Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article
Home > News > Columnists > Colonel Anil A Athale (retd)

Are we now a nation of shameless people?

October 19, 2004

India is a meaningless mass of amorphous humanity:' Oswald Spangler, The Decline of the West

A fewdays ago when a group of 16 Pakistani journalists visited the Jammu camp of Kashmiri Pandit refugees from the valley, there were unruly scenes. Many victims of terrorist violence beggedthe Pakistani journalists to ask their country to stop the violence and help them return to their homes.

The reaction of the visiting Pakistani journalists is not known but it ought to make every single of the one billion plus Indians hang their heads in shame. Here is a peaceful community of over 300,000, that was driven out of their ancestralhomes 14 years ago and have been living in pathetic conditions for all of those 14 years. What was the 'crime' of these people other than the fact that they practiced a religion different from the majority? Did they commit any atrocity against the majority?

True, Kashmiri Pandits are not the only such unfortunate people. Palestinians have been enduring this for the last 57 years! But there is a crucial difference, the plight of Palestinians is recognised by the entire world. India, as the self appointed 'mukhiya' [leader] of the Non Aligned countries, has been championing their cause. But 'we the people of a secular, democratic and socialist Republic of India' have resolutely and totally put them out of sight and out of mind.

The Kashmiri Pandit exodustook place in the early1990s. Since then we have had six prime ministers -- from V P Singh to Manmohan Singh, and three different parties have ruled India, including the ostensibly 'Hindu Nationalist'Bharatiya Janata Party. Yet all of themhave ignored the plight of thePandits and did nothing to end their suffering.

Also Read: Francois Gautier: Who cares for the Pandits?

The ever so alert judiciary that intervenes in issues ranging from the use of CNGin Delhi, topollution, to even the selection of hockey teams, does not look at the fate of 300,000 Indian citizens who have been denied their basic rights guaranteed under the Constitution. What stopped the Honourable Lordships fromtaking a suo moto cognisance of this injustice?

The sad plight of Pandits has also not touched the conscience of the ever so sensitive 'human rights' groups in India. The Teesta Setalvads and Javed Anands, the MedhaPatkars or Arundhati Roys of this world have been deafeningly silenton this issue. There are no street plays,no documentaries or painting exhibitions on the sad state of these 300,000 Indians. The news media, both print and television, have shown no inclination to highlight their cause.

Also Read: Sharanarthi: The Forgotten Ones

The political parties, government machinery,judiciary, mediaand the NGOs, have all failed to fight for the cause of these haplesspeople. The people at large have been apathetic. In no elections was this ever made an issue by any party. The common refrain seems 'how does it bother me!.'

Indians as a people have a short historical memory. It is precisely this attitude that helped the British gobble up the whole country, one region at a time. Thus while Robert Clive was busy finishing off Siraj-ud-Daulah in Bengal, Shah Shuja in Awadh was least concerned, till the British did not turn against him. In 1799, the Marathas watched the British under Duke of Wellington decimate Tipu Sultan, knowing fully well that it would be their turn next. After 150 years of slavery, nothing seems to have changed in this land of Bharatvarsha.

As a former soldier I feel ashamed that with the world's third largest army, we are unable to ensure the safety and security of our own citizens.

Has India reached that advanced stage of decay that we are now a nation of shameless people?

Guest Column

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 108

Sub: I will pass your message to everybody I know.

I really appreciate the author who dared to open the eyes of Indians about a big problem , but ignored by all.

Posted by rajeev

Sub: good article...

An amazing article. Thought provoking and trying to create ripples in the dead intellectual souls who govern.Indian govt should bring to light to UN on ...

Posted by Deepak Sood

Sub: Absolutely right

The author of this article is right when he says this. We are ahead in technology, agriculture and such other fields but when it comes ...

Posted by Amit Dhokre

Sub: Are we shame less?

Yes& No, I am sorry about the Pandits , I hope and pray something comes out the new deals , but PAKISTAN cannot be trusted ...

Posted by nandu

Sub: Very frustrating indeed

Does the rules of engagement only hold for the Indian army in Kashmir? Why are terrorist leaders-jealots responsible for killing thousand of innocent Kashmiri pandits ...

Posted by projjal roy



Copyright 2005 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.