The Web


Home > Movies > Reviews

Where is the soul in Passion?

Arthur J Pais | February 25, 2004 13:21 IST

James Caviezel as Jesus ChristMel Gibson has set a record: no Biblical film in history has ever had the kind of brutality as his The Passion Of The Christ.

A soul-less film, though well acted by James Caviezel and stunningly photographed by Caleb Deschanel, it does not offer illuminating thoughts on Jesus Christ.

The debate whether the film will perpetuate prejudice and anger against Jews for their perceived role in the killing of Christ will continue. Meanwhile, the evangelical Christians who are rushing to see the film with their children may want to do something fast: look for therapists to handle their trauma and nightmares after seeing this exercise in gore. Even adults who have seen the most violent films ever could find it difficult to keep their eyes open many times. 

The Passion Of The Christ on!

Pix: Mel Gibson's Passion

Pix: The Crucifixion on film

For a nation still consumed by the controversy over Janet Jackson showing her nipple over television, one could say that transgression was indeed pardonable compared to the debauchery of violence in this film.

If there is a film festival for fetishistic films, Gibson's movie will be hailed as a classic for its depiction of the beating and torture Christ had to endure. The flogging scene alone takes over ten minutes. You see the skin tearing and tiny pieces of flesh coming off his body slowly. The crown of thorns is then -- slowly -- hammered onto his head, and we get to see more blood drip down the face.

Wait, don't close your eyes. Wait for the spikes to be hammered into his palms.

Given the wide controversy, the movie could open big. And given its medium-range budget ($25 million), it may not lose any money at all. It will of course be interesting to see what kind of tortuous fate awaits it in the long run.  

Some of the finest films of our times, including The Godfather saga have had plenty of violence. But in Gibson's film, which portrays the last 12 hours before Christ was crucified, graphic scenes of torture overwhelm the viewer so much that we get to see little of Christ's soul.

If I were to see a more insightful about Christ, I will revisit The Gospel According to St Matthew, the 1996 film directed by Pier Paolo Passolini, the leftist Italian director who admired Christ's egalitarian outlook.  
Pontius Pilate (Hristo Naumov Shopov), the Roman administrator, asks the crowds assembled to see Christ being tortured, "Isn't this enough?"

But Jewish elders, convinced that Christ is a heretic, call for his crucifixion. The Romans are only happy to carry it out. There are many disagreeing accounts of Pilate in the Gospels and religious books. Some show him as a ruthless administrator and some a political pawn. Here, Pilate appears to be a sympatric character, and there is no doubt in Gibson's mind about that.

Nowhere does the film hint that Christ died for humanity. It does not echo the thoughts of many Catholic theologians that the death was in response to universal sins. 

The crucifixion as depicted in The Passion Of The ChristThe few kind Jewish characters are the people who like Christ and are beholden to him: Maia Morgenstern, a Jewish actress, plays his mother and Monica Bellucci is well cast as Mary Magdalene. But their parts are limited, and we see them do little beyond shedding a few tears for Christ. That they managed to do it well is some relief.

There are moments the movie sends mystical sensations down the spine like the eerie sequence in the Garden of Olives, where Jesus is being tempted by Satan (Rosalinda Celentano). But soon Gibson is possessed by a sado-masochistic streak and there is very little chance of a redemption.

Cast: James Caviezel, Monica Bellucci, Rosalinda Celentano, Hristo Naumov Shopov, and Maia Morgenstern
Director: Mel Gibson
Writers:  Ben Fitzgerald, Benedict Fitzgerald and Mel Gibson 
Cinematography: Caleb Deschanel 
Running time: 2 hours 10 minutes
Rating: R for sequences of graphic violence
In Latin and Aramaic with English subtitles.
Distributor: New Market Films


Mel Gibson hits back at critics

Mel Gibson under attack for Jesus film?

Pain and Passion

Mel Gibson's Christ film is branded anti-Jewish

Reviews for The Passion Of The Christ


Want to see this movie? Check out Rediff Movie Tickets!

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 36

Sub: The Passion

I was very impressed with Mel Gibson's film The Passion. It followed the Bible story and the language used, Latin and Aramaic, made the film ...

Posted by Tojo Melville

Sub: Thanx Gib...

I personally want to thank Mel Gibson for doing a great film in the film history. nobody has given a clear picture of what has ...

Posted by Robert

Sub: great film

the review is not true because it does not see the actual concept of suffering of christ. mel well done great film that will be ...

Posted by winston

Sub: bad, bigotted film by gibson

I agree with Arthur Pais' insightful review. The film is senselessly violent and misses the whole point- that Jesus was egalitarian and died to make ...

Posted by gita

Sub: Jesus's Love

The writer of this article has missed the point completely, for him this must be just another movie. And that's why he is comparing with ...

Posted by Indira


Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Write us a letter
Discuss this article

Click here for More Reviews

Copyright © 2005 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.