| Rediff India Abroad Home | All the sections | |
'Can Schumacher come back?' September 11, 2006 23:51 IST Formula One is in shock. Michael Schumacher's retirement decision has resulted in heartbreak across the globe, and rediff readers too felt let down by the legend's decision. Tributes to the great man were the order of the day as readers caught up with Raja Sen and Sumit Rajwade, apart from some Fernando Alonso criticism for his 'crybaby behaviour.' Here's how the chat went: Raja Sen says, Hey guys, assuming you all caught the race. And the aftermath. Let's talk about the most important F1 day this decade. Bala asked, if Schumi not opting to race in 2007, can Kimi do it for Ferrari ? schumi_fan asked, Alonso had an engine failure and did not go off the track cleanly. He has disturbed Massa's race although it was not his intention. Bad luck Massa vamsi asked, can schumi turn off his decision to quit julio asked, It was terrible to hear it from Schumacher that he would retire at the end of this season. It is the end of a great era with probably the greatest F1 driver ever [even better than Juan Manuel Fangio]. In a way, though, it is good that Schumi has decided to retire while he is at his peak. sss asked, Kimi is the best option for Ferrari after Michael I think... Rahul asked, That's it - It was emotional watching Schumi bid adieu ! - F1 is never gonna be the same again ramandeep_kaur81 asked, Dont u think schumi shud have stayed on for at least one more year? Hermit asked, Kimi is a fantastic driver .His clinical drives might win Ferrari titles, but still the void of Schumi cannot be filled Alonsofan asked, Who do you'll think will win the championship???? pankaj asked, hey what u say??? who will be champion next season? kimi or alonso? sss1 asked, Will Schumi have announced his retirement if he had not finished first??? julio asked, A strong chance of Schumi winning the championship. Both Alonso & Flavio Briatore showed poor sportsmanship by complaining about Ferrari & the FIA. Akki asked, We will never know how good Ferrari would have been with Shumi and Kimi as their main drivers. venki asked, will Alonso perform well in 2007 with the Mclaren Hermit asked, Alonso will have 2 sweat it out with the Mclanen's which are not as reliable nd robust as the Renaults this season .My money is on Kimi for the next season asked, BOXER asked, Do you not feel Schumi should have announced his retirement after 100 GP wins raj211 asked, frankly everyone on the chat....for me yesterday formula 1 announced it's retirement the most important aspect known as "passion" is no more in F1 Princess asked, So, with three races to go, are we expecting fernando alonso to just roll over and die? sss1 asked, Rediff mentioned him as a controversial gr8... aggression and arrogance comes naturally to winners Akki asked, Flavio Briatore world ends and starts with Alonso.Now that he's going to Mclaren and his main enemy Schumi retiring,I think it's high time for Flavio to Retire. asked, Amit asked, How would you rate Michael Schumacher as a sportsman from since he had a controversial career? Hermit asked, yeah, Kimi is a wonderful driver no doubt.nd with a Ferrari machinery, he can go all the way nd win his debut championship.But still, the aggression nd never-say-die attitude of Schumi will be missed for sure Sid asked, I don't have a question...but just something I'd like to share...you know there's a whole generation of us who have simply come to the point of loving the sport because of the fact that Michael Schumacher is on track. We have seen him ever since we started watching F1...to many he's the reason people switch to Star Sports on Sunday evenings. this void that has been created will not be filled up. kamalesh asked, what u think will scumi make it 3 out of 3 Amit asked, As you know Michael Schumacher has been blamed for quite some controversies by his critics. Would people still talk about this even after he retires? veeyess asked, Kimi's car reliability issues should be sorted out once he is behind the steering of a ferrari ... i have already started having great hopes for the next season. Surely a worthy successor as a driver though the legacy will be one that is hard to match bratpack asked, you are a self confessed ferrari fan, but if you had to lay your bets on another team for the next season.. based on various parameters which one would you choose? Hermit asked, I guess Coulthard summed it up perfectly well saying that for all these talk abt controversies nd stuff, there is no denying that Schumi remains a great champion . Well said David ! veeyess asked, absolutely raja; strange to see Briatore and Alonso bickering..need more class funnytothelimit asked, Have you taken a look at the BBC Have YouR Say message board? Infact, 95% of the responses and the people posting the responses hate Schumi there. But here in India particularly he stands out. Is that an indication of the lack of true experience of Indian Fans in F1 sport and politics or is it simply that the foreigners (from an Indian point of view) understand the sport and politics better and are fed up with F1? Akki asked, Schumi went to Ferrari when it was not the top teams and along with Ross Brawm.Jean Todt turned the team around.He is a complete driver.Just thinking of Alonso if he could go to Red Bull with Flavio and turn things around for them.He is only good in a fast car. Raghu asked, of course the never say die attitude of schumi will there, but it'll be kimi whoz gonna me in his shoes as i said... remember the last season? how raikkonen fared even though later part of the season he lost due to unwanted incidents.. i am sure kimi is equally competent. but one question here what about McLaren even though ALonso will be joining McLaren.. will that fierce competition be there between kimi & raikkonen veeyess asked, wasn't it a great race between massa and kubica and then massa and heidfeld? massa was unlucky in having to brake in alonso's debris :( paresh asked, this is to all of you why schumacher is the greatest driver of all times read the book "DRIVEN TO EXTREME by JAMES ALLEN" its a phase before the ferrai dominatoion pre 2000 dan asked, Hey Raja. what have u got to say on the cry made by Flavio saying that "they want schumi to win and hence are targetting Alonso".. Sathu asked, F1 has lost its leading light. Its ridiculous to see people saying Schmi could be the best driver but not the Greatest. People need to judge athletes by the desire to win, the never-say-die-attitude, the "I'll give it my all" way rather than anything else. Its sad that the world is dividen in admiring such a great driver. Ethics can be practiced elsewhenre and the need of the track is the Schumi Way. Do you agree that his is the Greatest? veeyess asked, and let us not forget the role massa played in bringing ferrari where they are in the constrcutors'. massa has effectively neutralised fisi ... from maverick to a more reliable driver ...the transition has been remarkable vishnu asked, With Schumacher gone, do you think that formula 1 will lose its huge popularity in Germany ? Sumit Rajwade says, Hi! All, its been a pleasure to see you all after a long time. sarfraz asked, Will anyone of the current lot rule next five seasons like schumi did? Amit asked, Hi Raja - my thoughts. Winning is not only everything. I completely admire Schumacher, but for me to become my sport hero and a legend, he needs to be much more than a great driver. For me, first you have to be an ethical and value driven person then be a great sportsman. I am just wondering how controversial he is - or are the stories just being overplayed? dan asked, Raja, arent we all sad. But then if Schumi wins the championship, it would be a great decision. And he has done a favour to Massa as well.. veeyess asked, coming back to this season, as we said in an earlier chat, the season heading towards a grandstand finish. A legend who has announced retirement - will he clinch it? The defending champion under intense pressure. Could you have asked for more? Button asked, Hi Sumit. How are u? Schumi is retiring. How do u feel? shweta asked, do you ppl think that after schumi retires both driver will gat equal place in the ferrari team?? coz whn schumi is there the second driver kinda plays role of second fiddle...... dan asked, Raja, Alonso's engine failure, Kimi second behind Schumi, Schumi wins last race at Monza, retires, gives matle to Kimi.. Well all this seems too right out from a fairy tale..?? sanjay asked, hi , was schumi afraid of Alonso, as he is quitting after this season.......AS, Schumi may lose all his success fame in next season raj211 asked, one thing is for tht schumacher fans will have nothing to look forward to in the sport of F1 now....no victory leap on the podium...no orchestrating the italian anthem.... sidd asked, Hs schumi gotten bigger than the team and the sport...also with montoya moving out of f1...is it doomsday for f1 next yr onwards harinder81 asked, What about the pace by which coulthard was going heywhere overtaking other cars..... i loved the moment when at a single instances he overtook two cars behind him ray asked, I have been a big fan of F1 for about 12 years hunting for F1 news years back on the internet and all. Of late F1 does not interest me anymore like it used to. For me Max Mosley has screwed up the whole thing ur comments please Akki asked, Now that Schumi has retired we will really get to know how good a Ferrari is as against a Renault or Mclaren.No one can drive a Ferrari or for that instance any F1 car as good as Schumi did. Akki asked, Now the only question remaining is WHO WILL WIN NEXT YEAR'S CHAMPIONSHIP? This year's championship is going to SCHUMI,surely. schumi_fan asked, Hi Guys, Kubica's great drive is overshadowed by Schumi's retirement. But what a great drive in his first season. What do you say Raja veeyess asked, getting into yesterday's race, the way schumi handled heidfeld first and then speed on the curva granda was magnificent and look at how kubica reacted to alonso whilst exiting the pits .. that in itself tells a story ;) Hermit asked, dan, as long as cricket rules in India, nothing else is gonna get the attention :( Rishi123 asked, hi what will be the line up for ferarri in 2007? any clue wat so ever? Sid asked, There have been many greats even during his "regime" if I may call it..Hakkinen, Hill..and Alonso off late..I think it was fantastic the way he won in 2005, but you know one has bounced back and bounced back hard the way Schumi has. Not to mention his perofrmance with Benetton in 94 and 95 and might I add that Mika and Coulthard were very much with McLaren even at that time. dan asked, Raja, Kimi is making the best move of his career. With Ferrari he can do wonders. What say? schumifan asked, I think that all of us irrespective of our fav teams and drivers should honestly ponder over the fact that noone has come even half way in achieving what Schumacher has achieved and that Schumacher raised F1 to level it is today. Also everyone should stop blaming Schumacher for everything(there are people who feel that he deliberately retired as he was scared of racing with Kimi!!!!!) Lets all salute the man for all his achievemnts and hope that we see his active involvement in F1 in future as well!!! veeyess asked, hey sumit, in the earlier chats u seemed to be hellbent on revolutionising the F! with rule changes... did u manage to come up with any funky ideas :D dan asked, Raja, What are ur predictions for the next 3 races. Do you think renault is stronger on Asian circuits ? dan asked, Hi Sumit, Wasnt Kimi too gracious yesterday in not challenging Schumi that seriously. asa asked, hey raja,what's the maximum age to start a career in motor racing and then climb up the ladder? is it necessary to start off from age of 5 or 6? i am 18 and waiting for ur reply!and if 18 is ok how to start off? dan asked, Raja, Whats the reason behind the great starts that Alonso makes..Almost everytime. Even with back of the grid he makes up quickly like yesterday and in Hungary.. Akki asked, I am just praying that Ross Brawn,Jean Todt dont leave Ferrari.Hope to see them working with Kimi,Massa in taking Ferrari to even bigger heights. Ranjan asked, Hi Sumit, Congrats on the Michael Schumacer win. Will he be able to win the F1 Championship this year? And do you think he took the right decision by the retiring after the season? I think nobody can replace him. abhishek111182 asked, Who will be first driver for Ferrari .. kimi or massa schumi_fan asked, Raja, your answe for what Amit asked is too diplomatic. Why don't you agree that Schumi is a controversial driver without ethics. Why was he stripped off all his points in '97?. Is it not because of his acts on track? dan asked, Raja, dont u love the sound of these F1 machines that Echos out of the trees in the narrow lanes of Monza circuit.. Ajay asked, Do u think ferrari find MSC replacement in kimi Roshan asked, If you had carefully listened to post race conf from schumi, he said he had to decide on his future with Ferrari before Massa does. This means that Ferrari had a secret deal with Kimi raikkonen and the fate of massa in ferrari depended on schumi's decision. And in no way schumi is going to block the future of massa in ferrari. Hence he decided to retire. Now does this not mean that Ferrari forced schumi to retire by making secret deal with kimi and giving +ve indications on massa ? Was this not an inferior way to treat the great Micheal schumacher by ferrari ? dan asked, Hi Sumit and Raja, What now, can Alonso turn it for Mclaren cos Ferrari with Kimi and Massa look like a lethal combo. What is ur guess for Alonso's partner in Mclaren.. Doesnt look like De La rosa will get the nod. RedBaron asked, I think all other drivers and the media overdo it when they say Schumi has cheated. For heaven's sake, Senna used his car as a battering ram to push Prost out.Just that tis fashionable to say Schumi is a cheat schumi_fan asked, One more great thing about Schuumi. He was always the guy who could drive well at new and Non Europe circuits. Be it Malaysia, US , Bahrain etc. Getting used to tropical conditions and driving on new circuits is an art. And don't forget his skill on wet circuits !! Akki asked, With Schumi gone we are saying an era ends.But now a new era starts with Massa,Kimi,Alonso,Kubica driving without Schumi's shadow clearing over them.Now drivers with get some acknowledgement and some TV footage with F1's greatest icon retiring. dan asked, Hi Sumit and Raja, What now, can Alonso turn it for Mclaren cos Ferrari with Kimi and Massa look like a lethal combo. What is ur guess for Alonso's partner in Mclaren.. Doesnt look like De La rosa will get the nod. aka asked, starting young for karting is good.. but what is the upper limit of the starting age? rachit asked, schumi is sposed to carry on a new 'role' in ferrari after he retires.. any clues on what tht could be?? Ranjan asked, Who can replace Schumi? Massa or Alonso? Chandranath asked, Was it Schumi opting to retire or Ferrari wanting to move on with Kimi and Massa ? Beacuase at 37 Schumi would surely not have stayed till 2009 the time till which Ferrari have contracted Kim ? schumi_fan asked, ya, that's a great idea...no one should be allowed to take a pit stop when Safety car is out. This is giving un due advantage to some teams although they claim it's stratedy dan asked, Raja, Dont u think Fisichella is pretty happy that Alonso is leaving Renault. After all Fisi seems to be fed up of making sacrifices for Alonso.. Next year we can see true talent of Fisichella .. aka asked, starting young for karting is good.. but what is the upper limit of the starting age? veeyess asked, Raja...kubica in a McLAren would be absolutely WOW! Except that he would sadly suffer from engine blow outs every 3rd race:( Ranjan asked, HI Raja, Can the remaining racers will be able to take place of Schumi bharat patel asked, how do you the rate of alonso being a champion next season cause as fas as i am concern raikkonen is a better driver then schumacher and he will drive the ferrari faster then schumacher veeyess asked, swapnil and satish ... we did not hear about fixing from Jean Todt or Michael that F1 was fixed when Michael was relegated to P22 in Monaco. Instead, we got a dignified drive which finally resulted in P5 ... who knows it may have even been better were it not for a couple of untimely safet car incidents dan asked, Hey Raja, Did u see that great move Coulthard made on turn 1 yestreday to overtake 2 cars in one shot.. Boy that was amazing. The Scot can still do good. What say? schumi_fan asked, Come on Sumit, MS as F1 GP boss?. Bernie Ecclestone is still alive...I am happy he is not in this chat :-) dan asked, Hi Sumit and Raja, Why is BMW Sauber suddenly turning out to be a strong package. They got great times in Qualifying and got a podium finish.. Good for the sport Satyasen asked, Raja, What's your take on the ensuing Kimi vs Fernando battle for supremacy? Your money on? Sathu asked, Massa and Kimi are Very Good Drivers, No dounts... But aren't they reluctant over-takers? Wont Alonso with Ferrari make a better combo? Sathu asked, Massa and Kimi are Very Good Drivers, No dounts... But aren't they reluctant over-takers? Wont Alonso with Ferrari make a better combo? Sathu asked, Massa and Kimi are Very Good Drivers, No dounts... But aren't they reluctant over-takers? Wont Alonso with Ferrari make a better combo? dan asked, Raja, wasnt it quite strange that in the post match conference, Schumi was gearing up to announce his decision while the question asked to him was about the first lap with him and Nick Hieldfield locked together.. Schumi had to change topic and Announce his retirement. Queer!! sss1 asked, Can Schumi become a coach to some F1 driver which will be a new concept??? Chandranath asked, Has any other individual sport seen a bigger and more dominant personality than Michael ? RedBaron asked, Alonso really is becoming very arrogant and it is sad that the current champion lacks maturity or poise. For all the times Schumi has been penalized in the past, he did express his opinion if he disagreed but not in this manner like a crybaby.And Briatore much the same. Nishit asked, @Raja: Ahh.. I am too late, I didn't know this was going to be held. I hope you got my message on your blog swapnil asked, How will be Renaults preformance next year? bharat patel asked, same with me raja kimi realy rocks all these years we have seen him loose races with a non reliable car infact once on the last lap his tyre just went off i think he will jus do wat ms has done all the years win championships veeyess asked, sumit...dont forget roger federer in tennis!!!! Nishit asked, @Raja : What do you think Schumacher's role could be with Ferrari now? aka asked, but still give me a practicle age for kicking off ur career in motor sport from the scratch?when is is too late to start swapnil asked, What about Larnce Armstrong sumit Chandranath asked, Who is Villunueve to question Schumi's greatness ? After all we can see the difference ( for the better)in BMW after he has been asked to step aside. Opinion ? Raja Sen says, hey hey when we talk of greats who have reinvented the sport, please lets not miss out Michael Jordan and Tiger Woods. veeyess asked, Who are the drivers to watch for in 07? Besides the usual suspects of Kimi and F'nando my take is that Massa, Kubica and Rosberg will be the ones to watch out for. Sumit Rajwade says, All right people, it was a great fun to chat and share the F1 fun again with you. See you post the next race. Till then, Happy week ahead. Santosh asked, I think Schumi should have till one more year so that he could have achieved 100 grandpix wins. What do you say? Roshan asked, Hey Raja I just checked up the facts and you were right. Schumi decided to quit in July after US Grand Prix. And he had hinted the same to his team after San Marino. No wonder we get to hear a seemingly ardent MS fan in chris Goodwin our commentator from an Maclaren (Kimi supporter) guy that he is !!! Raja Sen says, Alright guys, was a great chat. We'll be putting up some Schumi specials soon, and catch you next time for the post-China chat. Cheers! Formula One: The Complete Coverage
| |||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||