Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article
Home > News > Report

House dissolution illegal, but poll to go on: SC

Onkar Singh in New Delhi and Anand Mohan Sahay in Patna | October 07, 2005 11:15 IST
Last Updated: October 07, 2005 13:21 IST

In a landmark judgment, the five-judge Constitutional bench of the Supreme Court held that the presidential order to dissolve the Bihar assembly earlier this year was unconstitutional.

However, the court refused to interfere with the election process already motion and restore the dissolved state assembly.

Coverage: The February 2005 Bihar election

In a majority judgment, the bench -- comprising Justices Y K Sabbarwal, K G Balakrishnan,B N Aggarwal, Ashok Bhan and Arijit Pasayat -- ordered that the 'status quo ante' cannot be ordered as the electoral process had already been set in motion.

'The Constitutional bench has gone into the laid down procedures wherein the court has refused to interfere in the electoral process once elections have been called by the Election Commission,' the bench noted.

Meanwhile, Bharatiya Janata Party general secretary and noted Supreme Court advocate Arun Jaitley welcomed the apex court's decision.

Talking to reporters after the judgment, Jaitley said even if the court's verdict had gone the other way and restored the state assembly, then it would have been a win-win situation for the National Democratic Alliance.

Jaitley said the court had passesthe severest strictures against the state and central governments, and demanded that Bihar Governor Buta Singh be recalledimmediately.

BJP presidentL K Advani and NDA convener George Fernandes will call on President A P J Abdul Kalam on October 10 and apprise him of the situation following the Supreme Court order.

NDA's chief ministerial candidate for Bihar Nitish Kumar demanded the resignation of Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and the recall of Governor Buta Singh.

"The prime minister succumbed to pressure, and from which quarters, is known to everybody," he said, adding, "Dr Singh should step down immediately as his contention that the worst type of horse-trading prompted the Union cabinet to recommend the House dissolution, has been proved wrong by the highest court of the land."

"We stand vindicated.... we had said the House was dissolved unconstitutionally and the Supreme Court too has accepted our contention," Nitish told reporters in Patna.

"The whole exercise (of dissolution) was motivated by political lust," he added.

Nitish also announced that the NDA will make this issuethe main poll plank during the ongoing campagning inthe state assembly polls.

"We will go to the people during campaigning with the apex court ruling and urge them to do justice with us," he said.

With PTI inputs

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 19

Sub: Kalam is also culpable

Why did President Kalam sign the proclamation in such a great hurry, at "midnight"? He had the option of seeking the opinion of his legal ...

Posted by Cogito_ergo...

Sub: SC refuses to stay

Bhuttasingh, the Lalu's man[Lalu has said]and the central cabinet headed by Mr. manmohan singh-- Prime minister[Sonia's man]Played a nasty drama and the Hon. president ratified ...

Posted by Vengatampally,chicago

Sub: All is not LOST

The supreme court descison has made clear . ALL IS NOT LOST. There is place in country where these blind politicians can get a lesson. ...

Posted by Anuj Goyal

Sub: Dissolution of Bihar assembly

The order of supreme court has clearly pointed out that the dissolution of assembly of Bihar was illigal. It is sad that the persident of ...

Posted by Angel

Sub: S C Judgement on Dissolution of assembly

It is a justice in all respect. The verdict is quite balanced and equitable. We shall understand the democratic process in better way and appeal ...

Posted by Ravi S Pandey



Copyright 2005 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.