Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Home > News > First Look

Mumbai's Wailing Wall

January 20, 2005

The Mannat-e-Deewar has become Mumbaikars' Wailing Wall since the Mumbai Festival began recently.

As you pass along the seaface across the Mumbai Police Gymkhana you come across this facade festooned by suggestions about how to make the city better.

The neat, white chits are provided by the young volunteers of JSW, which is organising the art and heritage part of the festival.

The 'Mannat for Mumbai' wall is aflutter with suggestions, some ranging from plain 'I love Mumbai' to more thoughtful attempts like 'Lets all get together to keep up the spirit...'

The idea is to get the 10 best suggestions and forward them to the state government for action.

The messages come in all languages, typical of Mumbai's cosmopolitan nature... all tied to a grille by bright threads.

The wall is special in more ways.

Embedded are seven paintings by seven artists, each one expressing his/her feelings about Mumbai. The artists are Rina Saini Kallat, Justin Ponmany, Apnavi Thacker, Riyas Komu, Baiju Parthan, Sudarshan Shetty and Bose Krishnamachari.

Simple messages from passersby are the ones drawing attention.

Girish Bhatt (seen in the pic), 70, has been a Mumbaikar for more than six decades. His message is a simple: 'I love Mumbai and wish the best for it.'

How come he doesn't have even one little grouse to write about? "I don't want to break my head on the wall of corruption in the government," he says. Couldn't be put better or more pithily.

One says, "I need a job. Could the government reduce the population, so it is easier to get a job?"

Another says, "When will I see Mumbai as Shanghai?"

Perhaps the strangest suggestion is this: "There should be no difference between men and women." That's one the government can't do even if all corruption ends!

Photo: Jewella Miranda; Text: George J

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 4

Sub: mannat-e-deewaar ????

Should be deewaar-e-mannat, not the other way round! THIS (the wall says, "Pl give me my proper name") would be the prayer of the wall ...

Posted by Dileep

Sub: clean India

Dear Whom So Ever It concerns, I did my hotel management from in Chennai in 2000 and worked for hotels like Sheraton and the oberoi ...

Posted by Iyer Arun swaminathan

Sub: sugestions for a better mumbai

I have been a resident of mumbai for sometime but am currently settled in australia. I would say mumbai is far behind the present world ...

Posted by vaishali

Sub: traffic in mumbai

we want our traffic cops to improve the way they handle traffic in mumbai & reduce the congestion on main arterial roads in peak hours. ...

Posted by sanjay ahuja


Article Tools Email this article
Print this article
Contact the editors

Copyright © 2005 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.