Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article
Home > News > PTI

Natwar's son questions Volcker report's credibility

November 03, 2005 04:14 IST

External Affairs Minister K Natwar Singh's son and Congress legislator Jagat Singh on Wednesday night said the owner of an Indian company that had allegedly paid surcharge to a Swiss firm to import oil from Iraq was his friend.

Volcker panel, which investigated the oil-for-food scam, mentioned in a report that Natwar Singh was a beneficiary of Iraq's oil-for-food programme.

Jagat Singh told NDTV that Andleep Sehgal, owner of Hamdaan Exports, which had allegedly paid surcharge on behalf of Swiss company Masefield AG for the oil import, was his friend but made it clear 'that does not make me privy to his business dealings'.

He also said the Volcker committee had not sought any reaction from his father, though it had got in touch with some other individuals and companies named in the report, sought their opinion and response and had given them a chance to defend themselves.

"You can make any allegation against anybody... but you have to substantiate. The report has talked about my father being a 'non-contractual beneficiary'. But what exactly does that mean... They have kept it open-ended," Jagat Singh said.

Even the Russian and French governments have denied similar charges and said the documents and signatures on them were fakes, he said.

Asked whether they were contemplating legal action, Jagat Singh said no decision had yet been taken on the matter.

To a question on whether he would agree to a probe into the matter in India, he said though he had not been named himself, 'I am sure my father will stick to his statement' that he was ready to face an inquiry.

The Congress MLA from Rajasthan said he had no contact, no dealings with and never heard of (Zurich-based firm) Masefield AG.

Jagat Singh said Paul Volcker had never contacted Natwar Singh for his reaction 'neither on telephone, nor on the Internet and nor through mail. I fail to understand how he could make such a major omission... my father is no ordinary citizen. He is the External Affairs Minister and has great responsibilities'.

Admitting he had visited Iraq twice as a youth Congress member, he said once he was part of a Congress delegation led by his father and on another occasion to attend a youth Conference called by former Iraqi President Saddam Hussein's Baath Party where delegates from over 100 countries had gathered to seek lifting of sanctions against Iraq.

"Even the National Democratic Alliance government at that time was also of the view that the sanctions should be lifted," Jagat Singh said, adding an NDA delegation had also visited Iraq including Ram Naik and Najma Heptullah.

Asked if he was questioning the credibility of Volcker report, Jagat Singh said 'absolutely'.

© Copyright 2005 PTI. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of PTI content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent.
Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 5

Sub: is volcker from nda-mr jagat singh?

is volcker from nda-mr jagat singh?if you do not know the answer ,please ask other members of the upa

Posted by sudhir suri

Sub: most upright pm -nost tainted cabinet

most upright pm -nost tainted cabinet,this will go down in the histoty ofpost partition india.

Posted by sudhir suri

Sub: Creditability certificate from Natwar's son

Now we have to get a certificate from the minister son. Well what will they think of next. The congress never seem to suprise me ...

Posted by sg

Sub: Volcker report is bullshit

Vollcker report is american conspiracy to tarnish the image of the capable and good Indian Foreign minister Mr.Natwar Singh Sahab.

Posted by vijay

Sub: Natwar Singh

I am not sure if Mr.Natwar Singh is guilty as per the Volcker's Report or not. But I am a bit amused to read that ...

Posted by Malathi iyer



Copyright 2005 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.