urge the government to include members of the Pan-IIT Alumni Association as representatives on this panel and to help implement affirmative action."

Participate in the PanIIT 2006 Global Conference! Click here to register now!

The organisations said that IIT alumni, after 'considerable deliberation on the subject of reservations,' strongly believed that reservations and quotas are not viable alternatives for several reasons.

'We believe that meritocracy and excellence should be the guiding principles in implementing reforms,' the body said. 'Reservations and quotas along the lines of caste, creed, ethnicity, et cetera have only served to divide people and are regressive and counterproductive to the fundamental goals of social change.'

The alumni organisations also argued that the 'current system of quotas is ineffective and facilities for education are inadequate in IIT. The IITs are currently unable to fulfill even the previously set aside quotas for candidates from Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes. Also, there is a significant dropout rate among students who are admitted to the IITs through this system.'

The letter argues that 'merely increasing the quota does not achieve the intended goals. Also, increasing the student intake at the IITs without addressing the acute shortage of faculty and inadequate infrastructure - hostel rooms, student facilities, research labs, etc - would only serve to diminish the world-class standards achieved to date.'

'The IITs were set up for creating a group of Indians to be globally competitive. They were never created for mass education. Affirmative action should be applied for mass education at primary level, and not for institutions of excellence,' the letter said.

It warned that IIT's brand recognition 'has been hard won, and has played a very important role in the rising international esteem for India and Indians on recent year.' The letter urged the president and prime minister to maintain this meritocracy, and said failure to do so was against the national interest.

"This is the first time that every Pan-IIT organisation the world over -- European Union, Canada, Japan, Australia, Singapore, India, and the United States -- has come together with a single voice on a complex subject," Suresh Shenoy, co-president of Pan-IIT, told

Shenoy, an IIT Mumbai alumnus, is executive vice president of Information Management Consultants, Inc based in Reston, Virginia.

He said three members of the association -- Pradeep Gupta, Arjun Malhotra and Sunil Wadhwani -- were working with the Moily Committee to represent the alumni view on the subject.

Participate in the PanIIT 2006 Global Conference! Click here to register now!

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 31

Sub: OBC quata

I am against the OBC quata.the government use more money on the primary education of children who are below poverty level.thanks IITians to they are ...

Posted by mayuresh

Sub: Pan-IIT alumni against OBC quota

IITians take pride in solving problems from basics. But when it comes to the social problem,their fundas are zero. Just to understand the problem(solving would ...

Posted by Mahendra

Sub: IITs there and here

The Illinois Institute of Technology USA has recently agreed to offer four-year scholarships to all low-income Chicago Public School students who meet the school's rigorous ...

Posted by Partha Sarathy

Sub: One with Courage makes Majority

While various IITs and deemed universities bent backwards to please you know whom and said that they would wait, watch and ultimately toe the government ...

Posted by Partha Sarathy

Sub: Pan-IIT alumni views vague

Had they been so concerned about the progress of the nation they would have been serving the nation and/ or helped the country with constructive ...

Posted by Prasanna



Copyright © 2006 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.