|Rediff India Abroad Home | All the sections|
Slumdog unrealistic, says Rushdie
February 25, 2009 14:42 IST
Slumdog Millionaire may have waltzed through Oscars with eight trophies but that does not make it a favourite with India born author Salman Rushdie [Images], who has dismissed it for being unrealistic.
The Booker prize winning author dismissed the film publicly in a speech at Altanta's Emory University, saying it "piles impossibility on impossibility". The writer called the book and movie nothing more than "feel-good" and complained about various portions of the story.
Rushdie, who is famous as the master of 'magic realism' also differed with Slumdog Millionaire [Images] director Danny Boyle [Images] that the film was a realistic portrayal of Mumbai [Images]. The 61-year-old author said several scenes in the film were beyond explanation.
The other two Oscar favourite films The Reader and The Curious Case of Benjamin Button also failed to impress the writer, the examiner.com reported.
"I have to be honest the film didn't work for me but I am happy people are liking it...I find somethings shown in the film are very over the top but that's my personal response," Aamir had said recently.