rediff.com

NewsApp (Free)

Read news as it happens
Download NewsApp

Available on  

Rediff News  All News 
Rediff.com  » Cricket » Ponting should have been suspended: Chappell

Ponting should have been suspended: Chappell

December 28, 2010 12:34 IST

Former captain Ian Chappell is of the view that current Australia skipper Ricky Ponting should have been suspended instead of just being docked 40 per cent of his match fee for the ugly confrontation he had with the umpires in the fourth Ashes Test against England at the MCG on Monday.

- Scorecard

With his team struggling on the field, Ponting remonstrate with umpire Aleem Dar, pointing his finger at the Pakistani umpire after it was adjudicated that Kevin Pietersen did not edge the ball for a caught behind decision.

Ponting turned his attention to the square leg umpire, Tony Hill, as a group of Australian players crowded Dar.

Video umpire Marais Erasmus gave Pietersen not out after a hot spot replay failed to show an inside edge following a half-hearted appeal referred by wicketkeeper Brad Haddin.

Peter Siddle was also involved initially as he gave Ponting verbal support, but the speedster was lucky to escape sanction.

Chappell feels Ponting's behaviour was unacceptable and he has overstepped the mark.

"When I was playing it was quite clear in the laws you could discuss a point of law but you weren't allowed to argue a point of judgment. If I was adjudicating I'd think it was a suspendable offence," Chappell said.

"And it's not like it's the first time he (Ponting) has done it. I think the ICC are in part to blame, not for him arguing today, but if you want to stop those sort of things you've got to stop them straight away, the first time it happens," Chappell was quoted as saying by The Australian.

Ponting's first captain, Mark Taylor, also believes the Australian captain harmed his reputation and that of his team by arguing with the umpires and Pietersen.

"I don't mind a bit of a confrontation between players occasionally. I think that's good for the game, but you have to draw a line (with the umpires)," said Taylor.

"It (the referral system) is in place, it's been used, it's given not out. Replays showed he wasn't out. You've just got to get on with the game. The decision came from upstairs. There's no point arguing with the umpires. They're just relaying the message.

"You've got to ask yourself what is the point of the conversation because the umpire is not going to reverse his decision, particularly when your mate upstairs has looked at the replay and maybe got it right," said Taylor.

Former England captain Tony Greig felt that Ponting crossed the line and Siddle should also have been reprimanded.

"I don't know what Peter Siddle was doing there waving his finger."

© Copyright 2013 PTI. All rights reserved. Republication or redistribution of PTI content, including by framing or similar means, is expressly prohibited without the prior written consent.