Home > US Edition > The Gulf War II > Report

Tensions between Rumsfeld, army commanders: Report

Suman Guha Mozumder in New York | April 01, 2003 11:19 IST

According to US Army officers in Iraq, the Pentagon has not sent enough troops to wage the war against Baghdad.

Army commanders compare Defence Secretary Donald H Rumsfeld to Robert S McNamara, the architect of the Vietnam War who failed to grasp the political and military realities of Vietnam, The New York Times said on Monday.

"He [Rumsfeld] wanted to fight this war cheap. He got what he wanted," the newspaper quoted a colonel as saying.

Last week, Lieutenant General William S Wallace, the V Corps commander, fired the opening salvo against the Pentagon when he said that the military faces the possibility of waging a longer war than had been anticipated by many strategists.

"The comments echo the tension in the bumpy relationship between Rumsfeld and General Eric K Shinseki, the army chief of staff," the daily said.

Currently, there are about 100,000 coalition troops inside Iraq, part of more than 300,000 on land, at sea and in the air.

According to the report, some of Rumsfeld's advisers now acknowledge that they misjudged the scope and intensity of resistance from Iraqi paramilitaries in the south, and forced commanders to divert troops already stretched thin to protect supply convoys and root out Saddam Hussein loyalists in Basra, Nasiriya and Najaf.

However, the report said that the advisers also point to the air campaign's successes in the past few days in "significantly weakening" the Republican Guard divisions around Baghdad.

"It was a painful process to match political and military goals," one senior official was quoted as saying.

Article Tools

Email this Article

Printer-Friendly Format

Letter to the Editor

Related Stories

Iraqi convoy moves towards Najaf

Cook wants British troops to return

People Who Read This Also Read

US report pans Gujarat violence

Infiltration continued in 2002: US

Powell says Kashmir after Iraq

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 32

Sub: RE:Please report both sides

Unfortunately Joe, Most Indians think there is nothing more to American media other than CNN, just as they view American life and culture through their ...

Posted by FJC

Sub: More setbacks

Americans can expect more setbacks, since they are waging an unjust war on the unarmed iraqi people.

Posted by jaydeesh

Sub: Cheap ??

how can one say cheap , there is no thing like cheap in the war. US apolozises for killing of the iraqi women and children. ...

Posted by indian

Sub: editor

have the americans forgotten vietnam? lives will be lost, thats the cost of war. the americans have no choice to but to accept that. the ...

Posted by Akhil

Sub: Distorted world view

As long as American perception of the rest of the world is guided by what they see on CNN, America will continue making the same ...

Posted by Prakash


Copyright © 2003 rediff.com India Limited. All Rights Reserved.