Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections

Search:



The Web

India Abroad




Newsletters
Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article
Home > Business > Business Headline > Report


US outsourcing ban legally valid: experts

June 16, 2003 17:30 IST

The controversial legislations in several American states, including New Jersey, banning outsourcing of state contracting of services would be legally valid under the WTO's General Agreement on Trade in Services, according to US legal experts.

And that perhaps explains Deputy Prime Minister L K Advani's reluctance to take up the issue with President George W Bush during his recent visit to Washington.

Asked about it at a press conference, Advani said he had not raised the issue at his meeting with Bush because it was not a problem for India, but a concern for American companies, which are seeking to cut costs to remain competitive.

That, he said, was something that American companies have to deal with.

There is a need to distinguish between law and public policy when dealing with the outsourcing ban legislation, said William Bierce of the New York law firm Bierce & Kenerson.

Under WTO's GATS, "It would appear valid for government procurement of services,'' he said. "Such 'Buy America' or 'Buy Local' laws are illegal under GATS when they relate to purchases by private buyers. But for government buyers of services, the GATS allows such favouritism to local service providers," Bierce said.

''As a beggar-thy-neighbour policy of keeping jobs at home, such legislation would help generate employment at a time of economic decline, reducing the costs of public welfare and other social costs,'' he said.

However, such legislations would not be good public policy, Bierce added.

''Such legislations would deprive local governments of purchasing services at the cheapest price. It would hurt local taxpayers as consumers of government services.''

It was New Jersey which gave the lead in introducing anti-outsourcing legislation when in March 2002, New Jersey State Senator Shirley Turner introduced a Bill that would impose a 'Buy American' rule on all purchases in the state.

Under the Bill's provisions, for every state contract for services only US citizens and legal resident aliens shall be employed.

The Bill was inspired by the fact that recent published reports have indicated that telephone inquiries by welfare and food stamp clients under New Jersey's Families First Program were being handled by operators in Mumbai, after the contractor moved its operations outside of the United States as a cost-cutting measure.

The Bill was intended to ensure that State funds are used to employ people residing in the United States and to prevent the loss of jobs to foreign countries.

UNI


7333: The Latest News on Your Mobile!

UNI

Share your comments


 What do you think about the story?




Read what others have to say:


Number of User Comments: 9




Sub: Let's Strip Down

Hi America! Let's have a deal. You ban all BPO projects. You ban all IT projects. You ban all kind of subcontracting projects coming to ...


Posted by Puneet





Sub: if India forces '' Buy Indian''

If India forces "buy Indian", then Pepsi, Coke, reebok adidas etc... ( i guess i can fill a page with names ) should close down ...


Posted by raghavendra





Sub: Don't be too edgy

We totally understand about the concerns of the Outsourcing fear and feel the same if it has been happening in India. But what needs to ...


Posted by M.Srinivas





Sub: regarding ban BPO's

At present it is not effect int india.but in the future india can lose some revenue and also the U.S companies will be face cost ...


Posted by N.B.Raju





Sub: RE:US BPO bans legally valid

Maybe we can also stop recognizing US patents and Intellectual property rights. US Pharma companies etc will lose trillions of dollars, if we retaliate.


Posted by ajay sharma




Disclaimer


Advertisement






Copyright 2005 Rediff.com India Limited. All Rights Reserved.