The Web


Home > News > The Gujarat Riots > Report

Muslims welcome SC order on Gujarat

Ehtasham Khan in New Delhi | August 17, 2004 14:54 IST
Last Updated: August 17, 2004 15:06 IST

Prominent Muslim groups and individuals on Tuesday welcomed the Supreme Court order asking the Gujarat government to reopen 2,000-odd riot cases.

Out of the 4,200-odd cases of violence and sexual assault lodged in Gujarat, the police had closed around 2,000 cases saying the culprits could not be traced.

Discuss the SC order

Abdul Hameed Nomani, spokesman, Jamiat Ulama-e-Hind, said: "It is a good decision. We welcome the Supreme Court order. We hope that the victims will get justice and the culprits will be brought to book."

Jamiat has built 1,000 homes for people who lost their homes during the violence in Gujarat in February-March 2002.

The Supreme Court had earlier shifted two important cases -- the Best Bakery and the Bilkis Banu gang-rape -- out of Gujarat. The order was on the plea that the accused and the police harassed the witnesses and the victims.

Nomani said: "The police tried its best to save the culprits by closing the cases. But the court said no. Open the cases and investigate it again. It is a great decision."

S Q R Ilyas, spokesman, All India Muslim Personal Law Board, said: "It is an extraordinary order. People were losing faith in judiciary. This order will restore confidence in the victims and the minorities in general."

But the community leaders said it was unlikely that the victims would get justice.

"The same police will investigate these cases. So it is unlikely that they [police] will let anything go against them. We all know the role that the police played during and after the riots. That is why two cases were earlier transferred out of Gujarat," said Ilyas.

"Still this order will act as a deterrence. The message is clear: nobody is above law in this country."

The court has ordered the director general of police of Gujarat to report every three months regarding the progress of the cases.

Nomani said: "Monitoring is necessary. If the court monitors the progress regularly then we hope that justice would be done."

Shafi Monis, vice-president, Jamat-e-Islami, said: "This country is ruled by law. And nobody can play with it. If the Supreme Court takes interest in these cases in future also then it will give a good signal."

Freelance writer Andalib Akhter said: "The Supreme Court is setting a good trend. People should learn a lesson that you can not take everything for granted."

The Gujarat Riots: The Complete Coverage

Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 15

Sub: simple logic

Its a very simple thing to understand...if muslims want everything....and if they feel pained living in this country, who the hell is stopping them from ...

Posted by ram

Sub: Godhra

Hundreds of muslims were arrested under POTA for burning the train. Nobody, hindu or muslim is above the law. The SC judgement is against selective ...

Posted by vijay

Sub: Muslims....

Two points to be mentioned here: One, are these the same Muslims, who are now hailing Supreme Court and its order on Gujarat, who refused ...

Posted by Ashok

Sub: A historic decision

The Supreme Court direction for reopening the Gujarat riot case is historic.It is a welcome decision not only in the context of Gujarat riots but ...

Posted by M M Ashraf

Sub: Stop this minority drama and cribing and crying about religion

When will we grow beyond religion and castism... When are the muslims going to be stopped from being considered a minority? They account for a ...

Posted by N Patel


Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Write us a letter
Discuss this article

Related Stories

Kalam rejects Dhananjay's plea

AP HC stays Muslim reservation

SYL row: Notices to six states

People Who Read This Also Read

Best Bakery witness disappears

Copyright © 2005 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.