Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Get news updates:
Mobile Downloads
Text 67333
Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this Article

Home > News > PTI

'Merchants of death' remark aimed at Modi: Cong

December 08, 2007 18:43 IST

Related Articles
Coverage: Gujarat Elections 2007

Disowning party leader Kapil Sibal's defensive remarks, Congress on Saturday insisted that party chief Sonia Gandhi [Images] did refer to Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi [Images] when she used the phrase 'merchants of death' in her election speech and it was not apologetic about it.

"Of course, she did. You can read that statement," AICC spokesman Abhishek Singhvi told media persons in New Delhi, clearly distancing the party from senior leader Sibal's statement on Friday that Sonia did not refer to Modi when she said 'merchants of death.'

"What Sonia said is crystal clear. In view of Narendra Modi's acts, omissions and utterances over several years, Sonia's statement is mild. We stand by that description. There is no question about being apologetic," he said.

Asked whether Sonia would give a suo-motu clarification to the Election Commission over her speech, Singhvi said, "She needs to clarify nothing. Everything is on camera."

To BJP leader L K Advani's statement that the EC should also issue notice to the Congress chief and adopt the same yardstick for both her and Modi, he said: "No right thinking person can or will equate the statement of the Congress president with Modi."

"This is a deliberate mischief and a desperate attempt by BJP to try to justify the unjustifiable," Singhvi said.

Congress sources said Sibal's statement had sent a message that the party was afraid to take on Modi on the issue of the post-Godhra riots and the clarification today was meant to dispel any such impression.

Asked if the party was in disagreement with Sibal's statement, Singhvi said, "I am not here to comment on persons or personalities. All that I want to say is that the AICC stands by the statement, by the description."

"In the light of Modi's acts, omissions and utterances over the years, in the light of Modi's confessional statement a few days ago, in the light of Modi government's written affidavit in the Supreme Court, we reiterate and stand by the statement made from the AICC," he said.

Sibal said: "Sonia said 'your state functionaries.' 'Merchants of death' was meant for the manner in which certain state functionaries were working."

Singhvi has in the AICC briefings said the 'merchants of death' phrase was not only appropriate but too mild for Modi. He, however, refrained from using the 'merchants of death' phrase in the press briefing today and only repeated that the AICC stood by its statement when asked about it.

Singhvi also attacked Modi on the issue of development in Gujarat, saying, "It is easy to boast. It is easy to mislead if one runs away from facts and figures. It is easy to make tall claims if facts are conveniently avoided."

He accused Modi of having presented a false picture as regards tribal development, economic growth, prices and education.

He claimed the amount released by the National Democratic Alliance government during 2002-04 for tribal development was Rs 4,530 lakh, while the UPA released Rs 9,625.34 lakh during 2005-07.

© Copyright 2007 PTI. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of PTI content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent.