Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article

Home > News > Report

Church, Left come closer in Kerala

George Iype in Kochi | July 05, 2004 20:11 IST

Forty-five years after a Church-led 'liberation struggle' in Kerala pulled down the world's first democratically elected Communist government, the Left parties and the Church in India are cozying up. And you have the Manmohan Singh government to thank for this unlikely occurrence.

Ever since the Congress-led United Progressive Alliance government came to power in New Delhi, senior leaders of the Indian Church have been 'praising' the Left parties.

The Catholic Bishops Conference of India has lauded the UPA government's common minimum programme as onethat will "bring social justice, economic prosperity, and communal harmony".

In the past, the Left leaders' atheism and rigid ideologies have earned them the Church's wrath. In 1957, the Church led a 'liberation struggle' against Kerala's first communist government led by the late E M S Namboodiripad.

The Church's opposition was based on the belief that the Communists, who are atheists, would deprive it of control over its educational institutions. The agitation eventually led to Namboodiripad's government being dismissed by the Centre in 1959.

Since then, the Church and the Left have been "sworn enemies".

But these days you can see a sea change in the Church's approach to the Communists. Last week, Cardinal Varkey Vithayathil of the Syro-Malabar Church extolled the 'charity mission' of the Communist Party of India, Marxists.

"The CPI-M takes special care of the poor and the marginalized in India," Cardinal Vithayathil said. "Other political parties should emulate the CPI-M."

Inaugurating a palliative care unit in a hospital founded by the CPI-M in memory of the late trade union leader A P Varkey in Kochi, the cardinal extended what he called the Catholic Church's "whole-hearted support to the charitable programmes of the CPI-M". He also recalled how CPI-M-ruled West Bengal had been supporting the missions of Mother Teresa in Calcutta.

Cardinal Vithayathil is not alone in showering praise on the Left. CBCI president Cardinal Telesphore P Toppo of the Ranchi archdiocese and Bishop Thattunkal of the Cochin diocese have also appreciated the Communists in the last one week.

According to Bishop Thattunkal, the Communist parties and the Church need not hate each other any more. "The Church has no ill-will towards the Communists," the bishop told, adding that the Church appreciates any political party that carries outwelfare and developmental works for the people.

Cardinal Vithayathil's admiration for the Communist leaders has in turn earned him praise from the Left leaders.

But many Church leaders have been taken aback by the top hierarchy's sudden admiration for the Communists. "Yes, we are moving closer to the Communists because that is one party that has clear programmes for the poor and needy," a Church leader pointed out. "Maybe the feeling of friendship with the Leftists is because of the new Manmohan Singh government."

Church leaders maintain that Prime Minister Singh's recent announcement of special privileges for the minorities was "made possible because of the influence the Left Front has in the Congress-led government".

On Saturday, the prime minister proposed to establish a commission for minority educational institutions to provide direct affiliation of minority professional institutions with the central universities. He also announced the setting up of a national commission to enhance the welfare of socially and economically backward sections.

But senior Church leader Father Thomas Parathara said it is "wrong to say that the Church and the Left parties are in any new-found love."

Father Parathara told, "The Church's mission is social and economic development of the people. We also want the political problems of the people to be take care of by the parties. We appreciate any political party that does good for the people and their development."

More reports from Kerala

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 7

Sub: Future of Left

This makes clear about the double standards that Christians are displaying. About Left, as one person rightly said: "If there exists any future for the ...

Posted by Srinand

Sub: Church & Madam Sonia

Churh will rule India through Sonia, as she is the Supremo of Congress.

Posted by Mukesh

Sub: secular

If an hindu organization would have commented this, this will be a question to the secular credentials of India and harming its secular fabric. Hypocrites.. ...

Posted by sravan

Sub: Now you see the clear definition of ''secularism''.

Hello All! Now we see the what these Christian bigots mean by secularism! In a Hindu country they want equal(or more than equal) treatment by ...

Posted by Mysore Madhwa

Sub: left and the church

coming together of christians and left will spell disaster for india muslims and christians are trying to eliminate hindus from india slowly but steadily only ...

Posted by gaurav



Copyright 2006 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.