rediff.com

NewsApp (Free)

Read news as it happens
Download NewsApp

Available on  

Rediff News  All News 
Rediff.com  » News » Will Libya become Obama's Iraq?

Will Libya become Obama's Iraq?

Last updated on: March 20, 2011 12:42 IST

Will Libya become Obama's Iraq?

     Next

Next

Oil -- and not human rights or concern for democracy -- is the driving force for the war in Libya as it was in Iraq, says senior analyst B Raman.

"Despite the fact that it was French war planes which launched the first attacks, it's clear that this early phase of the operations is an overwhelmingly American affair -- all but a very small number of cruise missiles have been fired from American ships and submarines, " said Paul Adams, the BBC correspondent in Washington DC, while commenting on the air and missile strikes launched by the US, France and the UK against ground targets in government-controlled areas in Libya on the night of March 19.

As I watched the TV visuals and read reports on the strikes, I was reminded of what the previous George Bush administration called the decapitation strikes before it started the invasion of Iraq in 2003.

The military action in Libya has been projected as having the limited objective of a humanitarian intervention to protect civilians in the areas under the control of the rebels.

But its real objective is to have Muammar Gaddafi, the Libyan despot, removed from power as quickly as possible and install a pro-west leader at Tripoli so that western oil and gas companies could return to Libya and resume oil/gas production.

Plese click NEXT to read further..


Image: US President Barack Obama walks from a lectern after announcing limited US military operations against Libya, in Brasilia
Photographs: Jason Reed/Reuters
     Next

'Oil is the driving force behind US' Libyan operations'

Prev     Next
Prev

Next

Oil -- and not human rights or concern for democracy -- is the driving force in Libya as it was in Iraq. Saddam Hussein paved the way for his own isolation and destruction by antagonising his own people through cruel repression and his neighbours through his arrogance.

Gaddafi has similarly paved the way for his own isolation and ultimate destruction through similar policies of repression and arrogance. No force on earth could have saved Saddam in 2003. No force on earth could save Gaddafi in 2011.

Gaddafi is politically doomed. When a ruler -- be a democrat or a despot -- loses the support of his people his end is inevitable. The question is no longer whether Gaddafi will fall, but when and under what circumstances.


Image: Arleigh Burke-class guided-missile destroyer USS Stout (DDG 55) launches a Tomahawk missile in support of Operation Odyssey Dawn in the Mediterranean Sea
Photographs: Handout/Reuters
Prev     Next

'Obama will be wrong to think Libya is an exception'

Prev     Next
Prev

Next

What suffering it would cause to the Libyan people? Are they going to be the real beneficiaries of the UN-authorised and western-manipulated intervention or the consumer economies of Italy and other European countries dependent on the flow of oil and gas from Libya?

The Iraq invasion set in motion the train of events that ultimately led to the discrediting of the policy-makers of the Bush administration in the US and the Tony Blair government in the UK. As Barack Obama himself had often conceded, the involvement in Iraq contributed to the US's difficulties in the Af-Pak region.

One thought Obama had learnt the right lessons from Afghanistan and Iraq. It is apparent he has not. After the Second World War, the US had rarely covered itself with glory when it embarked on external adventures -- whether it was in Korea or in Vietnam or in Somalia or in Afghanistan or in Iraq. If Obama thinks Libya could be an exception, he is mistaken.


Image: Supporters of Libya's leader Muammar Gaddafi shout slogans as they arrive at Bab Al- Aziziyah
Photographs: Zohra Bensemra/Reuters
Prev     Next

'More anger will breed more terrorism'

Prev     More
Prev

More

The only effect of the Libyan adventure will be that the march of democracy, which started in Tunisia and spread to Egypt, will be stopped. The Arab despots, who have jumped into the western bandwagon against Gaddafi, have done so not because their hearts bleed for the civilians in Libya and for their human rights.

They have done so because they calculate that the diversion of the western attention to Libya enables them to crush the human rights and aspirations for democracy of their own people.

The western need for Arab support in Libya in order to show it as a truly international coalition of western crusaders and Islamic people has already led to a cruel suppression of the pro-democracy agitators in Bahrain with western voices and conscience remaining muted as the Sunni ruler, with the help of 2,000 ground troops from the states of the Gulf Co-operation Council, crushes the Shia protesters.

The western near-silence in Bahrain today and in Saudi Arabia tomorrow is the quid pro quo for the Arab support in Libya.

Whatever be the outcome in Libya, its echoes will be heard wherever American lives are threatened and American interests are endangered -- whether in the Af-Pak region, or in Yemen or in Egypt or elsewhere. We have seen the resurgence of the Afghan Taliban in Afghanistan with a Neo Taliban keeping the NATO troops bleeding.

We will be seeing a resurgence of Al Qaeda with a neo-Al Qaeda endangering American lives and interests everywhere. Anger breeds terrorism. More anger will breed more terrorism.


Image: A Libyan army soldier walks past an image of a hand crushing an F-16 fighter superimposed on a window at Bab Al- Aziziyah, Gaddafi's heavily fortified Tripoli compound
Photographs: Zohra Bensemra/Reuters
Prev     More