Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article
Home > News > Specials

The Rediff Special/Sheela Bhatt in New Delhi

Manmohan offered to quit over CPM protest to Indo-US exercise

January 07, 2006

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh had offered to resign last November when West Bengal Chief Minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharya refused to provide his government's support to the India-United States joint military exercise in West Bengal.

Not only did he offer to resign but he also told Bhattacharya that 'defence matters decided by the Centre can't be overruled by the states.' Dr Singh also gave the West Bengal CM the example of Kerala where Indo-China joint military exercises were conducted unhindered. According to a source in New Delhi, "The PM said no state can deny defence exercises." Dr Singh also issued a stern warning that the Centre can impose President's rule if a state does not cooperate in the country's defence matters.

He made these remarks during a telephone conversation with Bhattacharya, which took place before the exercise.

"The prime minister shows guts when a major issue related to America comes up," a senior government official in New Delhi said.

After his conversation with Bhattacharya, the Cabinet Committee on Security met and passed a resolution that states have to cooperate on defence matters.

The impact of Singh's strong stand was so intense that Prakash Karat, general secretary of the Communist Party of India-Marxist, met the prime minister the next morning and promised all-out cooperation for the Indo-US joint exercise.

Belying his soft exterior, Prime Minister Singh can turn into a man of steel even against his allies if he feels their policies or actions could threaten the national interest and prestige.

In this case, what angered him was that his commitment and belief to take the US on board in his strategic vision for India was being obstructed by the CPI-M, which rules West Bengal. That state's Marxist activists threatened to launch a massive agitation against the defence exercise.

India and the US conducted the six-day joint air exercise on November 7 at the Kalaikunda air force station in West Midnapore district.

But that was made possible only after Dr Singh handled the situation firmly, to the surprise of his colleagues.

Very few people in government know the prime minister had offered to resign, but only after sending a message that in India's federal structure, a commitment given by the Centre is binding on the states.

The schedule for the exercise had been drawn up by the military officers of the two countries in pursuance of the agreement for bilateral strategic cooperation reached during the earlier National Democratic Alliance government.

Joint exercises in pursuance of this agreement had been held before in other parts of India to the mutual benefit of the two countries.

When it was West Bengal's turn to conduct the exercise, the state CPI-M mounted an agitation and threatened to oppose the defence initiative through mass mobilisation of party workers, thereby creating fears about the smooth conduct of the exercise and the physical security of the visiting American officers and troops.

When Bhattacharya, toeing the state CPI-M line, also started sending out negative signals, Dr Singh called up the chief minister.

Instead of shifting the venue outside West Bengal, the prime minister put his foot down and insisted that the state government ensure there was no obstruction to the exercise because it has a bearing on national prestige.

Bhattacharya was not given any option but to concede Dr Singh's demand.

The prime minister's polite, but stern, message and his reminder to the chief minister of the latter's obligations under the Constitution was a historical political move which went unnoticed.

Following this, Bhattacharya asked the state police to take firm security measures for the exercise.

The West Midnapore district Left Front, however, went ahead with its protests.

An effigy of US President George W Bush and a copy of the India-US defense framework were burnt. Local Left leaders made speeches showing an Indian map with chains around it.

But the joint military exercise went ahead and was reported a success.

The Rediff Specials

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 83

Sub: Dr.Singh's Message.

It is high time, that the COMMON MINIMUM PROGRAMME is renamed as CONDITIONAL (COMMUNIST) MINIMUM PROGRAMME, or Common Minimum Programme under Communist Command.

Posted by surya

Sub: Dr. Manmohan resignation

I congratchulate Dr. Manmohan to mentions the Centrals rule position to the people who are ruling the state with out any rules except to stay ...

Posted by Prasad

Sub: lleftist

if this is with Russia or china they will agree.this stand is really ridiculous with our devolopement and new technology.they want people as idiots and ...

Posted by shiju

Sub: PM Teaches a lesson!

Bravo PM Dr.Manmohan Singh ji.Its our country's good luck that we got great minds on two most respected and foremost posts of our country.Both are ...

Posted by Sukhbir Singh

Sub: Congratulation to P. M.

I congratulate Prime Minister Dr. Manmohan Singh for taking right and firm decision in the interest of Nation .

Posted by D. P. Sinha



Copyright 2006 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.