NewsApp (Free)

Read news as it happens
Download NewsApp

Available on  

Rediff News  All News  » News » Modi as PM disastrous, Rahul has credentials: Dr Singh

Modi as PM disastrous, Rahul has credentials: Dr Singh

Last updated on: January 03, 2014 16:38 IST

'I do not believe I am a weak prime minister'



Prime Minister Manmohan Singh on Friday declared that he would bow out of office after the Lok Sabha elections and strongly backed Rahul Gandhi for the job while warning that Narendra Modi would be "disastrous" for the country.

"I will hand over the baton to a new prime minister," Singh said in an opening statement at a rare press conference, making it clear that he would no longer be in the running for the job when he completes his 10-year tenure in May after the Lok Sabha polls.

A number of questions at the 75-minute press conference in New Delhi pertained to his record in office which he deflected by repeatedly saying that it was his belief that history would be kinder to him than the contemporary media or the opposition.

But a question on his being perceived as a "weak" prime minister, brought forth an uncharacteristically strong attack on Modi when he accused him of "presiding" over the "massacre" of innocent people during the 2002 Gujarat riots.

"If by strong PM you mean that you preside over mass massacre of innocent citizens on the streets of Ahmedabad, if that is the measure of strength, I do not believe that kind of strength this country needs, least of all in its prime minister," he said.

At another point while answering a question on a potential contest between Rahul and Modi, Singh said, "I sincerely believe that it will be disastrous for the country to have Narendra Modi as prime minister."

He ridiculed Modi's campaign for a "Congress-free" India saying that was not going to materialise.

The press conference, only the third held by Singh in nearly 10 years in office, covered a wide range of subjects, mostly political, some pertaining to the state of the economy and a few on foreign policy. Information and Broadcasting Minister Manish Tewari conducted it and promised another interaction.

Click NEXT to read further...

Image: Prime Minister Manmohan Singh addressing the press conference in New Delhi
Photographs: Press Information Bureau


'History will be kinder to me'

Prev     Next


Voicing the hope that his successor would be from the United Progressive Alliance, the Prime Minister endorsed Rahul by stating that the Congress vice president "has outstanding credentials to be the PM candidate".

The Congress party would announce the candidate at the appropriate time. While clearly declaring that he would not hold office after the elections, Singh was vague on his future plans thereafter.  He had not thought this through.

Singh put up a weak defence of the government's record on corruption by arguing that coal scam and 2G spectrum licences allegations pertained to his first tenure 2004-09 after which people had voted back the UPA to power in 2009.

"They (voters) do not seem to have paid heed to all charges of corruption," he contended, ignoring the fact that these scams had been unearthed after 2009 elections. He, however, conceded that there had been irregularities in these allocations.  But the dimensions of these irregularities had been overstated by the media, the CAG and other entities.

To a query whether "dual centres of power" in the Congress had affected his functioning, the prime minister said "I sincerely believe that the arrangement where the Congress president and the prime minister did not happen to be same person has under the circumstances worked exceedingly well.

"For me it was a remarkable achievement that I have been able to complete 10 years without any hiccups between the prime minister and Congress president. Sonia Gandhi's support has been enormous. She was there to back me which facilitated my task in more than one way."

Asked about the perception that the decisions were taken in 10, Janpath, a reference to Sonia Gandhi's house, he said, "It is not a question of Congress president or the vice president.  If they have any view it ought to be reflected in the government to the extent possible. It is not a disadvantage or a drawback in our system. This has enabled us to deal with many issues.

Click NEXT to read further...

Photographs: Press Information Bureau

Prev     Next

'Rahul has outstanding credentials to be PM candidate'

Prev     More


"If the government recognised issues, I don't think it is right to say that this is wrong or it is disadvantage to make corrections if the party leadership says it is required in national interest.

"At the outset, the prime minister conceded that price rise could have been one of the factors in the defeat of the Congress in the recent assembly elections.

"Price rise was a factor in the people turning against the Congress.  The reasons for it were beyond our control as the prices of international commodities were rising making it difficult for us to control prices.  But we have taken enough measures to protect the weaker sections.  That should not be lost."

"We will reflect on what the results tell us for the future and learn lessons," he said.

Asked what he plans to do in future having ruled out yet another term, Singh, "I have not thought through it.  It is too early.  I have still five months to complete my present term.  When I reach that stage, I will cross the bridge."

When asked what were the best and lowest moments in his career as prime minister, he said, "Well, I will need time to reflect on this.  Certainly I think the best moment was when we were able to strike a nuclear deal with the United States."

To a question whether the thought of resigning crossed his mind against the backdrop of scams and difficulties, "I never felt like resigning at any time. I enjoyed my work and did my job without fear or favour."

But asked whether anyone in the Congress asked him to resign, Singh said, "Nobody had asked him to step down because of any inadequacies as prime minister."

Answering questions on his image being tainted by corruption allegations against the government, he said, "I have never used my office to enrich or reward my friends or relatives."

Prev     More
© Copyright 2018 PTI. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of PTI content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent.