|Rediff India Abroad Home | All the sections|
Speaker-Oppn stand-off in MP assembly
November 01, 2006 15:34 IST
During zero hour, Singh's poser led to a stand-off between Speaker Ishwardas Rohani and the opposition Congress with both sides flaunting rule books in support of their stand.
While pressing for immediate debate on the notice 'moved well in time before commencement of the sitting,' Singh said the issue should be debated urgently as Bharti had reported a threat to her life three days before the attack during polling for the assembly by-election in Malehra constituency in Chhatarpur district.
Though the Speaker initially ruled that the adjournment notice will be considered only after hearing the view of the government, which had been informed of the matter. When the house reassembled after half an hour adjournment, he said debate on the admissibility of the notice would be held on Thursday.
Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan also consented for the debate on Thursday.
However, Singh stood the ground that the Speaker had no right to delay the debate on an adjournment notice before ascertaining the government's view. But the Speaker said his ruling cannot be challenged and cited six instances when adjournment notices were taken up after considerable delay during Singh's tenure as chief minister.
Ignoring Singh's attempt to clarify that his view was misunderstood, the Speaker disapproved his argument, leading to uproar with the entire opposition on their feet and reaching the well of the house and the Speaker initially adjourned the sitting for half an hour.
When the house reassembled, the Speaker tried to rush through the business and got the business advisory committee report approved.
As Singh again tried to raise his point on the Speaker's power to delay debate, the Speaker read out the bills, which got the Governor's permission. The opposition Congress members again reached the well of the house and raised slogans forcing the Speaker to adjourn the sitting till Thursday.