Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article
Home > News > Columnists > Javed Akhtar

'Let's not lose sleep over Vande Mataram'

September 06, 2006

Related Articles
The Vande Mataram controversy
I have never quite understood politicians. Neither could I read their minds. Are they guided by logic? I don't think so. Or else why do they always make an issue out of a non-issue and waste Parliament's precious time?

The song Vande Mataram had some controversial stanzas. So what? They have been taken off. And that should have appeased a party as nationalist as the BJP. Instead, it chose to flog a dead horse and fan the fire of controversy. Is this the oft-repeated nationalism the party talks (read brags) about?

As a conscious citizen of this country, I feel such a stand is not only preposterous but also unnecessary. If some people don't want to sing the song, let them not sing it. But why waste our energy debating on it? We live in a democracy and should, therefore, allow people to exercise their democratic rights.

'Many Muslims may choose to sing Vande Mataram'

As lyricist and musician, I borrowed from Vande Mataram on three occasions -- for films Saza E Kala Pani (1996) and Phir Bhi Dil Hain Hindustani (2000) and while writing a song Price of Bullets on the Kargil war. I won't hesitate to say that each time I was thoroughly inspired by the song.

A party with a strong political base should rather concentrate on other vexing problems. For instance, they should lose sleep over 105 farmers committing suicide in Vidarbha last month or children dying of malnutrition and not over a national song's supposed separatist tone.

Instead of analysing Vande Mataram and going into hair-splitting details, BJP members should take note of pregnancy-related deaths in rural areas, do something to eradicate poverty and the unemployment that dog the country.

The politicians must not take people's attention away from core issues -- they should not influence them to move away from the less privileged population of the country. I beg the people of this country not to fall prey to the crafty designs of the politicians.

We have thousands of serious issues at hand. Let us stop being hypocrites and stop raising a hue and cry over things that do not matter.

Vande Mataram!

Guest Column

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 152

Sub: Vande Mataram a non-issue

Dear Javedji, Very easily said forget it. What we are talking about is national song. How can we forget those who issue fatwas for those ...

Posted by Raja

Sub: Thanks Javed Sahib

Javed Sahib's opinion through Let's not lose sleep over Vande Mataram" really depicts the correct com-gen (coming generation) Indian mind. I can have a rotound ...

Posted by rabikanungo

Sub: What if it happened to you?

If some one does not sing the Vande Mataram is because he does not feel he is Indian which is the case with majority of ...

Posted by rashmin

Sub: Re: Vande mataram issue

Hey Javed your comments are not surprising to me.. I have three questions for you.. 1) What has George Bush done to Indian muslims as ...

Posted by RK

Sub: vande mataram is not a issue

javed ji i am 100% agreed with you it is a stratergy of politican to divert attention of people from core issue to lull issue

Posted by kapil sharma



Copyright © 2006 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.