Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article

Home > News > Report

Lucknow madrassa sings 'Saare jahaan se accha'

Sharat Pradhan in Lucknow | September 07, 2006 19:16 IST
Last Updated: September 07, 2006 21:13 IST

Related Articles
'Many Muslims may choose to sing it'
Images: A salute to the nation
Coverage: The Vande Mataram row
Vande Mataram - A rendition

Instead of following the Central government directive on reciting the national song, Vande mataram, about 200 Muslim children chose to sing a popular patriotic song - Saare Jahan Se Accha Hindustan Hamara - at an assembly of a Lucknow madrasa on Thursday morning .

The Central government had earlier issued a missive to all states to ensure singing of Vande Mataram on September 7 in all educational institutions to mark the completion of 100 years of it being adapted as the national song.

While most schools followed the directive, Islamic institutions had, however, expressed their reservations on the matter.

"The idea behind singing this popular song was to prove that we Muslims are not unpatriotic. Our only objection to reciting Vande mataram was because it amounts to worshipping the nation and our religion forbids us from worshipping anyone other than Allah," said Maulana Khalid Rasheed , the Naib Imam of Lucknow's Idgah and head of Madrasa Nizamia, run by the Idgah Trust.

He sought to point out, "Those arguing in favour of singing Vande Mataram have repeatedly claimed that the song was only a kind of praise or salutation to the nation, we chose to sing an equally patriotic song in praise of the nation."

The Uttar Pradesh government had made it optional for students to follow the directive. Even the High Court held a similar view, leaving students free to decide whether to sing it or not.

According to state principal home secretary S K Agarawal, "Barring one minor incident of violence in Meerut district , no untoward incident was reported in this regards from any other part of the state."

He told mediapersons Thursday evening, "Two persons were injured following a clash between Vishwa Hindu Parishad activists and some local Muslims in Kalli patti village under Mavawan police circle of Meerut district."

In Lucknow, VHP activists staged a demonstration to mark their protest against Islamic institutions refusing to sing the national song.

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 13

Sub: Talking some sense!

This is the first time I am reading a Muslim Cleric taking some sense!!

Posted by Anonymous

Sub: thats the right thing to do

This is the right thing to do. I believe that patriotism is not based on which song you. One of the aspects of patriotism is ...

Posted by khalid khan

Sub: misconcept

Fanatic muslims and political leaders misleading the muslim community.Instead of vandemataram', sare jahase achcha was sung by madarsa pupils is meaningless.Even no doubt about their ...

Posted by appala prasad

Sub: Re: Patriotism versus God

Hi all, If someone ask me to prefer between God and the country. I would prefer God who is my creator rather than country or ...

Posted by habib

Sub: There no hindus or muslims or christians or sikhs - Just Indians

If Lucknow Madarassa is singing "Saare Jahan se", will it convince other fellow indians or so called "Indian Patriotic" that Indian muslims are patriotic. Its ...

Posted by k dsouza



Copyright © 2006 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.