Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article

Home > News > Report

Gujarat cop accused of burying evidence

Sheela Bhatt in New Delhi | August 25, 2004 12:40 IST

Senior Sub-Inspector R J Patil of Kalol police station, Panchmahal district, Gujarat, was on Monday night arrested for 'destroying evidence' related to some Gujarat riots cases.

Patil allegedly helped the accused in disposing off 14 bodies. Investigations have revealed that he also clubbed seven cases, which accounted for 14 murders, into one first information report†and closed the file.

Also Read

SC delivers one more blow to Modi

SC tells Gujarat to reopen riot cases

It's the first arrest by Gujarat police of one of its own officers in connection with the riots cases.

The tribal areas of Panchmahal had witnessed some of the worst violence in Gujarat in the aftermath of the February 27, 2002 Godhra carnage.

Over 50 people, mostly pilgrims returning from Ayodhya were burnt alive when miscreants set two bogies of Sabarmati Express afire near the Godhra railway station. The incident sparked off riots in large parts of Gujarat, leaving over 1000 people dead.

Two of the worst incidents in Panchmahal had taken place near Delol, where 23 Muslims were killed; and near Ambica Society†in Kalol.

Investigators have found glaring loopholes in the way the Ambica Society incident was investigated by Patil and his team.

Patil allegedly helped in the disposal of the bodies without the knowledge of the victims' relatives.

For all the violent incidents that took place near Ambica Society on March 1, 2002, including 11 murders, Patil filed only one first information report.

In this FIR he also included some other violent incidents that had taken place the same day in other parts of the town as also riot and arson cases from nearby Boru and Alindra villages.

The senior sub-inspector's arrest followed investigations by Special Investigating Officer Neerja Gotru.

Gotru assisted Inspector General of Police Rakesh Asthana, much before the Supreme Court directed the Gujarat government on August 17 to reopen over 2000 riots cases, in re-investigating cases that were closed either on the grounds that the accused were untraceable or that there was no credible evidence available.

Last year, after the Supreme Court ordered the Gujarat police to file a report on the Bilkis Bano rape case, the then police chief K Chakravarthy directed Asthana to look into all rape, murder and other serious riots cases closed summarily for want of evidence.

Additional Director General of Police (CID, crime) Kuldip Sharma monitored the investigations.

Gotru, who was then superintendent of police, Amreli, was chosen as a special investigating officer and was handed over four rape cases.

Gotru, who camped at the Kalol police station, found that soon after the March 1, 2002 incidents, the local police had collected some material evidence and put it on record in the station diary. Among the items were some bones.

The records mentioned that the bones were sent to a laboratory in Baroda for tests. Patil, however, did not follow up the tests before closing the case.

Mukhtar Ahmed, a social activist in Kalol, said: "Police officers, who have not fulfilled their duty in the riots cases, should be punished more severely than the accused. If an accused is to be hanged, the police should be hanged 10 times."

When the Ambica Society incident happened, Patil's senior was Deputy Superintendent of Police Dinesh Parmar, whose role is also likely to be scrutinised.

It is believed in political circles in Gujarat that equations between the police and the state establishment have changed after the change of guard in New Delhi. The pressure from the Supreme Court has also played its role.

Several police officers who had acted under political compulsion are now feeling the heat,†particularly after the SC order to reopen over 2,000 riots cases.

A senior Indian Police Service officer told "We were used after the riots. We will become scapegoats now."

A majority of the accused in the Ambica Society case have strong political connections. Ajay Soni and Dilip Dave, main accused in the Ambica Society cases, are members of the Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh.

More reports from Gujarat
Read about: Gujarat Riots | Earthquake hits India

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 6

Sub: Is there an end to all this violence?

Is there really an end to all this blood-letting or will it continue unabated? y can't people accept the fact that no society or for ...

Posted by shahab

Sub: one criminal cop gets arrested out of 10,000 criminal cops

Tens of thousands of Patils [Senior Sub-Inspector R J Patil of Kalol police station, Panchmahal district, Gujarat]went totally unpunished since independence because of the following ...

Posted by soma

Sub: Godhra ...

Dude, Ever heard of anybody getting arrested and punished for burning the train and killing people .... was just wondering ... What about some thousands ...

Posted by js

Sub: Introspection

No doubt.. whoever is guilty should be punished. But why do we see only those persons who were involved in riots? Why donít we see ...

Posted by Kapil Bhati

Sub: Discrimination

It is disgusting that in our country life of Hindus had become considerably cheaper than that of Muslims. Everyone is sheding tears in loss of ...

Posted by Deepak Singh



Copyright © 2006 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.