Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article

Home > News > PTI

Arjun Singh mum on quotas

April 30, 2006 20:06 IST

In the eye of a political storm over the controversial move on reservations in elite educational institutions, Human Resource Development Minister Arjun Singh held an intriguing press conference on Sunday, which he refrained from openly pushing his pro-reservation agenda but subtly attacked his cabinet colleague Kapil Sibal who had given the impression of being opposed to quotas.

In the face of explanations sought from him by the Election Commission over the move for the reservations in the middle of election campaigning in five states, the 75-year-old Congress veteran maintained that 'my lips are sealed' and said that he would speak on the subject only after the assembly poll results are out on May 11.

But he faced a volley of questions on the issue, which he deftly deflected. The fact that Singh, who has avoided the media in the middle of the controversy over reservations, had called a press conference had generated speculation that he might have a major announcement to make.

However,he chose to talk on reservation without backtracking or openly advocating it and to project himself as a veteran warrior against the RSS, about which he distributed a long written statement.

In an apparent reference to Sibal's remarks in Germany, which were perceived to be anti-reservation, -- something the Science and Technology Minister since denied -- a reporter asked why should ministers speak out of turn, Singh said that 'it is certainly not desirable'.

He indirectly confirmed reports that he complained to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh against Sibal by stating that decorum prevents him from saying what he had toldDr Singhand it was for him to take a view in the matter.

Asked what his appeal was to students agitating against reservation, Singh said he would only appeal to them that they should not listen to those who were 'instigating' them.

Asked to comment on Rahul Gandhi saying that both pro and anti-reservationists have 'valid reasons', he said he would not say anything about it.

In the press conference, Singh fielded a wide range of questions, including the late prime minister P V Narasimha Rao's book on Ayodhya in which he projected himself as a scapegoat, Natwar Singh's diatribes against Congress and Uma Bharati floating a new political outfit.

On Natwar Singh's remarks that he was being targeted and the Congress was not being spoken of, Singh said, "The Congress is nowhere in the picture. I am confident that it has not compromised and will not compromise."

Noting that Natwar Singh's meeting with him a couple of daysago had no significance, he made it was plain that if the former minister has spoken, which was a breach of party discipline,action could be taken.

"All controversies end at the grave," he quipped while sidestepping comments on Rao's book. He also evaded replies to former minister M L Fotedar's charge that Manmohan Singh had sided with Narasimha Rao after the demolition of the Babri Masjid.

Complete coverage: The reservation issue

© Copyright 2006 PTI. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of PTI content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent.
Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 18

Sub: Alternative

What is the alternative to reservations for socially deprived and economically denied people?

Posted by unknown

Sub: Indian education caught between rock and hard place

while the current guy is trying to trash the Indian educational system through caste-based reservations, the previous guy tried to do trash it by polluting ...

Posted by Karthik

Sub: Arjun Singh mum on quotas

In the interest of the country, Arjun Singh should be retired from Politics at the first instance. He is another V P Singh and these ...

Posted by Ratnesh Sahay

Sub: ArjunSing mum on quotas

It is high time that the senile politicians in India are thrown in the dust bin. They grew up by guarding and building up quota ...

Posted by K. Balakrishnan

Sub: Reservation and minoirityism

It appears that the appeasing of the minorities and "the down trodden"has to be done with a balance.For example in Kerala each of the "minority" ...

Posted by VIG Menon



Copyright 2006 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.