Rediff India Abroad
 Rediff India Abroad Home  |  All the sections


The Web

India Abroad

Sign up today!

Article Tools
Email this article
Top emailed links
Print this article
Contact the editors
Discuss this article

Home > News > PTI

Indian scholar challenges Newton's law

June 04, 2003 12:53 IST

An Indian technologist in Australia has challenged Newton's First Law of Motion and called for a revision of the classical theory in the light of modern technology.

According to Newton's First Law of Motion an object at rest tends to stay at rest and an object in motion tends to stay in motion, unless acted upon by an external force.

Arindam Banerjee, an alumnus of the Indian Institute of Technology-Kharagpur,argued in his recentbook, To The Stars!, that contrary to Newton'stheory an object can actually be moved without application of any external force.

"Central to mytheory is the proposal that our understanding of Newton's First Law of Motion should be revised," the 47-year-old research technologist, who works for Telstra in Melbourne, told PTI.

Based on his unconventional theory, Banerjee has described in a technical paper, a design for a 'perpetual motion machine,' which can generate energy without burning any kind of fossil fuel or using any radioactive process.

Called the Internal Force Engine, Banerjee claims it would never run out of power because it is 'self charging' without the need for any external source of energy.

"It is a machine drivenby energy internal to the body and can achieve unlimited kinetic energy within a short span of time, using much less energy obtained from external sources like a battery," he said.

The balance energy generated thus is free and could be produced indefinitely if a feedback loop is created in the system, Banerjee contended.

The technologist has created an electro-magneticallypropelled Internal Force Moved Body, which demonstrates that objects can be made to move from rest without friction, without expelling mass at high speed (as in rockets) or without any externally applied force, thus violating Newton's First Law of Motion.

Through a series of complex cycles involving a hydraulic system that channelises oppositely directed kinetic energies, Banerjee's IFMB produces ever increasing velocity with each cycle with 'no upper limit' to the velocity that it can reach.

Though his theory is based on the assumption that our present understanding of the Law of Conservation of Energy (which says: Energy can neither be created nordestroyed)is flawed, Banerjee clarified that certain new concepts arising out of his own postulations would have to get a firm footing first.

"For instance, the concept of 'internal force,' 'internal force moved body' and 'velocity addition' as proposed in the new theory would need innovations in the fields of electromagnetic and hydraulic systems," he said.

Successful implementation of the concept, fortified with designs and mathematical derivations, could mean a gradual elimination of the conventional sources of energy (fossil fuels) ensuring a pollution-free environment, the technology expert said.

The theory could also be used to describe the principles for the design of interstellar spacecrafts using the perpetual motion machine, Banerjee pointed out.

"Designing an engine that delivers more power than it takes to run has been a dream for all engineers. This concept has the potential to create a portable, cheap and no-noise machine to propel even huge systems," he said.

More reports from West Bengal
© Copyright 2005 PTI. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of PTI content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent.
Share your comments

 What do you think about the story?

Read what others have to say:

Number of User Comments: 102

Sub: Look before you leap

Dear Niharika, don't get into a frenzy so soon. It is anyway too premature to say anything about the authenticity of Banarjee's claims (personally I ...

Posted by niraj prasad

Sub: Do accept

Though I m not a physics scolar, for me it seems it is true. I can also question that which external force helps the planets ...

Posted by Loganath Siva

Sub: Not so easy to put aside!

If 500 years earlier you told someone that earth is flat he would have thought that you are a big fool. Today if you say ...

Posted by Chakravarthy Akella

Sub: This is a fake article

Look at the number of terms in quotes - 'self charging' 'no upper limit' 'internal force' 'perpetual motion machine' - this claim is just to ...

Posted by Vitthaljar

Sub: More on Mr. Banerjee

I searched and found Mr Banerjee's website. Man, does he ever meander on and on and on. I don't know if the physics...well, add up ...

Posted by BigMooseInCanada



Copyright 2006 India Limited. All Rights Reserved.