Search:



The Web

Rediff








Home > Movies > Reviews


Shah Rukh shines in Swades

Sita Menon | December 17, 2004 12:25 IST

So the big question is: Is Swades IT?

Here's a look at the baggage it carries:

  • Director Ashutosh Gowariker's Lagaan was one of the biggest hits in 2001.

  • Lagaan also won an Oscar nomination in the Best Foreign Language Film category.

  • Swades has approximately Rs 300 million (Rs 30 crores) riding on it, and that much to make up.

    Here's looking at what it has going for it:

  • Swades stars today's unrivalled superstar, Shah Rukh Khan.

    Pause.

    So is Swades IT?

    It's gotta be said: N-O.

    Would you like to review this film? Send us your review!

  • A few observations:

    It is the first movie in a long, long while that has one lone plot point driving it from start to end.

    Don't Miss!


    Special: All about Swades


    Mohan Bhargava (Shah Rukh), a project manager working on a rainfall monitoring satellite known as Global Precipitation Measurement at NASA, is struck by the most acute form of guilt when he visits India to meet the nanny he considers as his mother (Kishori Balal).

    Faced with poverty, caste system, illiteracy, child labour, lack of electricity and a host of other ills that plague India, he decides to channelise his energies into doing his bit for Charanpur (a fictional village said to be about 200 km off Delhi).

    Doing his bit translates to 'lighting a bulb,' as his superior John Stockton (a completely wooden Peter Rawley) patronisingly calls it, for his village.

    It is a Rs 300 million, three-and-half-hour long moral science lesson.

    Detailing a man's journey is all very well, but here is a film that reminds you of those social awareness documentaries that play just before the start of a feature film in theatres across India.

    Sure, no one doubts the sincerity of the idea behind making Swades. Conceptually, it is totally noble. But there is something amiss when you have to drive your point home in every frame of the movie. Especially when you have to say it out loud, rather than show it as a film is supposed to do.

    Some people would call it talking down to the audience. Taking the audience for granted. Preaching.

    And that is what makes Swades laboured viewing. There is so much morality thrown at you that it soon ceases to be a feature film.

    It just becomes one long, giant moral science lesson.

    The patchy screenplay, confused production design (Nitin Desai), incohesive editing (Ballu Saluja), unimpressive cinematography (Mahesh Aney) and the very 'scripted' dialogues (K P Saxena) are totally secondary, given the larger picture.

    And, for once, the songs in the movie -- composed by A R Rahman -- actually come as a welcome relief from the narrative.

    That begs the question: Is this the same person who directed Lagaan?

    But here are the two main positives of the film:

    1. Shah Rukh Khan.

    For the first time in a long, long while, Shah Rukh Khan, the actor, IS the role he plays: Mohan Bhargava. And that is one thing director Ashutosh Gowariker should be credited for.

    Gayatri JoshiShah Rukh Khan is sincere, takes you through the gamut of the journey his character experiences, even brings in shades to Mohan Bhargava's character. This may not be his 'best,' but this will definitely go down as one of his most 'genuine' performances.

    Newcomer Gayatri Joshi, as Gita, the village schoolteacher, and Mohan's love interest, is fairly competent.

    2. And the second positive: Director Gowariker's intentions behind making Swades. It is admirable that he keeps the movie well-grounded and down-to-earth throughout, not succumbing to any commercial pressures.

    But all said and done, 'Houston, we [definitely] have a problem.' :-)

    Want to see Swades? Check out http://tickets.rediff.com/



  • Want to see this movie? Check out Rediff Movie Tickets!

    Share your comments


     What do you think about the story?




    Read what others have to say:


    Number of User Comments: 226




    Sub: So what is it about Swades?

    After having watched this film 5-7 times in the last one year I can say that this is one of the most original and well ...


    Posted by Aditya Kannan Iyer





    Sub: swades is an excellent movie

    I think that swades is the best of all the movies i have seen till date. Shah rukh is mind blowing in this movie.This movie ...


    Posted by shreya gupta





    Sub: Magical

    Hi! Well I have'nt seen the movie as I study in Australia but started liking this movie as I think this movie relates to every ...


    Posted by Puneet





    Sub: Disappointing....review

    Sorry I checked in late.. but after readin one of the most unimpressive movie reviews.. i must say.. Rediff.. get some better writers. 'Swades'is one ...


    Posted by Kunal Chandra





    Sub: hi

    ashutosh had done a great job for posting idea of SWADES


    Posted by sourabh




    Disclaimer




    Article Tools
    Email this article
    Top emailed links
    Print this article
    Write us a letter
    Discuss this article


    Related Stories


    How well do you know Swades?

    Swades: The rediff connection

    Veer-Zaara: Instant hit abroad!









    Click here for More Reviews





    Copyright © 2005 rediff.com India Limited. All Rights Reserved.