Search:



The Web

Rediff







Home > News > The Ayodhya Issue > Report


ASI report on Ayodhya one sided: Habib

September 12, 2003 18:03 IST

Noted historian Irfan Habib has described the Archaeological Survey of India's report on Ayodhya as 'one sided'.

He also questioned the credibility of the report accusing the ASI of having 'deliberately altered' the names of historical periods in its finds.

"The ASI report has deliberately altered the names of historical period under political motivation," he said. "The report is a deliberate attempt to suppress the truth, it failed to conduct a tabulation of the animal bones found during the excavation of the disputed sites."

"These animal bones have been recovered from various levels of different periods and the ASI report should have tabulated the bones by periods, levels and trenches and should have also specified the species of animals," he added.

Habib claimed the ASI report 'offers not a single example of any medieval temple where pillars stood on the brick-basis which have been found on the site'.

He said the presence of Buddhist, Jain or Shivaite stones  and terracotta should also be taken into account because the so-called composite Buddhist, Jain and Shivaite temple of the type which the ASI is indirectly trying to suggest has 'till date never been found in India'.


The Ayodhya Issue: The Complete Coverage


Share your comments


 What do you think about the story?




Read what others have to say:


Number of User Comments: 11




Sub: only truth

Mr. Habib is right. Mr. habib keep it up. it is not only you but also some renowned archeologists have told the same . actually ...


Posted by ramchand





Sub: Qustion's for Mr.Javed Habib.

Dear Mr. Habib , If by sitting at your home u can decide the structure below the demolished mosque is a mosque ..only by referring ...


Posted by Debashish





Sub: Unexpected Comment from Mr.Habib

Mr. Habib is a historian not an archeologist and hence such comments are shocking, coming from a great intellectual like Mr. Habib. The ASI people ...


Posted by Brave Heart





Sub: Irfan Habib and ASI report

What else can one expect from this historian whose fundamentalist credentials are so much stronger than his professional credentials? The surprise is that you should ...


Posted by Mukunda Rao





Sub: IRFAN HABIB ON ASI FINDINGS.

Findings based on excavation work has to be always one sided- the truth. You can't have a report based on actual findings to satisfy both ...


Posted by J.N. Kini




Disclaimer





Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Write us a letter
Discuss this article










Copyright © 2005 rediff.com India Limited. All Rights Reserved.