rediff.com

NewsApp (Free)

Read news as it happens
Download NewsApp

Available on  

Rediff News  All News 
Rediff.com  » Cricket » Pietersen and Siddle play down Broad controversy

Pietersen and Siddle play down Broad controversy

Last updated on: July 13, 2013 11:46 IST

Pietersen and Siddle play down Broad controversy

     Next

Next

A controversial incident involving England's Stuart Broad was played down by players from both sides after a gripping third day of the first Ashes Test at Trent Bridge on Friday.

The blond all-rounder edged spinner Ashton Agar on to the gloves of wicketkeeper Brad Haddin and through to Michael Clarke at slip but, with the Australian players celebrating, umpire Aleem Dar did not raise his finger.

Broad refused to "walk", leaving the Australian players shaking their heads in disbelief and sparking a huge debate on Twitter about the spirit of cricket.

England batsman Kevin Pietersen said his team mate was within his rights not to "walk".

"Each and every player at every level of the game has the opportunity to wait for the umpire's decision," Pietersen told a news conference after England ended the day on 326 for six in their second innings, an overall lead of 261 runs.

"Aleem Dar is a fantastic umpire. We play our cricket hard and fair."


Image: The Australian players look on after Umpire Aleem Dar turned down an appeal against Stuart Broad of England during day three of the 1st Investec Ashes Test match between England and Australia at Trent Bridge Cricket Ground
Photographs: Ryan Pierse/Getty Images

     Next

'It's the umpire's decision'

Prev     Next
Prev

Next

Australia were unable to send the decision to the third umpire because they had used up their two referrals but fast bowler Peter Siddle said they were not feeling frustrated.

"You have to use referrals when you think you have a chance of taking wickets," he said. "You can't just keep them in your pocket in case you get one later in the game."

Siddle, who has taken six wickets in the match, was philosophical about the incident.

"At the end of the day it's the umpire's decision," he said. "It's hard out there for players and umpires.

"It is just part of the game and you can't be blaming anyone. There wasn't a big deal made of it by us."


Image: Australia's Ashton Agar celebrates after England's Stuart Broad edged the ball to Michael Clarke but umpire Aleem Dar gave it not out during the first Ashes cricket test match at Trent Bridge cricket ground in Nottingham
Photographs: Philip Brown/Reuters

Prev     Next

'Looking at the replays Broad doesn't look comfortable to me'

Prev     Next
Prev

Next

Pietersen said it had not even been discussed in the England dressing room.

"We are only worried about the lead we have and are fully focused on winning this Test match," said Pietersen who hit 64 before Broad (47) and Ian Bell (95) shared an unbroken seventh-wicket partnership of 108.

The Broad incident raised concerns about relations between the teams for the remainder of the five-match series.

"I do hope this doesn't set the tone for the rest of the series," said BBC radio commentator Jonathan Agnew. "Looking at the replays Broad doesn't look comfortable to me.

"He looks like a boy who has been sent into the corner in disgrace. There will be questions about how England play the game."


Image: Stuart Broad of England hits out during day three of the 1st Investec Ashes Test match between England and Australia at Trent Bridge Cricket Ground
Photographs: Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images

Prev     Next

'It's up to the umpire to give you out'

Prev     More
Prev

More

Most commentators blamed Dar's poor decision, rather than levelling criticism at the England player.

"There is no debate, it's quite simple," former England batsman Geoffrey Boycott told the BBC.

"The Australians I have played with and have watched, with the exception of Adam Gilchrist, believe in staying (at the crease) and it's up to the umpire to give you out - there shouldn't be a moral argument.

"They should be upset, disappointed and angered by the umpires," Boycott added. "If they keep making poor decisions it's up to the ICC (International Cricket Council) to do something about it."

Former Australia fast bowler Glenn McGrath agreed.

"To me it has to be the umpire," he said. "A player is allowed to stand his ground.

"If Australia had one appeal left Broad would have walked. The fact there was no referral left, he left it up to the umpire."


Image: Phil Hughes, Michael Clarke, Ed Cowan and wicketkeeper Brad Haddin appeal unsuccessfully for the wicket of Stuart Broad
Photographs: Laurence Griffiths/Getty Images

Prev     More
Source:
© Copyright 2014 Reuters Limited. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of Reuters content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent of Reuters. Reuters shall not be liable for any errors or delays in the content, or for any actions taken in reliance thereon.