|Rediff India Abroad Home | All the sections|
Wilkinson's skill excites some, irritates others
Julian Linden in Sydney | November 19, 2003 21:38 IST
When Jonny Wilkinson kicked his third drop goal in less than an hour during England's World Cup semi-final win over France, Prince Harry started throwing high-fives and English fans began dancing in the rain.
Wilkinson is a master of drop goals. He can kick them with his left foot or his right, from long range or acute angles, and his hat-trick against France took his total for the tournament to a World Cup record seven.
But not everyone was impressed by Wilkinson's tactics. Large sections of the huge crowd groaned in frustration every time he instinctively dropped the ball on to his foot.
While field goals have provided some of the most dramatic moments in rugby history, many players and spectators still regard them as a nuisance that goes against the spirit of the game.
Some consider them to be a cheap way of collecting points for teams that are not talented enough to score tries. No one wants to see them eliminated from the game, but many believe their value should be reduced from three points to one.
Former New Zealand winger Grant Batty is among the many critics who want the points system changed to place the emphasis on scoring tries, which are currently worth five points, just two more than a drop goal.
"If it was meant to be a kicking game," Batty said, "William Webb Ellis would never have picked up the ball and ran with it in the first place -- that was the idea."
Rod McCall, a member of the Australian team which won the 1991 World Cup, said he would at least like to see them reduced to two points, the same as a conversion.
"An attempt at drop goal is something you do if you couldn't be bothered [attacking] or you want to take cheap points," he said. "I'd probably knock it down to at least two points and bring the value of a try up.
"They will eventually do it. They will bring something into line that the try is the main option when a side is in the attacking 22."
Australia's current coach Eddie Jones said he was a great admirer of drop goals, but wants the value of tries increased to better reflect the importance of crossing the opponent's line.
"It's a great skill, field goals," Jones said. "Rather than reduce the number of points, maybe increasing the number of points for tries might be the way to go."