Clarke has to run his own team: Boycott
Former England batsman Geoffrey Boycott criticised Australian coach Mickey Arthur for treating the players like "school children" and said he finds the idea of setting the cricketers written tasks as "childlike".
Australia had sacked four players, including vice-captain Shane Watson, for the third Test against India after the cricketers failed to prepare a three-point presentation on how they could improve the team's performance following their defeats in Chennai and Hyderabad in the first two Tests.
Boycott said Arthur could have spoken to the players in private rather than behaving like a "teacher".
"It's like being schoolchildren and giving them something to do and if they don't do it, then just slapping them. If you feel that there is an area where they should improve, surely it is up to the coaching staff and the major coach himself, Arthur, to talk to them in private," he said.
"I always thought that's what a coach's job was. I don't like the coach-manager - you're like a teacher," Boycott told Cricinfo.
Image: Geoffrey Boycott
'In the end, they have to perform'
The 72-year-old former cricketer said as a coach, he would have tried to help the players with a friendly chat rather than asking them to prepare presentations.
"I would never play around with their technique or anything, but I would talk to them, I would watch them, and I would give them a bit of advice as to where they might improve. I would think that was my job," he said.
"And if I needed to talk to them about the mental attitude to batting and bowling, that again is my job through my experience and my maturity. But I don't think I should be setting them paper exams to ask them to write down what they think", he said.
"I think it's man to man, where the coach sits and talks privately to the players, saying, "Listen, I'm here to help you. What do you think? This is what I think.
"In the end, they have to perform, they have to make runs, batting and bowling, to stay in the team or help the team. That is really the crux. I don't like this business of setting them tasks which are very childlike," Boycott said.
Image: James Pattinson
'You've just got to be sensible and professional'
The former Yorkshire skipper felt as a captain it was important to be sensible and professional and said if he were in Clarke's shoes, he would have handled the issue differently.
"Clarke has to run his own team, that's what captains do when they're in charge. But it wouldn't be the way I would run it, put it that way. I've played under a lot of good captains. Michael Vaughan was a good captain, Brian Close, Mike Brearley, Ray Illingworth - the great thing they all had in common was to treat people like adults," Boycott said.
"In the end, you've just got to be sensible and professional. Some guys like to go out and switch off by having a few beers ... Everybody is different.
"As long as you get some sleep, and you're ready to play ... I'm sorry, anything else is very childish and it wouldn't be the way I would do it," he added.
Image: Michael Clarke
Problems should have been nipped in the bud
Boycott said if the decision was taken because of a series of such incidents as mentioned by Clarke then those issues should have been sorted out earlier.
"Clarke had said that it was building up for some time. Now that would worry me, because that says to me there's been other things going on.
"It's not just setting them a task, to fill in a form and say where they can improve their batting and bowling, that there are other things that are going on.
"If there have been other things, then it should have been nipped in the bud before it got to the point where this is the last straw," he added.
Image: Michael Clarke and Coach Mickey Arthur