Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article
Home > News > Columnists > Arvind Lavakare

In the national interest, Dr Singh?

February 06, 2006

One meaning of the word 'confer' is 'have discussions'. Its extension into 'conference' would therefore mean a formal meeting where there would be discussion, however brief.

But Sonia Gandhi-appointed Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's press conference the other day was anything but that. There was to be no discussion whatever at that 'conference' -- even a refutation of the answer or a supplementary was denied. It was no more than a question-and-answer meeting, with journalists being given numbers on placards. Bowler number seven bowled to Younis Khan and Younis Khan condescended to play him -- period. Take it or leave it.

That is why Manmohan Singh got away with his laughable innovation of the phrase 'enlightened national interest.' The UPA government's decision on the Iran vote at the IAEA board of governors' meeting at Vienna, relations with USA and other countries, the government's economic and domestic priorities -- all these, our PM said, would be guided by 'enlightened national interest.'

Isn't any country's prime minister expected to act only and exclusively in 'national interest'? So what was Manmohan Singh being so lofty and solemn about?

And 'enlightened' national interest? What's that? Is it some kind of 'spiritualised' national interest? Was it national interest born of profound wisdom that only Manmohan Singh and/or Soniaji possesses?

Message Board: Do you believe in Dr Singh?

We will not know. We will not because, as said earlier, Manmohan Singh's meeting with the journalists the other day was but a Q-and-A meeting. But our media would do well to note that phrase and ask the PM at some future meeting to spell out the epistemology of his 'enlightened national interest' phrase. But beware: he might well answer, 'I would not like to comment.'

If Prime Minister Manmohan Singh truly had national interest at heart, he would have spelt out at length why our country's almost entire nuclear science community's vicious but studied opposition to the Nuclear Energy Pact with the US is wrong and antinational. Why are scholars like Bharat Karnad repeatedly writing in the press warning the educated against that pact? The prime minister seemingly is unconcerned in his ensconced belief of 'enlightened national interest.'

If the man had the courage of a true patriot, he should convene a live televised debate on this pact with him facing nuclear experts, some former members of the armed forces and defence analysts. Assuring our ignorant Parliament that the pact was in our best interest and then telling President Bush that the deal had the backing of Parliament though Vajpayee (with 138 MPs in the Lok Sabha) objected to it is neither being honest nor courteous to a democratically elected Opposition.

If Manmohan Singh truly had national interest at heart, he would not have publicly defended Buta Singh's recommendation to dissolve the Bihar assembly and thereby undermined the sanctity of the Supreme Court judgment on the issue while also pooh poohing it as but a 3-2 verdict.

Manmohan enthralls media

If Manmohan Singh truly had national interest at heart, he would not have upheld his government's decisions on the gubernatorial mischief and malfeasance in Goa and Jharkhand.

If Manmohhan Singh truly had national interest at heart, he would not have described Sonia Gandhi's role as being 'a legitimate influence on the government' when the fact is that 'Madam' has been grafted into a bizarre, surreal constitutional position without being made accountable to Parliament in any which way.

Leave alone his newfound catchphrase of 'enlightened national interest,' our prime minister was not quite honest at his Q-and-A meeting the other day. He claimed credit for the national economy's conspicuous growth 'in the last three years' cleverly overlooking the fact that his UPA government came to power less than two years ago, and that economic policies take a couple of years to show results.

Analysis: What Dr Singh said

Similarly, he claimed credit for the excellent relations with the US and when the fact is that it was the NDA efforts that had brought a US President to our cities and villages so soon after the superpower had slapped a slew of sanctions on us. Ditto with China being made to agree by NDA to Sikkim being a part of India and to exchange the long outstanding matter of maps of the disputed borders.

Tailpiece: There was one small mercy at Manmohan Singh's press meet: he didn't describe the defreezing of Quattrochis's millions in London as an act of 'enlightened national interest.' And, considering the way he ridiculed L K Advani, that presumably is the act by which he'd like us to judge his work.

Arvind Lavakare

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 12

Sub: Different rules ?

How come Mr Lavakare never asked for a national televised debate when Mr Vajapai went in for a nuclear explosion ? How come when it ...

Posted by Haphar

Sub: In the national interest, Dr Singh?

Arvind Lavakare seems to be a true Indian. He has joined the 108 Indians in criticizing all that is done & said by the men ...

Posted by MSK Murthy

Sub: re: in the national interest

the author is totally biased. Obviously he hates the Congress and loves BJP. Sonia is extra-constitutional? What is that supposed to mean? Does she pass ...

Posted by Rahul

Sub: In the National interest, Mr PM

Our PM seems to have been inspired by (of all persons!) Musharraf (remember his "Enlightened moderatiion")in subjecting the Nation to his idea of "Enlightened National ...

Posted by VRP Sarathy

Sub: No self respect - this man

I agree with Arvind on all points. This man, our "Prime Minister", was known as a humble, honest man. People thought he could deliver. But ...

Posted by Rajeev



Copyright 2006 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.