Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Get news updates:
Mobile Downloads
Text 67333

Home > India > News > Columnists > B Raman

   Email   |      Print   |   Get latest news on your desktop

Discrepancies in IM's emails need to be studied

September 16, 2008

Related Articles
SIMI's Hubli meeting was key
The hunt for Indian Mujahideen's Al Arbi
The Indian Mujahideen threat is real
Pathetic handling of blasts' aftermath
Subhan, the mastermind behind Indian Mujahideen
Eye-witness account: Five feet from death
Another email, an open challenge
Wide tentacles ensure SIMI's plans go on
Tips to protect your wi-fi from hackers
Complete coverage: The Delhi blasts
The group calling itself the Indian Mujahideen [Images] has so far sent five e-mail messages to sections of the media since it made its appearance in November last year.

The first message was sent a few minutes before the serial blasts in three towns of Uttar Pradesh [Images] last November.

The second was sent after the blasts in Jaipur [Images] in May.

The third was sent before the blasts in Ahmedabad [Images] on July 26.

The fourth was sent after the press conference held by the Gujarat police in August, in which they claimed to have solved the case relating to the Ahmedabad and Jaipur blasts, identified the perpetrators and arrested many of them. According to the Gujarat police's version, the Students Islamic Movement of India is now operating as the IM.

The fifth message was sent before the blasts in New Delhi [Images] on September 13.

The first, second, third and fifth messages claimed responsibility for the blasts and the fourth debunked the Gujarat police's claims of having solved the case and tried to convey the impression that those arrested had nothing to do with the blasts. Surprisingly, the IM has not sent any e-mail message claiming responsibility for the serial blasts in Bangalore on July 25.

Intriguingly, the IM describes its latest e-mail warning of the New Delhi blasts as 'our third consecutive e-mail'. It says: 'The Indian Mujahideen accepts the sole responsibility for the Delhi serial blasts, and we claim this, through our third consecutive e-mail, which is, unfortunately, still a mystery for you. It is very sad to see the bad condition of your cyber forensics who have still failed to find our technique of sending the 'Message of Death'.'

Why does the IM talk of only three e-mail messages, when the media had received five e-mails, all purporting to be from the IM?

A careful study of all the e-mail messages purported to have been sent in the name of the IM indicates the following:

While the first two e-mail messages were virulent in their content, they were not obnoxiously abusive in their language. The last three messages were not only virulent in their content, but also obnoxious in their language.

I had pointed out in my earlier column that in the message about the Ahmedabad blasts, they had used the word 'bastard' which normally Al Qaeda [Images] and pro-Al Qaeda organisations are never known to use.

The latest message on the New Delhi blasts is even more abusive than the previous two messages regarding the blasts in Ahmedabad. Gujarat Director General of Police P C Pandey has been abused as a 'rascal', a 'bastard', a 'corrupt old hag', a 'base-born criminal' and a 'filthy loyal dog of Narendra Modi' [Images]. These are typical of the underworld of Mumbai and Gujarat.

The Gujarat and Rajasthan police and their police chiefs have been severely condemned in the latest, and a specific threat of terrorist attack has also been held out against A K Jain of the Rajasthan police. But, significantly, there is no criticism of the Karnataka police and its chief. There is not even a reference to the investigation by the Bangalore police, whereas the investigations by the Ahmedabad and Jaipur police have been debunked and their claims of having solved the cases have been questioned.

Similarly, there is no reference to the UP police's investigation into the blasts of last November.

The language used in the third and fourth messages about the Ahmedabad blasts and the fifth message about the New Delhi blasts, which are very abusive, differ from the language used in the first message about the UP blasts and the second about the Jaipur blasts.

Why such discrepancies? It is important to find answers to them before we come to definitive conclusions about the IM. Just as the proof of the pudding is in the eating, the proof of the terrorist is in the catching. Unless and until we are able to identify and neutralise or arrest the right persons who are the brains behind the IM, we will have more surprises.

We have arrested many perpetrators of individual blasts, but I am not sure we have arrested the brains. By thinking and prematurely projecting that we have identified and arrested the brains, we will make ourselves liable for more surprises, which could damage the credibility of the police in the eyes of the public.

In the latest message, the state governments of Gujarat, Rajasthan, Maharashtra, Madhya Pradesh [Images], Uttar Pradesh, Andhra Pradesh and Karnataka have been criticised for their alleged harassment of Muslims, but the main brunt of the criticism has been on Maharashtra and the Mumbai police. Having attacked the national capital in New Delhi, they could target the economic capital Mumbai next.

From these messages, it is apparent that the IM does not as yet have a strategic objective such as the establishment of an Islamic caliphate or the 'liberation' of the Muslims of India. Its objective till now is purely tactical, to wreak vengeance on the Hindutva organisations and the various state governments accused of harassing Muslims. New Delhi seems to have been targeted not only to exhibit their capability for action in the capital, but also to wreak vengeance on the Government of India for its failure to prevent the demolition of the Babri Masjid in December 1992.

The message says: 'Babri Masjid was and will remain to be our glorious self-esteem and Inshallah, we will prove it to you a hornet's nest in which you have immersed your bare hand, unaware of the pain to come. If you are prepared to suffer the results of this issue, then by the will of Allah, verily! We will make you face it, and if you feel you are wise enough, then here we announce our ultimatum: Vacate the land of Babri as soon as you can.'

B Raman

   Email   |      Print   |   Get latest news on your desktop