|Rediff India Abroad Home | All the sections|
Health is exclusive wealth
March 19, 2009
No such doubts assail India yet, in part because the public sector continues to dominate significant sections of the economy (oil, power, roads and so on) but also because the cash-strapped government needs to rely on it for future investments.
Given the way India's public sector companies are forced to function by their major shareholder, the government, it may appear sensible to leave larger parts of the economy to private sector investment.
Privatised physical infrastructure is one thing. Growing private involvement in social infrastructure is quite another, and governments certainly need to worry when the private sector starts filling in the spaces left by public investment in education, healthcare and so on.
More worrying, perhaps, is the aggressive expansion of the private sector in the healthcare space as demonstrated by the rise of corporate hospital chains such as Apollo, Fortis, Wockhardt and scores of others.
The big problem is that the benefits of this development are largely exclusionary. It is no coincidence that the rise of the big hospital chains has been concurrent with rising incomes of India's middle class and rich.
As a result, in India we have the ability to deliver such cost-effective, world-class medical knowhow that patients from developed economies now visit this country for treatment (an episode from the legal series Boston Public was even centred on this trend).
Yet the majority of India's population remains excluded from these huge leaps in medical knowhow and delivery systems. Despite state and central governments' attempts to attract private investment in healthcare, India has just nine beds and seven physicians per 10,000 people. In other words, rising private investment in healthcare is not making India healthier.
These anomalies were highlighted in a perceptive essay "The Indian Corporate Hospitals: Touching Middle Class Lives" by Bertrand Lefebvre in which he argues that, "the corporate hospital can be read as an enacted utopia for the Indian middle class, as a monument dedicated to consumerism in the realm of healthcare".
Lefebvre shows how these hospitals are basically a business like any other - from the way they are promoted (slick brochures and ad copy) to their location and the corporate culture within.
Certainly, the overtly five-star environment in these hospitals, from the d�cor to staff attitude, is sufficiently intimidating for "economically weaker" people to even consider approaching.
Ironically, healthcare remains a robust business even in the downturn. As a report in Business Standard showed, realtors and manufacturers are slashing investment but corporate hospital chains are collectively investing over Rs 2,500 crore (Rs 25 billion) in expansion plans, mainly driven, several chief executives said, by rising demand and easier availability of medical insurance (again from the private sector).
To be fair, the problem of inadequate healthcare does not lie with these hospitals themselves but in the manner in which they have been allowed to function by the government.
If India needs a sustainable "bailout", it's not in fussy excise cuts or "packages" for certain sectors of the economy or even in an expensive employment guarantee scheme but in more efficient healthcare delivery in which the profit motive is dovetailed with public good.
More Guest Columns