Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article

Home > News > Report

'Advani's yatra will fail'

Sheela Bhatt in Ahmedabad | April 05, 2006 20:49 IST
Last Updated: April 06, 2006 01:46 IST

"The Suraksha Yatra of 2006 is different from L K Advani's previous rath yatras because this time he is dependent on Gujarat Chief Minister Narendra Modi for its success," said Achyut Yagnik, political analystand co-author of the book Creating a Nationality: Ramjanambhoomi Movement and the Fear of the Self.

Yagnik, Left-leaning thinker and writer, told that in 1990 when Advani embarked upon a yatra over the Ram Janmabhoomi temple issue Modi and Pramod Mahajan were the architects behind the yatra. They needed Advani to carve out their political careers out of the event and out of his towering leadership.

Complete Coverage: The BJP Yatra

Thesituation is reversed in 16 years. Advani's future now depends on Modi, feels Yagnik.

Yagnik saysthat Advani's first yatra was successful because in 1990, the Sangh Pariwar was with him. Today the pariwar is fractured. The Vishwa Hindu Parishad, Kisan Sangh and Bajrang Dal toiled forBJP's success then while today all three are against Advani.

The BJP's organisational capabilities have suffered due to the Sangh Pariwar's infighting making Advani's task difficult. "Advani wants to resurrect himself through this yatra. He wants to gain back credibility he lost within the party," claims Yagnik.

He said, "In 1990, the objective was clear and many Hindus because many were ready to support the idea of constructing a temple in Ayodhya. The 1990 yatra was culmination of something that started in form of Bharat Ekatma yatra in 1983 when gangajal was made the symbol of unity of India's Hindus."

Such symbolism to unite all shades of Hindus is missing this time. Yagnik argues that Shaktas (believers in Mother Goddesses), Shaiviites (followers of Lord Shiva) and Viashnavites (followers of Lord Vishnu) got united in favour of Ram temple movement but this yatra has no unifying theme.

On the charge that the Congress also doesn't enjoy credibility when it played communal politics after the Shah Banu judgment and that the charge of Muslim appeasement does stuck on it occasionally, Yagnik said, "Since 1970s the Congress have Muslims in their electoral politics formula, they are one of the pillars of Congress along with Dalits and tribals, just like the Hindus are for the BJP.

Yagnik says, "The so called appeasement of Muslims by the Congress or the issue of national security are issues worth taking up in Parliament or the press club. You can't communicate "security" of country meaningfully on the streets. And how are Muslims connected to problem of security?"

Advani said that he got the idea for a yatra after the news of the Muslims headcount in Indian Army by the Sachchar Committee were published.

Yagnik said that the facts of the Sachchar Committee and itsterms of reference are distorted by the BJP. Yagnik defends the attempt by saying, "In many states, Muslims are part of Other Backward Communities."

Yagnik concluded, "This yatra will not be successful."

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 4

Sub: Advani`s venture

I look at HIS venture differently.The most mature politician on streets of country communicating to all communities to leave agenda of hate,fall in nationalistic mainstream ...

Posted by ashwani arora

Sub: It is bound to fail.

Largely because the yatri is wrong. The yatri has proved his disloyalty towards the silent majority beyond words. This yatra is a joke that Lalji ...

Posted by chanakya

Sub: My message blocked

Why was my previous message blocked?

Posted by Dinesh

Sub: Illogical comparison

My commi friend Mr. Achyut Yagnik has twisted mind, that's why he is compairing a religious yatra with a pure polotical yatra. And to his ...

Posted by Dinesh



Copyright 2006 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.