|
Modern day Sholay must star Ajay Devgan, Vivek Oberoi, Manoj Bajpai
Rediff readers' poll on what if Ramesh Sippy's classic were remade today
|
Have your say!
Choose your cast and crew for a modern Sholay
Tue Dec 3 18:23:41 2002
Name:gurindersony
City, Country:barcelona,(spain)
Your Views:sunny diol as verru
ajay devgan as jai
rani mukharji as basanti
amrish puri as gabbar singh
raj k. santoshi director
Tue Dec 3 18:36:43 2002
Name:Dev
City, Country:USA
Your Views:Amitabh Bachchan: Thakur
Nana Patekar: Gabbar Singh
Govinda: Veeru
Karishma: Basanti
Ajay Devgan: Jai
Kajol: Radha
Tue Dec 3 18:36:47 2002
Name:Rajiv
City, Country:India
Your Views:Jai - Hrithik
Veeru - Vivek
Gabbar - Manoj Bajpai
Basanthi - Kareena
Tue Dec 3 18:37:26 2002
Name:BALAJI IYER
City, Country:MUMBAI INDIA
Your Views:jai - vivek oberoi
veeru : saif khan
basanti : shilpa shetty
music: viju shah
direction : raj kumar santoshi
Tue Dec 3 18:37:39 2002
Name:kunal
City, Country:ahmedabad,india
Your Views:todays no actor will fit for the star cast for sholay
Tue Dec 3 18:40:43 2002
Name:Sholay_fan
City, Country:Bangalore/india
Your Views:Jai: Amitabh
Veeru: Dharmendra
Gabbar : Amjad Khan
Basanti: Hema
Director: G.P.Sippy
No one can replace them...it is not at all possible.
Tue Dec 3 18:40:51 2002
Name:k rohinton
City, Country:Mumbai,India
Your Views:Jai Aamir Khan,
Veeru Shahrukh Khan,
Gabbar Ajay Devgan,
Basanti Rani
Tue Dec 3 18:43:18 2002
Name:Ajay Arora
City, Country:Faridabad, India
Your Views:Veeru-- Bobby Deol
Jai -- Abhishek Bachan
Basanti-- Priety Zinta
Gabbar Singh--Manoj Bajpai
Director-- Raj Kumar Santoshi
Scriptwriter-- Javed Akhtar
Music Director-- A.R. Rahman
Tue Dec 3 18:43:58 2002
Name:K. Rajmohan
City, Country:Trivandrum, India
Your Views:Jai - Ajay Devgun
Veeru - Vivek Oberoi
Gabbar Singh - Manoj Bajpai
Basanti - Twinkle Khanna
Music Director - A R Rehman
Scriptwriter - Gulzar
Director - Ram Gopal Varma
Tue Dec 3 18:44:45 2002
Name:vivek
City, Country:india
Your Views:Jai-hrithik
veeru-sharukh khan
gabbar-gulshan grover
basanti-kareenakapur
Tue Dec 3 18:48:19 2002
Name:Sanjeev Pathak
City, Country:India
Your Views:Veeru - Amir Khan
Jai - Ajay Devgan
Gabbar Singh - Ashutosh Rana
Basanti - Shilpa Shetty
Music Director - Anu Malik
Scriptwriter - Mahesh Bhatt
Director - David Dhawan
Tue Dec 3 18:51:18 2002
Name:K. Rajmohan
City, Country:Trivandrum, India
Your Views:Jai - Ajay Devgun
Veeru - Vivek Oberoi
Gabbar Singh - Manoj Bajpai
Basanti - Twinkle Khanna
Music Director - A R Rehman
Scriptwriter - Gulzar
Director - Ram Gopal Varma
Tue Dec 3 18:51:58 2002
Name:pravesh
City, Country:mumbai, india
Your Views:Jai: Akshay Kumar
Veeru:Govinda
Basanti: Kajol
GABBAR: manoj bajpai
thakur: naseeruddin shah
music_ ar rahman
director: mahesh manjrekar
Tue Dec 3 18:52:00 2002
Name:Amol Angre
City, Country:Mumbai
Your Views:Sanjay Dutt as Thakur.
Akshay Kumar and Urmila Matondkar as Veeru and Basanti.
Ajay Degan and Kajol as Jai and the widow.
Ashutosh Rana as Gabbar.
Directed by Ram Gopal Verma and music by Sandeep Chowta.
Tue Dec 3 18:55:52 2002
Name:viki
City, Country:india
Your Views:i think shahrukh khan and sunny deol would be pefect for sholay
Tue Dec 3 18:56:22 2002
Name:glee
City, Country:kochi
Your Views:Jai would be Sunny Deol
Veeru should be Akshay Kumar
Gabbar Singh can be Shakti Kapoor
And Aishwarya can be basanti
Tue Dec 3 18:58:49 2002
Name:SAMEER VIQAR
City, Country:gulbarga,india
Your Views:1)JAI=ABHISHEK BACHEN
2)VERU=BOBBY DEOL
3)GABBER=THE VILIAN OF FILM(JUNGLE)
4)BASANTI=ESHA DEOL
Tue Dec 3 18:59:41 2002
Name:SANJEEV
City, Country:MUMBAI,INDIA
Your Views:BOBBY [VEERU] & ABHISHEK [JAY]
KAREENA KAPOOR [BASANTI] & RANI MUKHERJEE [JAYA BHADURI'S ROLE]
ANUPAM KHER AS THAKUR
SHADAAB KHAN [AMJAD KHAN'S REAL SON] AS GABBAR....!!!!
ANU MALLIK AS MUSIC DIRECTOR & SALIM-JAVED AS SCRIPT WRITERS AGAIN [PLS UNITE FOR GOOD]
JOHNNY LEVER AS THE JAILOR
JAVED JAFFERY AS THE SOORMA BHOOPALI
Tue Dec 3 19:01:30 2002
Name:Dipti Pastakia
City, Country:Urbana, MD
Your Views:Jai -- Jackie Shroff
Veeru -- Anil Kapoor
Gabbar Singh -- Amrish Puri
Thakur -- Amitabh Bachchan
Basanti -- Madhuri Dixit
Director -- J.P Dutta
Tue Dec 3 19:01:49 2002
Name:ANUJA
City, Country:HYDERABAD,INDIA.
Your Views:I WOULD CHOOSE SUNNY DEOL AS VEERU
ABHISHEK BACHCHAN AS JAI
ESHA DEOL AS BASANTI
ANU MALIK AS MUSIC DIRECTOR AND MYSELF AS DIRECTOR.
Tue Dec 3 19:02:45 2002
Name:shiva
City, Country:gandhidham, gujarat-India
Your Views:Amitabh = Abhishekh
Dharmender=Bobby Deol
Hema Malini = Kareena Kapoor
Jaya Bachan = Karishma Kapoor
Amjad Khan = "HE HAS TO RE-BORN"
Music Director = "Anu Malik
Script writer = "SALIM-JAVED"
Director = "Ram Gopal Varma or Raj Sippy himself
Tue Dec 3 19:03:56 2002
Name:anuj malhotra
City, Country:london
Your Views:Jai- Vivek Oboroi
Veeru- Shah Rukh Khan
Gabar- Nana Patekar
Basanti-juhi chawla/preeti zinta
jaya bachans role-karishma kapoor
music-ar rehmaan
script-javed akhtar
director- subhash ghai the showman
Tue Dec 3 19:04:31 2002
Name:pramod
City, Country:hattiesburg, usa
Your Views:I would select govinda as veeru bcoz his charachter got a comedy touch, raveena as basanti, ajaydevgan as jai, music is by rahman and ramu will direct the movie. gabbar singh is played by the vilian from china gate movie.
Tue Dec 3 19:07:26 2002
Name:Anirban
City, Country:New Delhi
Your Views:I would pick the same cast again! ALWAYS!
For Sanjeev Kr, Amjad, Anand Bakshi and R D Burman, I would settle only for them reincarnated as themselves.
The cast is irreplaceable.. thinking of any other actors or anybody other than Pancham as the music director is nothing short of sacrilege!
Tue Dec 3 19:07:37 2002
Name:Sandeep shrikhande
City, Country:Pune, India
Your Views:Nobody is capable to do SHOLAY...the way bacchan,dharmendra & hemamalini has done. So dont try to make it again..
Tue Dec 3 19:07:59 2002
Name:Sreedhar Byreeka
City, Country:Pune, India
Your Views:Jai - What the heck, it will be Amitabh!
Veeru - Whats more the heck, it should be Dharmendra
Thakur -Try Chiranjeevi!
Basanti - Dream Girl, if you didnt know, Hemamalini
Gabbar Singh - How I wish... well dont we have that Bhiku Matre
Music Director - Try Ilayaraja, else AR Rahman would rap-up the melodies! (Didnt get it?... well a melodious Sholay would be the best re-make. See its not aping, just re-making.)
ScriptWriter & Director: Ram Gopal Verma
Tue Dec 3 19:08:13 2002
Name:atul koul
City, Country:mumbai,india
Your Views:jai-sanjay dutt
veru-govinda
gabbar singh-kader khan
basanti-karishma kapoor
music-a.r.rehman
scripwriter-david dhawan
director-david dhawan
Tue Dec 3 19:08:55 2002
Name:Mrs. Babu
City, Country:Mumbai, India
Your Views:well in my opinion aamir khan as veeru(dharamendra's role)
Akshaye Khanna as Jai(big B's role)
kajol as basanthi (just dying to see aamir khan & kajol paired opposite each other)
ashutosh rana as gabbar singh
karisma kapoor in Jaya Bachchan's role
anupam kher in Sanjeev kumar's role. music of coz has to be of A R Rahman's & this has to be directed by Ram gopal Verma or Vikram Bhatt.
Tue Dec 3 19:09:43 2002
Name:Neelam Balani
City, Country:Anand, India
Your Views:I would pick Ajay Devgan for the role of Jai
Shahrukh Khan as Veeru
Manoj Bajpai as Gabbar Singh
Kajol as Basanti
Tabu in Jaya Bhaduri's role
E. Niwas will be a my choice of director.
Music has to be by Rahman
Tue Dec 3 19:10:36 2002
Name:SREENATH B TRIVIKRAM
City, Country:DOMBIVLI, INDIA
Your Views:SHOLAY CANT BE REMADE EVEN WITH THE SAME STAR CAST, THATS A FILM WHICH WILL HAPPEN ONLY ONCE A LIFE TIME.
ALL THEW ACTORS WERE FIRST CLASS SOMETHING WHICH IS SURELY MISSING IN THE CURRENT LOT. THERE ARE TALENTED ACTORS, BUT STILL IT CANT BE REMADE.
Tue Dec 3 19:12:23 2002
Name:RAJ N. NARONE
City, Country:Dar-Es-Salaam, Tanzania
Your Views:Jai - Ajay Devgan
Veeru- Sunny Deol
Basanti - Rani Mukherji
Thakur - Paresh Rawal
Gabbar - New face like Amzad himself
Tue Dec 3 19:13:05 2002
Name:RAJESH NAIR
City, Country:MUMBAI
Your Views:JAI=MYSELF/
VEERU=GOVINDA/
GABBARSINGH=PARESH RAWAL
BASANTI=AMRITAARORA.
MUSIC=NADEEMSHRAVAN
SCRIPT=SALIM
DIRECTION=ANEEZBAZMI
Tue Dec 3 19:13:07 2002
Name:Mahesh Halpeth
City, Country:London, UK
Your Views:You just can't make an epic like Sholay again, full stop, end of story !
Just as Raj Kapoor once said said, when asked "why don't your films contain dream sequences ?" and he had replied, "Give me Mukesh, Nargis, Hasrat Jaipuri, Shankar and Jaikishen and will just think of one"... He never made another dream sequence of its kind... same way, you just cannot make Sholay again, not with the current crop of crap actors anyway !!
But still hypothetically thinking, the cast could be:-
Gabbar Singh - Mangal Pandey
Jai - Akshay Kumar
Veeru - Vivek Oberoi
Basanti - Antara Malli
Surma Bhopali - Jhonny Lever
Thakur - Anupam Kher
Widow - Aishwarya Rai
Ungrezi Jailor - Shakti Kapoor
Script writer - Anees Bazmi
Director - Ramgopal Verma
Music Director - Vishal
Tue Dec 3 19:14:12 2002
Name:Gopal Patwal
City, Country:Mumabi,India
Your Views:Jai - Abhishek Bachchan
Veeru - Vivek Oberoi
Basanti - Rani Mukhrjjee / Aaishwarya
Gabbar Singh - Asutosh Rana / Manoj Bajpai
Tue Dec 3 19:15:18 2002
Name:Assad
City, Country:Mumbai, India
Your Views:Directed by Raj Kumar Santoshi...
Tue Dec 3 19:15:26 2002
Name:Sravan
City, Country:Hyderabad, India
Your Views:Jai: Ajay Devgan
Veeru: Aamir Khan
Gabbar Singh: Aasish Vidyarthi
Basanti: Manisha Koirala
Music Director: A.R.Rehman
Script Writer: Annez Bazmi
Director: Ram Gopal Varma
Tue Dec 3 19:16:04 2002
Name:Vishal.
City, Country:Mumbai , India
Your Views:Jai - Abhishek Bachchan
Veeru - Bobby Deol.
Gabbar Singh - Paresh Rawal.
Basanti - Kareena Kapoor.
Music - Annu Mallik.
Tue Dec 3 19:18:06 2002
Name:Shantala Matti
City, Country:Bangalore, India
Your Views:Obviously Jai would be vivek oberoi and veer-hritik...and gabbarsing amrish puri....but basanti would be rani or juhi
Tue Dec 3 19:18:54 2002
Name:sridhar
City, Country:london,united kingdom
Your Views:jai---shah rukh khan
veeru-sunny deol
basanti--raveena tandon
gabbar singh--manoj bajpai
musis directoe-sandeep chowta
direstor-ram gopal varma
script writer-ram gopal varma
Tue Dec 3 19:21:00 2002
Name:himanshumisra
City, Country:kanpur,india
Your Views:jai-kk of chall
veeru-akshaykumar
basanti-kareenakapur
gabbarsingh-ashutoshrana
Tue Dec 3 19:24:08 2002
Name:sanju
City, Country:US
Your Views:aamir khan has jai, shah rukh as veeru, basanti is preity
Tue Dec 3 19:26:14 2002
Name:Shiraj Shikhar
City, Country:Mumbai
Your Views:Jai - Ajay Devgun
Veeru - Sunny Deol
Basanti - Karisma Kapoor
Jaya Bhaduri's role - Tabu
Thakur - Danny Denzongpa
Gabbar Singh - Mukesh Tiwari
Jailor - Johnny Lever
Soorma Bhopali - Laxmikant Berde
Music - Anu Malik
Director - J P Dutta
Tue Dec 3 19:28:07 2002
Name:Reghu
City, Country:Dammam, Saudi Arabia
Your Views:Basanti as Karishma Kapoor
Tue Dec 3 19:28:16 2002
Name:Ninad
City, Country:Dubai. UAE.
Your Views:There has, is and will be only one Sholay. Recreating the magic is impossible.
Tue Dec 3 19:29:08 2002
Name:Prabha Hadkar
City, Country:Mumbai, India
Your Views:Jai- Shahrukh Khan
Veeru- Salmaan Khan
Basanti- Kajol
Gabbar- Amrish Puri
Tue Dec 3 19:30:22 2002
Name:B.R.Parthasarathy
City, Country:
Your Views:Jai-Abhishek Bachan
Veeru-Suny deol
Basanti- Esha deol
Gabbar-Ashitosh Rana
Music director-A.R.Rehman
script writer-salim -Javed
Director-Karan Johar
Tue Dec 3 19:30:30 2002
Name:Bipin
City, Country:Pune, India
Your Views:The film SHOLAY was truly a marvelous movie. If at all one decide of remaking it, the original cast, director, script writer, musician can ONLY make a remarkable movie.
Considering today's situation NOBODY is worth and capable of contributing to this movie directly and indirectly.
Tue Dec 3 19:33:09 2002
Name:Paddy
City, Country:Tokyo, Japan
Your Views:Aj ka Sholay Setting: 2003
Primary Casting
Amithabh = Hrithik
Dharmender = SRK
Sanjeev Kumar = BigB
Amjad Khan = Manoj Bajpai
Hema Malini = Priety Zinta
Jaya Bhaduri = Esha Deol
Music Director = Anu Malik
Script Writer = Javed Akhtar
Director = Farhan Akhtar/Raj Kumar Santoshi
Tue Dec 3 19:34:12 2002
Name:gopal
City, Country:gopalbs@rediffmail.com
Your Views:gabbar- nana patekar
jailor-asrani - jonny levers
jai - ajay devgan
veeru - amir khan
director shekhar kapur
basanti - rani or kajol
jailor - sanjiv kumar - shahhrukh khan / om
puri
jaya bhaduri -puja batra
Tue Dec 3 19:34:27 2002
Name:man mohan
City, Country:india
Your Views:for Jai ajay devgun
veeru sunny deol
gabbar singh-amrish puri
in place of sanjeev kumar cast Bajpayee ( actor )Basanti pretty
Tue Dec 3 19:34:32 2002
Name:shyam
City, Country:mangalore, India
Your Views:Ashuthosh Rana as Gabbar Singh,
Abhishek Bachhan as Jai
Karishma Kapoor as the widow
Bobby Deol as Veeru
Kareena Kapoor as Basanti
Music Director A. R. Rahman
Script will be Salman Khan
Directed by Subhash Ghai
Samba will be played by me coz i am shyam mohan(alias mac mohan )
Tue Dec 3 19:35:21 2002
Name:Tarek
City, Country:Melbourne,Australia
Your Views:Jay- Ajay Devgan
Veeru- Shahrukh khan
Gabbar Singh- Manoj Bajpei
Basanti- Aishwaria Rai
Music- Shanker,Ehsan,Loy
Script and direction- Rajkumar Santoshi
Tue Dec 3 19:35:22 2002
Name:karthik
City, Country:bangalore india
Your Views:Thakur:Amitabh Bachchan
Jai: Ajay Devgan
Veeru: Abhishek Bachchan
Basanti:Preity Zinta
Gabbar: Manoj Bajpai
music director: AR Rehman
Script: Javed Akthar
Director: Farhan Akthar
Tue Dec 3 19:36:28 2002
Name:samik
City, Country:india
Your Views:jai == shah rukh khan
veeru== salman khan
gabbar singh==china gate villian
music director == shankar ehsaan loy
scriptwriter == mansoor khan
Tue Dec 3 19:38:12 2002
Name:Inderjeet Singh
City, Country:Ludhiana, INDIA
Your Views:Well in my opinion the Sholay combination can't be replaced, they were just perfect for the kind of role for which they were chosen.
Tue Dec 3 19:38:51 2002
Name:Aparna
City, Country:Hyderabad, India
Your Views:In place of Amitabh- Ajay Devgan
In place of Dharmendra - Shahrukh Khan
In place of Hema - Juhi Chawla
In place of Jaya Bhaduri - Kajol
Gabbar Singh - Amrish Puri
Music Director - A.R. Rahman
Director - Ashutosh Gowatrikar
Tue Dec 3 19:39:51 2002
Name:Prashant
City, Country:USA
Your Views:Sholay is the movie of milleneium .You just cant make it.
Tue Dec 3 19:39:58 2002
Name:deepa
City, Country:india
Your Views:jai-Ajay Devgan
veeru-akshay kumar
thakur-suresh oberoi
gabbar-ashutosh rana
basanti-preity zinta
radha-rani
music dir-ismail durbar
dir-mani ratnam
script/songs-gulzar
cinematography-santosh sivan
Tue Dec 3 19:40:02 2002
Name:SATWANT
City, Country:SINGAPORE
Your Views:BAHCHAN JUNIOR AS BAHCHAN SENIOR
BOBBY DEOL AS DHARMENDRA
KHARISMA KAPOOR AS JAYA
KARENNA KAPOOR AS BASANTI
NOBOBY CAN REPLACE AMJAD KHAN
Tue Dec 3 19:42:07 2002
Name:Sunit bhargava
City, Country:Pune, India
Your Views:Jai : Ajay devgan
Veeru: salman khan
Gabbar Singh: ashutosh rana
Basanti: amisha patel
music Director : ar rahman
Director : ashutosh govrikar
Tue Dec 3 19:43:11 2002
Name:Jitender
City, Country:Austria
Your Views:Jai Sharukh Khan
Veeru Hrithik Roshan
GabbarSingh Amrish Puri
Basanti Karishma Kapoor
Music Anu Malik
Script Karan Johar
Directed Karan Johar
Yash Chopra
Tue Dec 3 19:45:18 2002
Name:John-Noel
City, Country:France
Your Views:Jai=Ajay Devgan
Veeru=Aamir Khan
Gabbar Singh= Om Puri
Basanti=Nandita Das
Music Director=A R Rahman
Script writer=Javed Akhtar
Director=Ashutosh Gowrikar
Tue Dec 3 19:45:28 2002
Name:Appi
City, Country:USA
Your Views:Jai - Hrithik
Veeru - Vivek O
Gabbar - Manoj Bajpai
Bsanthi - Kajol
Tue Dec 3 19:46:22 2002
Name:Vinod
City, Country:Bangalore, India
Your Views:Direction : Mani Ratnam / John mathew Mathan
Music: A R Rahman
Script : Director himself / Javed Akhtar
Jai: Amir khan
Veeru: Akshay Khanna
Gabbar Singh: Akshay kumar
Sanjeev KUmar's role: Amitabh Bachan/ Mammootty
Basanti : Preity Sinta
Tue Dec 3 19:48:34 2002
Name:Lalit Mohan
City, Country:Toronto, Canada
Your Views:I dont think it could be remade. But even then if you want to remake it.
Here is what I think.
Anupum Kher can do Sanjeev Kumar. (any thing is possible for him)
Sharkuh Khan can try Amitabha Bachan ( he knows how to copy)
Amir Khan can do Dharmendra ( He can be even better)
Juhi Chawla can be Hema ( not much difference)
and here is the main guy Gabbar Singh. I think Manoj Bajpai can be taken as Gabbar Singh. Director is the main person who else except me who selected these all stars ;). Any way I think Nana Patekar can direct it. Give it a try Nana has a big creative mind.
Tue Dec 3 19:49:13 2002
Name:Sandesh Panse
City, Country:India
Your Views:Are you nuts ??? The film Sholay can never be made again.
Tue Dec 3 19:50:03 2002
Name:navroop singh
City, Country:new delhi, india
Your Views:jai -- Shahrukh khan
veeru -- hrithik roshan
basanti -- aishwarya rai
gabbar singh -- asutosh rana
thakur -- amrish puri
music director - shankar, ehsaaan & loy
Script writer - Javed akhtar
Director - farhan akhtar
Tue Dec 3 19:50:32 2002
Name:Santosh Kunder
City, Country:Mumbai, India
Your Views:Jai - Akshay Kumar
Veeru - Sunil Shetty
Gabbar Singh - Paresh Rawal
Basanti - Tabu
music director - A R Rahmen
scriptwriter - Me
direct - Ram Gopal Verma
Tue Dec 3 19:50:42 2002
Name:Deepak Pant
City, Country:Concord, NH, USA
Your Views:Jai - Abhishek Bachhan
Veeru - Sunny Deol
Gabbar Singh - Gulshan Grover
Basanti - Amisha Patel
Tue Dec 3 19:52:03 2002
Name:Sanjay
City, Country:Atlanta, USA
Your Views:Jai Dev - Ajay Devgan (This character needs very good facial expressions and intense presense because Amitabh's silence did what 100's of dialogues would'nt have done. So Ajay is close to that capability)
Veeru - Shahrukh Khan (Simply because he has better comedy skills)
Basanti - Madhuri Dixit (Posseses very good dancing and acting skills)
Radha - Kajol (Perfect Match, A cake walk for her)
Thakur - Amitabh (Well... just dont cut his hands though)
Gabbar - Amjad Khan's Reincarnation ( Just could'nt think of a replacement... Amjad cant be replaced as far as this particular role is concerned)
Director - Vidhu Vinod Chopra
Script Writer - Salim & Javed or Javed
Music Director - Anu Malik (Adopts any kind of music very well... would do a good job of matching the legendary R.D. music)
All said and done... you still cant remake Sholay even with the very best of today's actors. Its once in thousand years affair.
Tue Dec 3 19:54:26 2002
Name:Alok Tayal
City, Country:NY, USA
Your Views:Well honestly I will pickup exactly the same cast. Every single person.
They were just perfect. The new generation is great but little too Sophisticated for Sholey.
Tue Dec 3 19:55:40 2002
Name:Arun
City, Country:London
Your Views:I think the roles of Sanjeev Kumar, Amitabh, Dharmedra, Amjad Khan, Hema & Jaya Bhaduri should be played by Amitabh, Aamir Khan, Shar Rukh, Manoj Bajpai, Preity Zindal & Rani.
Tue Dec 3 19:56:50 2002
Name:Aadil Allana
City, Country:Mumbai, INDIA
Your Views:Sharukh Khan - Jai
Salman Khan - Veeru
Juhi - Basanti
Kajal - Widow {in love with Jai}
Manoj Bajpai - Gabbar
Amrish Puri - Thakur(Sanjeev Kumar)
Tue Dec 3 19:57:46 2002
Name:RAJESHSHETTY
City, Country:DUBAI
Your Views:Jai=Hrithik
Veeru=Vivek oberoi
Basanti=Madhuri dixit
Gabbar singh=Amrish puri
Tue Dec 3 20:00:14 2002
Name:Shantanu Bhat
City, Country:Pune, India
Your Views:Ajay Devgan as Jai, bcos there is no actor that can present angry young man like Ajay now a days...I would give Vivek Oberoi chance for Veeru, Kajol for Basanti..Hmm. .. Aamir khan for Thakur.. yeah he would do great.. And..think Akshay Kumar for Gabbar... yes his voice is sutiable for that.. SRK for Samba( ha ha ha)...yeah he will do monkeying around.And of course A.K. Hangal will be also be there..dont worry..
Tue Dec 3 20:00:53 2002
Name:Ami
City, Country:Tokyo, Japan
Your Views:Jai Shah Rukh Khan
Veeru Indranil Roy
Basanti Karishma Kapoor
Gabbar Nasiruddin Shah
Tue Dec 3 20:01:22 2002
Name:Chirag
City, Country:NJ, USA
Your Views:Ajay Devgan as Jai
Vivek Oberoi as Veeru
Manoj Bajpai as Gabar Singh
Amitabh Bachan as Thakur
Tabu as Basanti
A.R. Rehman for Music
Mahesh Manjrekar Director (Good with Action)
Sholay was and is and will be the greatest hindi film ever made and any remake will never match the original.
Tue Dec 3 20:01:59 2002
Name:raghukatte
City, Country:bangalore, india
Your Views: Veeru- Akshay kumar
Jai - Ajay Devgan
Basanti- preeti zinta
Gabbar Singh- Manoj Bajpai
Script Writer- Rangeela's Script writer
Direction- Ram Gopal Verma
Tue Dec 3 20:03:14 2002
Name:Abhijit Ganguly
City, Country:NJ,USA
Your Views:I can't think of remake of Sholay.
Master pieces can not be re-made
Tue Dec 3 20:03:59 2002
Name:Sameer
City, Country:Pune, India
Your Views:Jai: Akshay Khanna
Viru: Govinda
Gabbar singh: Amrish Puri
Basanti: Karishma Kapur
Tue Dec 3 20:08:48 2002
Name:Chandra Shekhar
City, Country:Chicago, US
Your Views:Jai:Akshay Kumar
Veeru:Shahrukh Khan
Gabbar:Ashutosh Rana
Basanti:Juhi Chawla
Music Director:Anand Milind
Director:Ram Gopal Verma
Tue Dec 3 20:13:33 2002
Name:JATINDER
City, Country:ABOHAR,INDIA
Your Views:JAI-SANJUY DUTT
VEERU-VIVEK OBEROI
BASANTI-ANTRAMALI
GABBAR-ASHUTOSH RANA
Tue Dec 3 20:15:50 2002
Name:Abrar Hussain Farshori
City, Country:Geneva, Switzerland
Your Views:Sholay was a unique film, nobody can replace the old artists, they were just fine.
Tue Dec 3 20:16:03 2002
Name:SHRIPAD R. JUMDE
City, Country:Little Rock, USA
Your Views:Jai - Akshay Kumar
Veeru - Salman Khan
Gabbar - Mukesh Rishi
Thakur - Abhishek Bachan
Basanti - Priety Zinta/Shilpa Shetty
Jaya ) - Rani Mukherjee
Helen - Antra Mali
Tue Dec 3 20:16:21 2002
Name:sauvik basu
City, Country:bombay, india
Your Views:Jai - vivek oberoi
veeru - Hritik
basanti - kareena
radha - aishwarya
thakur - Anil Kapoor
gabbar - Sunny Deol
director - Ramesh Sippy
music director - Jatin lalit
scriptwriter - use the same
old script
Tue Dec 3 20:16:45 2002
Name:krishna
City, Country:india
Your Views:Jay - Hrithik Roshan
Veeru - Abishek Bachen
Basanti - Amisha
Gabbar - NEW FACE
Scriptwrite and Director - Ramgopal varma
Tue Dec 3 20:17:42 2002
Name:somya
City, Country:delhi, india
Your Views:shahrukh khan, fardeen khan, aishwarya rai, diya mirza
Tue Dec 3 20:18:43 2002
Name:Sumit Bajaj
City, Country:Delhi,India
Your Views:manisha koirala should be gabar,pooja bedi should be basanti,bobby and sunny should be jai and veeru,music director should be anand millind and script should be rumi jaffery
Tue Dec 3 20:18:55 2002
Name:uday
City, Country:Boston
Your Views:Gabbar: Nana Patekar
Jai : Ajay Devgan/Sanjay Dutt
Veeru : Govinda
Tue Dec 3 20:21:07 2002
Name:Murali
City, Country:Baltimore, USA
Your Views:For basanti Madhuri dixit fits in for other roles nobody , this is a classic movie never can be remade.
Tue Dec 3 20:22:35 2002
Name:rocky
City, Country:india
Your Views:jai= sanjay dutt
veeru= sunny deol
gabbar= amrish puri
basanti= karishma
jaca bachan= aishwariya
Tue Dec 3 20:29:47 2002
Name:Prashant
City, Country:USA
Your Views:Don't even think about remaking Sholay. You guys can not make movie like Sholay so forget about cast, director etc.
Tue Dec 3 20:30:49 2002
Name:Naina
City, Country:Mumbai
Your Views:Jai: Sunny Deol
Veeru: Akshay Kumar
Basanti: Rani Mukherjee
Ashutosh Rana: Gabbar
Amitabh Bachchan: Thakur Baldev Singh
Tue Dec 3 20:31:11 2002
Name:Praveen Bakshi
City, Country:Chandigarh, India
Your Views:Jai ---> Abhishek Bachhan
Veeru ---> Bobby Deol
Gabbar Singh ---> Bajpayee
Basanti ---> Sonali Bendre
Thakur ---> Ashutosh Rana
Director ---> Subhash Ghai
Music Director ---> Anu Malik
Script Writer ---> Script is already there (use the same)
Tue Dec 3 20:31:24 2002
Name:Sai Anand
City, Country:Centerville, Ohio
Your Views:Jai: Shahrukh Khan
Veeru: Salman Khan
Gabbar Singh: Amrish Puri
Basanti: Aishwarya Rai
Music Director: Jatin - Lalit
Tue Dec 3 20:32:29 2002
Name:Nischal M.
City, Country:Los Angeles, USA
Your Views:Thakur Baldev Singh: Amitabh Bachchan
Jai: Abhishek Bachchan
Veeru: Bobby Deol
Basanti: Rani Mukherjee
Radha: Aishwarya Rai
Gabbar Singh: Shadab Khan (Amjad Khan's son)
Director: Ramesh Sippy
Music: Anu Malik
Scriptwriter: Javed (The original)
Tue Dec 3 20:34:29 2002
Name:Hetal Patel
City, Country:Rome,USA
Your Views:Abhishek Bachan as Jay.
Veeru as Bobby Deol.
Basanti as Kareena Kapoor.
Gabbar as Ashutosh Rana.
Music Director As Sandeep Chowta.
Script Writer as Rajkumar Santoshi.
Director as Rajkumar Santoshi.
Tue Dec 3 20:35:34 2002
Name:VIVEK GUPTA
City, Country:mumbai,india
Your Views:BASANTI----------- Kareena
VEERU------------- Saif Ali Khan Pataudi
JAI--------------- Akshaye Khanna
GABBAR SINGH------ Nirmal Pandey
THAKUR SAAB------- amitabh B
DIRECTOR---------- undoubtely Raj Kumar Santoshi
MUSIC DIRECTOR---- Sandeep Chowta
SCRIPT WRITER----- Anurag Kashayp and Rumi Jaffery
Tue Dec 3 20:36:12 2002
Name:Amit Patel
City, Country:Dubai, UAE
Your Views:Jai : Govinda
Veeru : Fardeen Khan
Basanti : Jyothika
Tue Dec 3 20:37:02 2002
Name:Jayesh Shanbhag
City, Country:Cincinnayi, USA
Your Views:Jai : Still Amitabh no one would close to his role.
But I would say in today's time it would be Jackie Shroff .
Veeru : I would say Veeru's son aka Sunnu Deol
Gabbar Singh : Ashutosh Rana
Basanti : Madhuri Dixit
Music Director : A.R. Rahaman
Scriptwriter : Salim - Javed
Director : J.P. Dutta
Tue Dec 3 20:38:59 2002
Name:Vikram
City, Country:Goa, India
Your Views:Jai - Amrish Puri
Veeru - A.K.Hangal
Basanti - Bindu
Gabar Singh - Adnan Sami
Music director - Udam Singh
Tue Dec 3 20:39:39 2002
Name:ajit gokhale
City, Country:gokhale_ajit@hotmail.com
Your Views:Sanjeevkumar's role to Anil Kapoor
Amjad's role to Ajay Devgan
Amitabh's role to Hrithik
Dharmendra's role to Akshaykumar
Hema's role to Madhuri
Jaya's role to Kareena
Tue Dec 3 20:41:25 2002
Name:Anup toshniwal
City, Country:Parbhani.(INDIA)
Your Views:Cast-Jai-abshek Bachan.
Viru-Bobby Deol.
Gabber-Sanjay Datt.
Thakur-Pravesh Ravel.
Basanti-Preeti Zenta.
Tue Dec 3 20:42:55 2002
Name:Nidhi Singh
City, Country:U K
Your Views:Jai-Sunny Deol
Veeru-Ajay Devgan
Basanti-Madhuri Dixit
Gabbar Singh- Nana Patekar
Tue Dec 3 20:43:29 2002
Name:Vijay Anand
City, Country:Chennai , India
Your Views:Jai - Ajay Devagan
Veeru - Govinda
Gabbar Singh - Salman Khan
Basanti - Preeti zinta
Thakur - Nana Patekar
Soorma Bhopali - Jaaved Jaafri
Music Director - Anu Malik
Director - David Dhawan
Tue Dec 3 20:45:45 2002
Name:Nisheeth
City, Country:India
Your Views:Jai-> Akshay Kumar
Veeru-> Saif Ali Khan
Basanti-> Preeti Zinta
Gabbar -> Sunny Deol
Tue Dec 3 20:47:00 2002
Name:Akshay
City, Country:Chicago, USA
Your Views:Jai - Shahrukh Khan
Veeru - Bobby Deol
Basanti - Kajol
Thakur - Amrish Puri
Gabbar Singh - Mukesh Rishi
Music Director - Jatin-Lalit
Director - Subhash Ghai
Tue Dec 3 20:47:03 2002
Name:Mohamed
City, Country:Dubai
Your Views:new villan (like amjad khan at the time making of Sholay) Sharuk (Amitab) and Amir (Dharmender)Rani mukarji (Hema malini)
Tue Dec 3 20:47:50 2002
Name:kumar
City, Country:bangalore,india
Your Views:Jai: Sunil Shetty
Veeru: Akshay Kumar
Gabbar: BC Patil.
Basanti: Karishma
Tue Dec 3 20:48:01 2002
Name:Vijay Anand
City, Country:Chennai , India
Your Views:Jai - Ajay Devagan
Veeru - Govinda
Gabbar Singh - Salman Khan
Basanti - Preeti zinta
Thakur - Nana Patekar
Soorma Bhopali - Jaaved Jaafri
Music Director - Anu Malik
Director - David Dhawan
Tue Dec 3 20:49:07 2002
Name:Aditya Nathani
City, Country:calcutta / india
Your Views:Sunny Deol - Veeru
Sharukh khan - Jai
madhuri dixit - basanti
ashwariya rai - jaya
naseeruddin shah - thakur
amrish puri - gabbar
Tue Dec 3 20:49:45 2002
Name:Anish
City, Country:USA
Your Views:Jai- ajay devgan
Veeru-aamir khan
Basanti-madhuri dixit
gabbar-nana patekar
takur-amithab
Tue Dec 3 20:50:49 2002
Name:sanjay k thade
City, Country:kolkata india
Your Views:no magic of originaol sholay can be created as it was a genius masterpiece.by stroke of accident the contemparory best performing artists were involved in making and acting in the movie. the camera work the music,sets, diolougs, art direction were of highest order lot of planning had gone in to making the masterpiece -so - no replacement possible
Tue Dec 3 20:54:58 2002
Name:deepak patel
City, Country:kuala lumpur
Your Views:jay:salman
veeru:aamir
basanti:juhi chawla
widow bahu:kajol
thakur:jackie shroff
gabbar:ashutosh rana
Tue Dec 3 20:56:43 2002
Name:Sharada
City, Country:Pune, India
Your Views: Veeru : Shah Rukh Khan
Jai : Aamir Khan
Basanti : Preity Zinta
Gabbar Singh : Ashutosh Rana
Tue Dec 3 20:57:18 2002
Name:Sridhar
City, Country:OH, USA
Your Views:Sholay is like the Godfather...which can be made once in a lifetime.....everything about the film was perfect and cannot be changed
Tue Dec 3 20:58:11 2002
Name:Chandresh Shah
City, Country:Mumbai , India
Your Views:Abhishek Bacchan - Jai
Sunny Deol - Veeru
Sadashiv Amrapurkar - Gabbar Singh
Kajol - Basanti
Tue Dec 3 20:58:17 2002
Name:Ajay
City, Country:London UK
Your Views:Amitabh Bachchaan as Takhur
Ammir Khan as Veeru
Shah Rukh Khan as Jai
Ashwaryia Rai as Basanti
Juhi Chawala as Jaya's role
Nana Patekar as Gabbar Singh
Tue Dec 3 21:01:03 2002
Name:Sudhansu Panigrahi
City, Country:Chiago, USA
Your Views:Jai: Saharukh Khan
Veeru: Gobinda
Gabbar Singh: Gulson Grover
Basanti: Madhuri Dixit
Music Director:A R Rehaman
Director: Karan Johar
Script: Kader Khan
Tue Dec 3 21:01:17 2002
Name:Nik
City, Country:Phoenix, USA
Your Views:Jai: Anil Kapoor
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Radha: Madhuri Dixit
Basanti: Kajol
Thakur: Jackie Shroff
Gabbar: Manoj Bajpai
Tue Dec 3 21:03:07 2002
Name:gouse khan
City, Country:jodhpur, India
Your Views:For Jai's role nonly VivekOberoi can justify,Veeru's role can be donned by Hrithik Roshan, Gabbar's role should be given to Manoj Bajpai and FOr Basanti's role Madhuri dixit should fit the bill.
Tue Dec 3 21:03:14 2002
Name:AJAY JAYMAL
City, Country:LONDON UK
Your Views:Music Diretor: AR Rahman
Scriptwriter: Farhan Akhtar
Director: Ashtosh (Lagaan)
Amitabh Bachchaan as Takhur
Ammir/Shah Rukh/Hrithk or Vieck as Jai n Veeru
Ash as Basanti
Nana Patekar as Gabber Singh
Tue Dec 3 21:05:36 2002
Name:mrinal
City, Country:calcutta
Your Views:jai : hrithik roshan
veeru : fardeen khan
gabbar : manoj bajpai
basanti : aishwarya rai
music director: anu malik
director : aditya chopra
Tue Dec 3 21:31:16 2002
Name:anup Kurien
City, Country:Wisconsin, USA
Your Views:Hirthuk Roshan Jai and Akhsay Kumar Veeru
Anu MAllick Music Director
Raj Kumar Santhosi Director
Ashutosh Rana as gabar
Tue Dec 3 21:32:26 2002
Name:Ritabrata Chatterjee
City, Country:Minneapolis, USA
Your Views:Thakur : Amitabh Bachchan
Jai : Ajay Devgan
Veeru : Shahrukh Khan
Basanti : Aisharya Rai
Gabbar Singh: Naseeruddin Shah
Scriptwriter: Javed Akhtar
Director :Asutosh Gawarikar
Music : A R Rehman
Though I put this names, I can't digest anybody to be equivalent of the original cast.
Tue Dec 3 21:33:51 2002
Name:shashi kant
City, Country:Hannover, Germany
Your Views:shollay is a historical film..it΄s each moment..each charecter is uncompareble.. if you are asking me a questen like who will cast jai i.e. only ameetab..veeru can be only be dhremendra..and so on..
Tue Dec 3 21:34:19 2002
Name:anup Kurien
City, Country:Wisconsin, USA
Your Views:Hirthuk Roshan Jai and Akhsay Kumar Veeru
Anu MAllick Music Director
Raj Kumar Santhosi Director
Ashutosh Rana as gabar
Tue Dec 3 21:36:27 2002
Name:shreya
City, Country:bangalore,india
Your Views:veeru: hrithik
jai: vivek oberoi
basanthi: rani mukharjee
gabbar:manoj bajpai
Tue Dec 3 21:36:37 2002
Name:shaks
City, Country:raleigh, usa
Your Views:music director = ar rahman
amitabh bachchan = hrithik roshan
dharmendra = amir khan
hema malini = madhuri dixit
jaya bachchan = tabu
gabbar singh = rahul dev
producer = yash chopra
helen = sushmita sen/ bipasha basu
director = ashutosh gowariker
Tue Dec 3 21:38:14 2002
Name:Parag Kane
City, Country:Mumbai, India
Your Views:Veeru - Ajay Devgan
Jai - Akshay Khanna
Gabbar Singh - Amrish Puri
Surma Bhopali - Salman Khan
Basanti - Madhuri Dixit
Thakur - Naseeruddin Shah
Music - Ram Laxman
Director - Barjatya's
Tue Dec 3 21:38:55 2002
Name:Biswajit
City, Country:Tampa,USA
Your Views:Abhishek Bachan as Jai
Vivek Oberoi as Veeru
Priety Zinta as Basnti
Sunny Deol as Gabbar
Direction RamGopal Verma
Music AR Rehamna
Script Writer Honey Irani
Tue Dec 3 21:45:39 2002
Name:Pradeep
City, Country:Hyderabad
Your Views:Veeru-Bobby Deol
Jai-Abhishek Bachchan
Thakur- Amitabh Bachchan
Gabbar-Ashutosh Rana
Basanti-Aishwarya Rai
Thakur`s Bahu- Rani Mukherjee
Soorma Bhopali-Javed Jaffri
Jailor- Anupam kher
Script-Javed Akhtar
Music Director- A.R.Rehman
Director-Raj Kumar Santoshi
Tue Dec 3 21:49:15 2002
Name:Sushma
City, Country:Duluth,USA
Your Views:I think Kareena kapoor as Basanti,Hritik roshan as veeru,amir khan as jai,anupam kher as gabar singh.Ar rahman as music director,Farheen akhtar as script writer,Aditya chopra as the director.
Tue Dec 3 21:50:34 2002
Name:Ranjeet
City, Country:Ahmedabad,India
Your Views:Jai - Abhishek Bachchan
Veeru - Vivek Oberoi
Basanti - Rani Mukherjee
Gabbar - Manoj Bajpai
Thakur - Naseeruddin Shah
Tue Dec 3 21:51:09 2002
Name:Preetam
City, Country:Mumbai,India
Your Views:Jai- Ajay Devgan
Veeru-Shahrukh Khan
Basanti-Kajol
Thakur-Amitabh Bacchan
Gabbar-Manoj Bajpayi
Music Director- AR Rahman
Director-Ashutosh Gowarikar
Tue Dec 3 21:51:25 2002
Name:Jessica
City, Country:Toronto, Canada
Your Views:Jai-Akshay Kumar
Veeru-Vivek Oberoi
Gabbar Singh-Gulshan Grover
Basanti-Juhi Chawla (I'd prefer Preity Zinta cuz she's younger. She can do the comedy but not sure if she can dance??)
Tue Dec 3 21:54:11 2002
Name:Ricky
City, Country:toronto, canada
Your Views:Director: RamGopal Verma / Faran Akhtar
Jai: Govinda
Veeru: Aamir Khan
Basanti: Priety Zinta
Gabbar: Paresh Rawal
"Sanjeev Kumar's role": Naseerudin Shah
Music: Shankar, Ehsaan and Loy
Script: Javed Akhtaar
Tue Dec 3 21:58:26 2002
Name:Arvind
City, Country:Delhi
Your Views:Jai Abhishek Bachhan
Veeru Bobby Deol
Basanti Rani Mukherji
Gabbar Mukesh Tiwari/ Manoj Vajpayee
Tue Dec 3 21:58:28 2002
Name:Tushar Patil
City, Country:Belgaum India
Your Views:I would choose Anil Kapoor for Veeru and JAckie for Jai. For Basanti I would go for Juhi Chawla. And gabbar singh none other than Danny Denzogpa
Tue Dec 3 21:59:59 2002
Name:amit
City, Country:USA
Your Views:No One...In that case I will not see movie. Thats why that is SHOLAY. Film specialists says there are 2 part of Indian Film Industry One is Before Sholay and other one is after....SO No More Sholay
Tue Dec 3 22:00:35 2002
Name:Bhagat
City, Country:mumbai, India
Your Views:veru : Amir Khan
jai : Ajay Devgan
Gabbar singh : Ashutosh Rana
Basanti : Juhi chawala
Tue Dec 3 22:01:23 2002
Name:ali
City, Country:austin, TX
Your Views:Jai- Ajay Devgan
Veeru - Aamir Khan
Basanti - Juhi Chawla
Jaya Bhaduri's part - Kajol
Sanjeev Kumar's part - Amitabh Bachchan
Gabbar Singh - Manoj Bajpai
Music Director - Shankar-Ehsan-Loy
Tue Dec 3 22:01:35 2002
Name:hardik
City, Country:california,usa
Your Views:jai-abhishek bacchan
viru-ritik roshan
thakur-amitabh bachhan
basanti-priti zinta
gabbarsing-manoj bajpai
Tue Dec 3 22:06:49 2002
Name:sabby
City, Country:usa
Your Views:i have seen sholay more than 8 times . i dont think any one can makethat kind of movie any more even sippy its self.
after sholay many films came but none of them make success.
Tue Dec 3 22:10:34 2002
Name:Fez Ali
City, Country:Dallas, TX
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti: Karisma Kapoor
Widow: Sonali Bendre
Thakur: Paresh Rawal
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Music: A.R. Rahman
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Tue Dec 3 22:11:39 2002
Name:Varun Upadhyaya
City, Country:London, UK
Your Views:Sunjay Dutt for Veeru's role
Govinda for Jay's role
Aishwarya for Basanti's role
Amitabh for Thakur's role
Ashutosh Rana for Gabbar's role
Tue Dec 3 22:14:15 2002
Name:Rajiv Kainth
City, Country:canada
Your Views:Jai : Abishek
Veeru : Boby Deol
Gabbar Singh : Asotosh Rana
Basanti : Rani Mukerjee
Tue Dec 3 22:14:50 2002
Name:Prakash .S. Sharma
City, Country:Pune,India
Your Views:I would like to choose Sanjay Dutt as Jay and Salman Khan as viru and Gabbar Singh? er, I would definitely choose Ashish Vidyarthi.And for Basanti's role Esha Deol is the best choise just like her mother in Sholay.
Tue Dec 3 22:14:52 2002
Name:chris
City, Country:newjersey,usa
Your Views:sanjay dutt as jai,shahrukh as veeru,amrish as gabbar,kajol as basanti.music director wud be nadeem shravan.script writer wud be
subash ghai,direction wud be mahesh manjrekar.
Tue Dec 3 22:15:51 2002
Name:Romel
City, Country:Buffalo, NY, USA
Your Views:i think jai shud b abhishek bachan and veeru shud b govinda... basanti shud b played by kajol and gabbar singh by akshay khanna
Tue Dec 3 22:16:18 2002
Name:Ketan
City, Country:USA
Your Views:Veeru - Sunny Deol
Jai - Abshishek Bachhan
Basanti - Madhuri Dixit
Director - Vidhu Vinod Chopra
Script - Salim (??) / Javed Akhtar
Gabbar Singh - Ashutosh Rana
Thakur - Amitabh Bachhan
Tue Dec 3 22:16:19 2002
Name:Prakash .S. Sharma
City, Country:Pune,India
Your Views:I would like to choose Sanjay Dutt as Jay and Salman Khan as viru and Gabbar Singh? er, I would definitely choose Ashish Vidyarthi.And for Basanti's role Esha Deol is the best choise just like her mother in Sholay.
Tue Dec 3 22:18:05 2002
Name:Aslam Mogul
City, Country:NJ, USA
Your Views:Gabbar Singh - Manoj Bajpai
Thakur - Shah Rkh Khan
Basanti - Priety Zinta
Jaya - Karishma Kapoor
Jai - Abhishek Bachan
Veeru - Saif Ali Khan
Jailor - Paresh Rawal.
Director - Ram Gopal Verma
Tue Dec 3 22:19:42 2002
Name:Hiren
City, Country:Detroit,USA
Your Views:Jay : Aamir khan
Veeru : Shaharukh khan
Gabbar : Amarish Puri
Basanti : Madhuri Dixit
Music Director : A R Rehman
Script writer : Javed
Director : Ram Gopal Verma
Tue Dec 3 22:22:32 2002
Name:Neha
City, Country:Agra, India
Your Views:Veeru-Sunny Deol
Jai-Ajay Devgan
Basanti-Shilpa Shetty
Thakur Baldev Singh-Jackie Shroff
Gabbar Singh-Ashutosh Rana
Jaya Bachchan's role-Raveena Tandon
Music-Ismail Darbar
Background Score-Sandy Chowta
Scriptwriter-Neeraj Pathak
Director-Sanjay Leela Bhansali
Tue Dec 3 22:22:51 2002
Name:Mahesh
City, Country:USA
Your Views:veeru - Sunny Deol
Jai - Hrithik
Basanti - Madhuri
Gabbar - Vivek Oberoy
Thakur - Anil Kapoor
Jaya Bhaduri - Tabu
Tue Dec 3 22:23:33 2002
Name:sunil prasanth
City, Country:hyderabad, india
Your Views:according to me jai's character is the toughest in the movie, and shahrukh khan suits best. in veeru's character akshay fits perfect.
though juhi is out of the rat race there is no better option for basanti other than juhi..she is the best.
gabbar singh's character is ashuthosh rana
Tue Dec 3 22:24:03 2002
Name:bharat
City, Country:chennai,India
Your Views:Jai: Amir Khan
Veeru: Hritik Roshan
Gabbar: Jackie Shroff
Basanti: Tabbu
Tue Dec 3 22:25:57 2002
Name:Ramesh Ramakrishnan
City, Country:Fremont, USA
Your Views:Ajay Devgan for Veeru, Sunny Deol for Viru, Kajol for Jaya, Gabbar: Ashutosh Rana Basanthi: Karishma Kapoor
Tue Dec 3 22:26:20 2002
Name:Amish Thakur
City, Country:Mumbai, India
Your Views:Jai - Akshay Kumar
veeru - Fardeen Khan
Basanti - Aishwarya Rai
widow - Amisha Patel
Thakur - Amitabh Bachchan
Gabbar - Nana Patekar
Director - Sanjay Leela Bhansali
Music - A R Rehman
Tue Dec 3 22:29:05 2002
Name:shyamsiyer
City, Country:chennai
Your Views:sunny deol as jai
shahrukh khan as vijay
madhuri as basanti
Tue Dec 3 22:30:22 2002
Name:sanjeev chopra
City, Country:New Delhi,India
Your Views:1. Jai could be Sanjay Dutt.
2. Veeru could be Govinda.
3. Basanti could be played by Karisma kapoor.
4. Gabbar Singh by Paresh Rawal.
5.Thakur could be played by Kader Khan.
5.Soorma Bhopali by Jonny Leaver.
6.Directed by David Dhawan.
7. Music by Anu Malik.
8.Script Writer Suraj Sanim.
9.Asrani's role by Satish Kaushik.
10. Kalia's role by Ashok Saraf.
Tue Dec 3 22:30:29 2002
Name:Sarosh Mir
City, Country:USA
Your Views:Abhishek Bachan - Jai
Preity Zenta- Basanti
Bobby Deol- Veeru
Shahrukh Khan-Gabbar Singh
Naseeruddin Shah- Thakur
Tabu-Jaya Bahaduri
Tue Dec 3 22:31:25 2002
Name:Varoon P. Anand
City, Country:Panama
Your Views:Amitabh Bachchan: Abhishek Bachchan or Ajay Devgan
Dharmendra: 1 Salman Khan or Govinda
Sanjeev Kumar: Naseeruddin Shah
Hema Malini: Aishwarya Rai
Jaya Bhaduri: Sushmita Sen or Rani Mukherjee
Amjad Khan: Nana Patekar or Sanjay Dutt
Sachin: Sonu Nigam
Jagdeep: Johnny Lever
Asrani: Paresh Rawal
Tue Dec 3 22:34:37 2002
Name:Vinod
City, Country:USA
Your Views:First off, it's stuff to think of replacements for AB, Amjad Khan, and Dharamendra.
For the part of Jai, I would pick Ajay Devgun. He has that intensity that could come close to AB's sterling performance.
For Veeru, that maybe tough. Veeru was tough, romantic, and funny. SRK and Hritik don't fit the bill. I would probably pick Akshay Kumar.
For Basanti, Madhuri would be perfect. A close 2nd is Sri Devi or Kajol.
For Thakur, people would say AB, since his age would fit the role. But that role was so limited, it's an insult to AB. I would pick Kadar Khan, the master of dialogues.
And for Gabbar Singh, I would go with Gulshan Grover. He has that natural evil look.
Amrish Puri is a natural choice, but Gabbar wasn't old, so he might not be a good choice. But let's be honest, there's only one Gabbar Singh.
Tue Dec 3 22:36:41 2002
Name:Sanjeevani Sharma
City, Country:USA
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Salman Khan
Basanti: Aishwarya Rai
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Music Director: A R Rehman
Sriptwriter: Gulzar
Director: Shekhar Kapoor
Tue Dec 3 22:37:16 2002
Name:Prashant Bhatia
City, Country:Nottingham , UK
Your Views:Vivek oberoi- Veeru
Arjun Rampal- Jai
Preity zinta - basanti
Amitabh Bachchan - Thakur
Atul Kulkarni- Gabbar singh
Amisha Patel- Radha
Music Director - Anu Malik
Tue Dec 3 22:37:49 2002
Name:Krishna
City, Country:Mysore, Karnataka, India
Your Views:Jai - Abhishek Bacchan
Veeru - Akshay Kumar
Basanti - Kajol
Gabbar Singh - vivek oberoi
Tue Dec 3 23:52:44 2002
Name:Vikram
City, Country:USA
Your Views:Jai: Shah Rukh
Veeru: Saif Khan
Basanti: Preity Zinta
Imam: Hangal
Gabbar: Sanjay Kapoor
Thakur: Anil Kapoor
Wed Dec 4 00:00:06 2002
Name:aniket
City, Country:a1aniket@rediffmail.com
Your Views:i would certainly choose arjun rampal as jay, vivek oberoi as veeru, rani mukharji as basanti and jackie shroff as thakur and manoj vajpai as gabbarsingh.
though my favs are srk and ash but being persona themselves they can't fit into such "FILM OF TEAM".and i think above comb. will make wonders,for sure!!!
Wed Dec 4 00:02:11 2002
Name:Nasir
City, Country:Kuwait
Your Views:Dont even think to remake Sholay, it can not be made again, no way.It will remain the best movie ever made in india.so let it be un touched.
Wed Dec 4 00:02:24 2002
Name:sharath
City, Country:dallas,usa
Your Views:madhuri ..basanti
sharukh ..jay
aamir ...veeru
amithabh..thakur
manoj bajpai..gabbar
music..arrahman
director..ram gopal varma
Wed Dec 4 00:03:43 2002
Name:Shilpa
City, Country:USA
Your Views:Its highly impossible to recreate the magic of Sholay. Even if Ramesh Sippy tries to make Sholay again its just impossible.Never...So forget about making Sholay again.
Wed Dec 4 00:04:24 2002
Name:Anand Ramaswamy
City, Country:Kings Circle, Mumbai, India
Your Views:I would pick Sanjay Dutt as Veeru, Aamir Khan as Jai, Sayaji Shinde as Gabbar Singh, Madhuri Dixit as Basanti, Dilip Kumar as Thakur, Rani Mukherjee as Mrs.Jaya Bachchan, A.R. Rahman as Music Director and Subhash Ghai as the Director.
Wed Dec 4 00:05:29 2002
Name:sukhnayan
City, Country:Kolkata, India
Your Views:I would remake Sholay with Anil Kapoor as Jai;
Akshay Kumar as Veeru
Rani Mukherjee as Basanti
music director- A.R.Rehman
director-Subash Ghai
Wed Dec 4 00:07:27 2002
Name:Manoj Japher
City, Country:Pune, India
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shahrukh Khan
Basanti: Preity Zinta
Gabbar Singh: Sushant Singh(of Jungle Fame) or Manoj Bajpai
Music Director: A.R.Rehman
Director: Ram Gopal Varma
Wed Dec 4 00:47:36 2002
Name:arfeen sayeedi
City, Country:kingston,jamaica,(w.i)
Your Views:jai-abhishek bachchan,
veeru- bobby deol,
gabbar singh-tinu verma,
basanti-rani mukharji
Wed Dec 4 00:49:48 2002
Name:Kunal S Palwankar
City, Country:Mumbai,India
Your Views:Jai-Aamir Khan
Veeru-Sunny Deol
Basanti-Aishwarya Rai
Gabbar-AMJAD KHAN
Music Director-A.R.Rehman
Scriptwriter-Aushtosh Gowarikar
Director-Aushtosh Gowarikar
Wed Dec 4 00:53:00 2002
Name:Vinayak Hegde
City, Country:Sunnyvale, USA
Your Views:Jai : Arjun Rampal
Veeru: Vivek Oberoi
Gabbar: Srivastav
Basanti: Kareena Kapoor
Thakur: Ompuri
Thakur's daughter: Rani Mukherji
Music Director: Rehman
Scriptwriter: Khader Khan
Director: Shekhar Kapoor
Wed Dec 4 00:54:02 2002
Name:Hima
City, Country:Bangalore, india
Your Views:Saif Ali Khan - Dharmendra
Akshay Khanna - Amitab Bachhan
Preity Zinta - Hemamalini
Rani Mukherjee - Jayabhaduri
Wed Dec 4 00:54:43 2002
Name:Vimala
City, Country:B'lore, India
Your Views:Jai -- Aamir Khan
Veeru -- Shahrukh Khan
Gabbar Singh -- Ashutosh Rana
Basanti -- Madhuri Dixit
Wed Dec 4 00:56:37 2002
Name:weyanaar
City, Country:edison, usa
Your Views:jai=abhishek
veeru=hrithik
gabbar=sharukh
basanti=karina
tagore=jackie
Wed Dec 4 01:04:44 2002
Name:Sohan R Ranjan
City, Country:Silver Spring, USA
Your Views:The current lot is useless, just some skirt-chasers. Forget about any "sholay" coming ut of this bunch.
Wed Dec 4 01:06:00 2002
Name:Shariq Ahmed Tariq
City, Country:Little Rock, USA
Your Views:Jai : Ajay Devgan/Sanjay Dutt
Veeru : Shahrukh Khan/Aamir Khan
Thakur Sahab : Naseeruddin Shah/Amitabh Bachan
Gabbar Singh : Nana Patekar
Basanti : Kajol
Radha : Tabu
Soorma Bhopali: Johnny Lever
Wed Dec 4 01:06:01 2002
Wed Dec 4 01:09:55 2002
Name:Kamal
City, Country:Hindustan
Your Views:Jai : Ajay Devgan
Veeru : Sunny Deol
Basanti: Madhuri Dixit
Gabbar : Ashish Vidyarthi
Thakur : Amitabh Bachhan
Script Writer : Javed Akhtar
Music Director: A R Rehman
Director : J P Dutta
Wed Dec 4 01:10:00 2002
Name:Dilip Razdan
City, Country:USA
Your Views:jai-abhishek bachchan
veeru-bobby deol
basanti-preeti zinta
gabbar singh-vivek riaz
Wed Dec 4 01:16:16 2002
Name:rAJ
City, Country:bOSTON, U.S.A.
Your Views:AAMIR KHAN AS DHARMENDRA,
HRITIK ROSHAN AS AMITABH,
NASEERUDDIN SHAH AS SANJEEV KUMAR
ATUL KULKARNI AS GABBAR
KAJOL AS BASANTI
RANI MUKHERJEE AS JAYA BHADURI
Wed Dec 4 01:19:43 2002
Name:Irfan Makki
City, Country:Toronto, Canada
Your Views:Director: Ram Gopal Verma
Jai: Salman Khan
Veeru: Shahrukh Khan
Basanti: Priety Zinta
Thakur(Sanjeev Kumar): Jackei Shroff
Jaya Bachan's role: Aishwarya Rai
Gabbar: Ajay Devgan
Script Writer: Salim Khan
Music Director: Himesh Reshammiya
Wed Dec 4 01:20:21 2002
Name:PARVEZ
City, Country:TYLER USA
Your Views:SALMAN KHAN AS DHARMENDRA
SHAHRUKH KHAN AS AMITABH
AISHVARYA RAI AS HEMA MALINI
AMRISHPURI AS GABBAR
Wed Dec 4 01:21:57 2002
Name:Mushtaq
City, Country:houston, usa
Your Views:Jai : Akshay kumar
veeru: Sunil shetty
Basanti: Sonali Bendre
Gabbar singh: Paresh rawal
music director: anand-miling
scriptwriter: javed akhtar
director: Abbas-Mastan
Wed Dec 4 01:23:45 2002
Name:Praveen
City, Country:LA
Your Views:Jai : Abhishek Bachchan
Veeru : Fardeen Khan
Gabbar Singh : Shakti Kapoor
Basanti : Urmila
Music : Anu Malik
Script : Javed Akhtar
Direction Ram Gopal Verma
Wed Dec 4 01:24:37 2002
Name:Sanjana
City, Country:San Francisco, USA
Your Views:Jai-Anil Kapoor
Veeru-Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti-Kajol
Wed Dec 4 01:28:54 2002
Name:SUBRAHMANYAM
City, Country:HYDERABAD,INDIA
Your Views:SANJAYDUTT AS JAI.
SUNNYDEOL AS VEERU.
BASANTHI AS MADHURIDIXIT.
GABBARSINGH AS AMRISHPURI.
MUSICDIRECTOR AS ANNUMALIK.
SCRIPTWRITER AS JAVADATHAR.
DIRECTOR AS MAHESHMANJEKAR.
Wed Dec 4 01:31:15 2002
Name:ali
City, Country:riyadh, saudi arabia
Your Views:jai- fardeen khan / akshaye khanna
veeru- hrithik roshan
basanti-sushmita sen
gabar singh- danny
jayabhaduris role- kajol
Wed Dec 4 01:32:54 2002
Name:Trisha Savalia
City, Country:USA
Your Views:Veeru: Bobby Deol
Jai: Abhishek Bacchan
Basanti: Esha Deol (who cares for incest)
Jaya's role: Karishma (Kapoor nay Bacchan?)
Gabbar: Atul Kulkarni
Sanjeev Kumar's role: Mohanlal
Asrani's role: Johny Lever (he'd probably say, VPSingh, Laloo Prasad ke zamane ka jailor hain)
Music Director: Maestro Ilaya Raja
Director: Ram Gopal Varma
Wed Dec 4 01:34:33 2002
Name:Kimaya Manan
City, Country:Santa Barbara, USA
Your Views:Veeru: Aamir Khan
Jai: Ajay Devgan
Basanti: Madhuri Dixit
Radha: Aishwarya Rai
Thakur: Amitabh Bachchan
Gabbar: Ashutosh Rana
Music Director: Jatin Lalit
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Having said that, I don't think anybody should attempt to remake Sholay. Nobody could ever measure up to the standard set by this all-time great movie.
Wed Dec 4 01:38:49 2002
Name:Thomas
City, Country:USA
Your Views:Nobody can replace the original cast. Probably Johnny Leer in place of Asrani.
Wed Dec 4 01:40:55 2002
Name:Jignesh
City, Country:Pittsburgh,USA
Your Views:Jai - Abhishek Bacchan
Veeru - Govinda
Gabbar - Ashutosh Rana
Basanti - Kajol
Thakur - Manoj Bajpai
Director - Rajkumar Santoshi
script - Javed Akhtar
Music - A.R.Rahman
Lyrics - Anand Bakshi.
Wed Dec 4 01:45:39 2002
Name:seema
City, Country:mumbai india
Your Views:abhishek bachchan to play role of jai .
Wed Dec 4 01:49:16 2002
Name:naveen
City, Country:San Francisco,USA
Your Views:Jai: Arjun Ramphal
Veeru: Abhishek Bachan
Gabbar:Paresh Rawal
Basanti:Aishwarya rai
Thakur: Amitabh Bachan
Music: A.R.Rahman
Script: Ram gopal varma
Director: Sanjay leela bansali
Wed Dec 4 01:51:57 2002
Name:Sonali Tamhane
City, Country:Philadelphia, USA
Your Views:I wouldn't want to change a thing about Sholay. It's an epic which has been etched on peoples souls. So when people watch it with another cast they are definitely going to compare them with the original cast and that wouldn't be fair to the new cast, cause no matter how much ever they work hard, they will never be able to match upto the original cast. And that's the reason that makes Sholay,well "SHOLAY"!!
Wed Dec 4 02:00:11 2002
Name:Siddharth
City, Country:Pittsburgh, USA
Your Views:Jai: Akshay Kumar
Veeru: Aamir Khan
Gabbar: Ashutosh Rana
Basanti: Aishwarya Rai
Music Director: A.R.Rahman
Director: Shekhar Kapur
Wed Dec 4 02:53:11 2002
Name:Alekh
City, Country:Atlanta, GA
Your Views:Sanjeev Kumar - Manoj Bajpai
Hema Malini - Kajol
Dharmendra - Vivek Oberoi
Amitabh Bachchan - Arjun Ramphal
Jaya Bhaduri - Aishwarya Rai
Amjad Khan - Rahul Dev
Wed Dec 4 03:01:36 2002
Name:Kaushik Biswas
City, Country:Dresden,Germany
Your Views:Jai:Ajay Devgan.
Veeru:Amir Khan/Shahrukh Khan
Basanti:aisharya
Gabbar singh:Manoj Bajpai/Asutosh Rana
Music Director:Anu Malik
Scriptwriter:Javed Akhter and I would like Mr.Ram Gopal Verma as the director... But obviously I would not finance this film.
I can not take the risk of making Sholay again.
Wed Dec 4 03:05:24 2002
Name:Vaseeharan
City, Country:New York
Your Views:Jai : Sanjay Dutt
Veeru : Sunny Deol
Basanti : Urmila Matondkar
Widow : Tabu
Thakur: Jackie shroff
Gabbar: Rahul Dev
Music : A.R.Rehman
Director: Subhash Ghai
Wed Dec 4 03:06:48 2002
Name:Deepak
City, Country:Pune, India
Your Views:CLASSICS CAN NEVER BE RE-CREATED.
Wed Dec 4 03:10:08 2002
Name:Sumeet
City, Country:N.Delhi, India
Your Views:Jai - Ajay Devgan,
Veeru - Govinda,Bobby Deol
Basanti - Kajol, Amisha Patel
Thakur - Sanjay Dutt,
Jackie Shroff
Gabbar - Vivek Oberoi,
Jailor - Anupam Kher,
Surma Bhopali - KNPH mein Hrithik Roshan kaa dost("lay lee jeeyey naa SIR"),
and i am sure that A.K. Hungal is still alive to do his own role since he has been old since the age of 20..
Wed Dec 4 03:10:11 2002
Name:Yogesh Minglani
City, Country:atlanta, usa
Your Views:none of the current aactors can match Amitabh, Dharmendra, Sanjeev Kumar or Amjad Khan
Wed Dec 4 03:11:10 2002
Name:Janani Sairam
City, Country:Mississauga, ON, CANADA
Your Views:Jai - Ajay Devgun
Veeru - Shahrukh Khan
Gabbar Singh - Danny Denzgonpa
Basanti - Juhi Chawla
Jaya Bhaduri - Kajol
Sanjeev Kumar's role - Suresh Oberoi
Music Director - Bappi Lahiri
Scriptwriter - Honey Irani
Director - Mahesh Manjrekar
Wed Dec 4 03:11:36 2002
Name:Sam
City, Country:Delhi, India
Your Views:Veeru - Sanjay Dutt
Jai - Akshay Kumar (or Aamir Khan)
Thakur - Amitabh Bachchan
Gabbar - Nana Patekar
Basanti - Rani Mukherji (or Preiti Zinta)
Music Director - Sandeep Chowta (or Rehmaan)
Director - Shekhar Kapur
Wed Dec 4 03:18:27 2002
Name:Partha
City, Country:Birmingham, USA
Your Views:Jai:Ajay Devgan
Veeru:Shah Rukh Khan
Gabbar:Nana Patekar
Basanti:Shilpa Shetty
Wed Dec 4 03:22:58 2002
Name:arun
City, Country:mumbai,india
Your Views:Vivek Oberoi as veeru ,and hritik as jai, preity zinta as basanti, rani as radha, amir khan as thakur and manoj bajpai as gabbar and a.r.rahman should do the music ,ram gopal verma should write the script and abbas-mastan should direct the film
Wed Dec 4 03:25:49 2002
Name:Prasad
City, Country:SF, USA.
Your Views:Jai(Amitabh): Vivek Oberoi/Abhishek
Viru(Dharmendra): Govinda
Basanti: Preity Zinta/Madhuri
Thakur: Amitabh Bachchan
Gabbar: Manoj Bajpai
Surma Bhopali: Johnny Lever
Director: Subhash Ghai/Ramgopal Varma or Rakesh Mehra
Wed Dec 4 04:08:52 2002
Name:Maya Machindra
City, Country:Ooty, India
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti: Karisma Kapoor
Widow: Tabu
Thakur: Paresh Rawal
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Samba: Rajpal Yadav
Lyrics: Javed Akhtar
Screenwriter: Farhan Akhtar
Music: A.R. Rahmna
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Wed Dec 4 04:10:09 2002
Name:Geeta Ardhanjali
City, Country:Houston, USA
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti: Karisma Kapoor
Widow: Tabu
Thakur: Paresh Rawal
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Samba: Rajpal Yadav
Lyrics: Javed Akhtar
Screenwriter: Farhan Akhtar
Music: A.R. Rahmna
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Wed Dec 4 04:10:31 2002
Name:Daboo Popatia
City, Country:Los Angeles, USA
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti: Karisma Kapoor
Widow: Tabu
Thakur: Paresh Rawal
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Samba: Rajpal Yadav
Lyrics: Javed Akhtar
Screenwriter: Farhan Akhtar
Music: A.R. Rahmna
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Wed Dec 4 04:10:50 2002
Name:Sonya Porbander
City, Country:Atlanta, USA
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti: Karisma Kapoor
Widow: Tabu
Thakur: Paresh Rawal
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Samba: Rajpal Yadav
Lyrics: Javed Akhtar
Screenwriter: Farhan Akhtar
Music: A.R. Rahmna
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Wed Dec 4 04:11:09 2002
Name:Rajguru Poonawala
City, Country:Agra, India
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti: Karisma Kapoor
Widow: Tabu
Thakur: Paresh Rawal
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Samba: Rajpal Yadav
Lyrics: Javed Akhtar
Screenwriter: Farhan Akhtar
Music: A.R. Rahmna
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Wed Dec 4 04:11:37 2002
Name:Akhtar Jahangir
City, Country:Islamabad, India
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti: Karisma Kapoor
Widow: Tabu
Thakur: Paresh Rawal
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Samba: Rajpal Yadav
Lyrics: Javed Akhtar
Screenwriter: Farhan Akhtar
Music: A.R. Rahmna
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Wed Dec 4 04:11:55 2002
Name:shambhu
City, Country:NY, USA
Your Views:Jai - Abhishek
Viru - Bobby Deol
Basanti -Prety Zinta
Gabbar - Vivek Oberoi
Wed Dec 4 04:12:19 2002
Name:Khoche Pathan Puttar
City, Country:Kabul, Afghanistan
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti: Karisma Kapoor
Widow: Tabu
Thakur: Paresh Rawal
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Samba: Rajpal Yadav
Lyrics: Javed Akhtar
Screenwriter: Farhan Akhtar
Music: A.R. Rahmna
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Wed Dec 4 04:13:13 2002
Name:Rana Jung Bahadur
City, Country:Bombay, India
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti: Karisma Kapoor
Widow: Tabu
Thakur: Paresh Rawal
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Samba: Rajpal Yadav
Lyrics: Javed Akhtar
Screenwriter: Farhan Akhtar
Music: A.R. Rahmna
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Wed Dec 4 04:13:26 2002
Name:Daulat Khanum
City, Country:Bombay, India
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti: Karisma Kapoor
Widow: Tabu
Thakur: Paresh Rawal
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Samba: Rajpal Yadav
Lyrics: Javed Akhtar
Screenwriter: Farhan Akhtar
Music: A.R. Rahmna
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Wed Dec 4 04:13:40 2002
Name:Indira Veer
City, Country:Lucknow, India
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti: Karisma Kapoor
Widow: Tabu
Thakur: Paresh Rawal
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Samba: Rajpal Yadav
Lyrics: Javed Akhtar
Screenwriter: Farhan Akhtar
Music: A.R. Rahmna
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Wed Dec 4 04:13:58 2002
Name:Naila Moosa
City, Country:Srinagar, India
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti: Karisma Kapoor
Widow: Tabu
Thakur: Paresh Rawal
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Samba: Rajpal Yadav
Lyrics: Javed Akhtar
Screenwriter: Farhan Akhtar
Music: A.R. Rahmna
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Wed Dec 4 04:14:07 2002
Name:Salman Ahmed
City, Country:Srinagar, India
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti: Karisma Kapoor
Widow: Tabu
Thakur: Paresh Rawal
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Samba: Rajpal Yadav
Lyrics: Javed Akhtar
Screenwriter: Farhan Akhtar
Music: A.R. Rahmna
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Wed Dec 4 04:14:21 2002
Name:Zubair Premji
City, Country:Calcutta, India
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti: Karisma Kapoor
Widow: Tabu
Thakur: Paresh Rawal
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Samba: Rajpal Yadav
Lyrics: Javed Akhtar
Screenwriter: Farhan Akhtar
Music: A.R. Rahmna
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Wed Dec 4 04:14:39 2002
Name:Chintak Gandhi
City, Country:Rajkot, India
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti: Karisma Kapoor
Widow: Tabu
Thakur: Paresh Rawal
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Samba: Rajpal Yadav
Lyrics: Javed Akhtar
Screenwriter: Farhan Akhtar
Music: A.R. Rahmna
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Wed Dec 4 04:15:00 2002
Name:Habib Raawat
City, Country:Denver, USA
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti: Karisma Kapoor
Widow: Tabu
Thakur: Paresh Rawal
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Samba: Rajpal Yadav
Lyrics: Javed Akhtar
Screenwriter: Farhan Akhtar
Music: A.R. Rahmna
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Wed Dec 4 04:15:19 2002
Name:John Abraham
City, Country:Bombay, USA
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti: Karisma Kapoor
Widow: Tabu
Thakur: Paresh Rawal
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Samba: Rajpal Yadav
Lyrics: Javed Akhtar
Screenwriter: Farhan Akhtar
Music: A.R. Rahmna
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Wed Dec 4 04:15:39 2002
Name:Abhishek Dorangi
City, Country:Bombay, India
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti: Karisma Kapoor
Widow: Tabu
Thakur: Paresh Rawal
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Samba: Rajpal Yadav
Lyrics: Javed Akhtar
Screenwriter: Farhan Akhtar
Music: A.R. Rahmna
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Wed Dec 4 04:16:19 2002
Name:Vijay
City, Country:Los Angeles, USA
Your Views:No one could ever re-make Sholay. It is the most significant and defining Indian film ever made and no numbnut like Hrithik Roshan or Vivek Oberoi could ever play Veeru or Jai. Besides, Sholay is nothing without Gabbar Singh and Gabbar Singh belongs to Amjad Khan. Without him, there is no question of a Sholay re-make...even for fun!
Wed Dec 4 04:16:19 2002
Name:Lalita Raj Thakur
City, Country:Mount Abu, India
Your Views:Jai: Aamir Khan
Veeru: Shah Rukh Khan
Basanti: Karisma Kapoor
Widow: Tabu
Thakur: Paresh Rawal
Gabbar Singh: Ashutosh Rana
Samba: Rajpal Yadav
Lyrics: Javed Akhtar
Screenwriter: Farhan Akhtar
Music: A.R. Rahmna
Director: Ashutosh Gowariker
Wed Dec 4 04:16:59 2002
Name:Prabhu
City, Country:Stillwater,USA
Your Views:AB - Vivek Oberoi
Dharmendra - Hrithik
Hemamalini - Priety Zinta
Jaya Bachan - Sonali Kulkarni